5 ms·
Pilot (piston engine, with only around 20 hours of light jet dual). As a pax on this flight, I might not have noticed much unless I was looking out the window.
by sokoloff 5y ago
Pilot (piston engine, with only around 20 hours of light jet dual). As a pax on this flight, I might not have noticed much unless I was looking out the window.
This seems like a fault of the crew (obviously), but probably more on the PNF (pilot not flying) than the PF (pilot flying). Article says 4 pilots were on board, but fails to mention that 2 of them (relief pilots) were likely not in the cockpit on the departure.
It’s hard for me to imagine that a qualified crew would fly such a non-standard departure with “we were following the flight director” as an excuse. There’s nothing above you to hit on departure; get away from terrain! Fly the calculated airspeeds. Where was the Vr callout?! That rotation to a pitch angle is what takes you off the runway, not the FD command bars.
Once they made the mistake and corrected it, I don’t have much concern with the continuation. 262 knots indicated isn’t that big of a deal that I’d worry about shedding parts from departure flaps and leading edge devices or stressing the gear (they likely pulled the gear up well before breaking 250 KIAS anyway). I’d be more concerned with the safety of an overweight landing than continuing. (A 777 can dump fuel, but the crew that just moments ago couldn’t fly an entirely routine departure isn’t the crew that I want to be calling an audible and figuring out how to safely dump fuel at night and return for a max weight landing. How would they program the FD for that?! ;) )
My prediction is that almost every pax had no idea how close to dying they came until they read about it later.
I catch heat every time I mention that air crew training and certification standards are not uniform across the globe and that I am reluctant to fly on many foreign-flag carriers. (However, Emirates and most EU-flag carriers are ones that I would not hesitate to fly on.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hindsightbias 5y agoMaximum Flap (Placard) Speeds for 777-300 Flaps KIAS 1 255 5 235 15 215 20 200 25 190 30 180 262 is way high for 30 degrees with slats.
- HeavenFox 5y agoYou don't take off with 30 degrees of flaps though, fortunately.
- sokoloff 5y agoCorrect. This was likely a flaps 15° (or maybe 20°) departure (being a heavy departure).
- dylan604 5y ago262 is still too high for either of those flap positions according to the above list. So while you may be correct with your comment, it is pretty much without point??? Edit: At least for the topic of this discussion. However, I'll now be able to win a bar bet when someone aks what flaps position for a heavy take off of a 777 would be
- sokoloff 5y agoSure. The question becomes "given an airplane that's had a limit airspeed exceeded by about 22% (so aerodynamic loads typically less than 1.5x the placarded limit), what's then the safest course of action for a crew who just minutes ago demonstrated that they were incapable to perform an uncomplicated, utterly standard takeoff procedure?" Do you want them declaring an emergency, dumping fuel, flying around at night, and coming back for a max weight emergency landing? Or do you want them continuing the flight, sending someone back with a flashlight to look over the wing trailing edge, and continuing on as normally as possible to DC? If my butt or a family member's butt is on that airplane, I don't want these yoke holders trying to figure out and execute the emergency procedure after flunking the standard day one of flight school procedure, while flustered from almost milking themselves, and knowing that they’re looking for a job in the new year. Take a few hours; paint a magenta line all the way to DC and fly it.
- vultour 5y agoThe 777 has a flap load relief system and should retract the flaps at 216 knots. Don't know if it works this early during takeoff.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dataflow 5y ago> I catch heat every time I mention that air crew training and certification standards are not uniform across the globe and that I am reluctant to fly on many foreign-flag carriers. (However, Emirates and most EU-flag carriers are ones that I would not hesitate to fly on.) Has anyone made some sort of a rough list of which carriers one can feel safe on?
- jdavis703 5y agoI’m probably going to get downvoted for this, but focus on large, legacy airlines based in countries that have a long safety record (not just in terms of crashes, but also just general approach to safety).
- afr0ck 5y agoI agree. I would nominate Delta Airlines, British Airways and Lufthansa to be the top safest carriers in the world.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThis is the list of airlines banned from flying into the EU on safety grounds. https://transport.ec.europa.eu/transport-themes/eu-air-safety-list_en https://transport.ec.europa.eu/transport-themes/eu-air-safet...
- Pasorrijer 5y agoMy personal list is Tier 1 US, Canadian, British and German carriers as well as Qantas. Probably throw Air France and KLM in too. In Africa, Ethiopian would be the only airline I would fly if I had to fly an African airline. I probably would have had a middle eastern airline on the list before I did a project with them last year. After that, I learned a lot that made me stick to the list above.
- ComputerGuru 5y ago> I probably would have had a middle eastern airline on the list before I did a project with them last year. Does this include One World/Star Alliance members?
- jdavis703 5y ago> My prediction is that almost every pax had no idea how close to dying they came until they read about it later. This is why you should keep the window shade open during taxi, takeoff and landing (a handful of airlines require this, but IME it’s the minority). In the event of a crash or other incident you also want to know what’s outside the plane. Maybe there is burning debris on your side, so you want to exit from the other?
- beef-supreme 5y agoI'm pretty keeping the shades up outside of cruising altitude is required.
- sokoloff 5y agoThat depends on the airline. El Al used to require them to be closed for ground operations (I assume from some I’ll-conceived “security” reason.) It’s common for daytime ops from desert airports for the cabin crew to ask you to close them at the gate to minimize heat gain on the aircraft.
- s0rce 5y agoI've routinely been asked to close them once we've landed when its hot out (mostly in hot areas of the western US).
- dvlat 5y agoI also had that impression until a flight attendant of Virgin Airlines insisted on me keeping them closed during takeoff.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoAll European airlines I've been on always required then up for takeoff and landing
- JshWright 5y ago> Article says 4 pilots were on board, but fails to mention that 2 of them (relief pilots) were likely not in the cockpit on the departure. The 777-300ER has two jump-seats in the cockpit. I believe standard practice is for the "off duty" crew to be in the cockpit, in the jump-seats, for takeoff and landing (basically, any time the "sterile cockpit" rule would apply).
- cm2187 5y agoAnd apparently they were also fired. You don’t fire someone who isn’t even in the cockpit.
- FL410 5y ago> It’s hard for me to imagine that a qualified crew would fly such a non-standard departure with “we were following the flight director” as an excuse. There’s nothing above you to hit on departure; get away from terrain! My understanding is that the 121 guys train to fly the FD and not "wing it." I think it's easier for us 91 guys to jump to the "just fly the plane" mentality. That said, still a pretty baffling situation all around, especially the seemingly lackadaisical attitude towards post-exceedance inspection.