3 ms·
Hi. Okay, I guess I shot from the hip on these comments (chalk it up to someone who's spent a few years navigating the regulatory world of online gambling). I d
by noduerme 15y ago
Hi. Okay, I guess I shot from the hip on these comments (chalk it up to someone who's spent a few years navigating the regulatory world of online gambling). I do think what you're trying to do makes for a pretty compelling proposition to games developers, and as you seem to be shouldering all the risk and cost involved, it would be difficult to refuse that kind of monetization without any research or overhead, especially the kind required to achieve the gold-standard UK license.
I do think $1.5M was a bit expensive for the license. Your T&C state: "the “Game Rules” (which are different for each Game), which explain
the specific rules of the Game and are available on our Game Rules
page [Note to the Gambling
Commission: we propose to do this in a similar way to other
operators, see for example http://casino.ladbrokes.com/en/live- http://casino.ladbrokes.com/en/live-
dealer/help and http://www.partycasino.com/games/more-games/ http://www.partycasino.com/games/more-games/.
The games (and, therefore, the rules) have not yet been finalised,
but in drafting the rules we will comply with the “Fair and open”
provisions of the Licence Conditions and Codes of Practice];"
This sounds like a pretty pricey pay-to-play for rules that aren't yet finalized (i.e. the assumption being that zero games are yet licensed on your platform). You could have done the same thing in Curacao for about $60k, or Malta for around $250k.
The question of whether there's an ecosystem like what you're describing, or whether that's something that can be astroturfed, is open, but depends on regs outside the EU and to a large extent individual jurisdictions' willingness to play ball, and the ability to move money rapidly through local payment options.
This still leaves open the question of what happens to a guy in Russia who's making money by hosting a game that's monetized through your site, with other Russian players betting on it. While the UK might have no problem with that, the Russian / Chinese / Vietnamese / Australian / Japanese / Norwegian / French / Italian / Greek / Israeli (and lots more) governments certainly do have problems with any casino that's not specifically licensed and regulated separately under their own jurisdictions. So a local developer in those markets may not be violating UK law or WTO regulations, but could still be in deep trouble with their own local law enforcement. If Her Majesty's MI6 is going to spring rebel iphone devs out of a Tajik prison for that $1.5M, then it was well worth it =)
As with all things online-gambling, there's a murkiness in the system, because one country's laws state that doing X is legal in another country, and that this license permits it. Likewise, a Costa Rican data processing company is fully within its legal rights to run gambling in the United States, as far as Costa Rican law is concerned. We know how that usually works out.
I think -- and I'm not trying to be harsh, because there may well be a market for this (although the HN crowd probably isn't hip to how or why exactly, and you'd do better on a gambling forum) -- but essentially you've prepaid for prestige by the truck-load and are hoping a market exists to rent a piece of it. It'll be interesting to see if it works. I think it's hard for any company to justify the price of a UK license w/o a huge volume in sportsbetting already coming through the door. What you're potentially tapping into here is an unknown quantity, and everything (legally) is in flux right now around the world, so it's an interesting time to try it.
I wish you the best, and apologize for coming off as rude. I've got my doubts, but look forward to seeing your progress.
- davidtyleryork 15y agoHey noduerme, Thanks for the kind words, and no worries, we love getting feedback from smart people like you because it highlights developers' potential concerns and also some issues that we should iron out in-depth answers for. So you know, we got the gold standard license is because we wanted to have the gold standard and face as little legal/regulatory issues down the road as possible. Our goal is to build a reputable, legal business that operates everywhere that gambling is legal. We have international payment providers and again, assume full responsibility for gambling, so developers have nothing to worry about, regardless of where their game is hosted and where their players are. We specifically cite that this is legal for US developers because gambling is 100% illegal in the US, so this is proof that use of our API does not violate local law. That said, the legal issues surrounding this are definitely the primary concern among developers. We've been thinking of good ways to communicate this (other than company lawyers of the developing firm, which have given their employer the all clear every time thus far). We hope that this will be alleviated to some extent as the first games built on our platform go live. We do have partners already building on our platform, such as Lucky Derby by Toy Studio. See here for more info: http://www.toystudio.com/2011/08/04/lucky-derby-coming-soon/ http://www.toystudio.com/2011/08/04/lucky-derby-coming-soon/ Thanks again for a great conversation, and definitely ping us here or via email with any more questions (I'm tyler@betable.com)
- yakto 15y ago> We specifically cite that this is legal for US developers because gambling is 100% illegal in the US, so this is proof that use of our API does not violate any law. I'm having trouble parsing that.
- davidtyleryork 15y agoI see why this could be confusing. Essentially, online gambling is 100% illegal in the US, but we are working with multiple US developers whose lawyers have confirmed that our API is legal to use. It is also important to note that players must be in a legal gambling jurisdiction to play.