2 ms·
Potato potato, as they say. It wouldn't be surprising if there was no link at all between reality and the poll. Consider as a worse case; there is a political
by roenxi 5y ago
Potato potato, as they say. It wouldn't be surprising if there was no link at all between reality and the poll.
Consider as a worse case; there is a political question with a fairly clear reality ("the legislators should legislate the value of exp(1) to be 2.5 to make life easier"). The silent majority ignores the silly poll, and the lunatics who believe this is a good idea all put in a vote because they want to promote their mad cause.
The poll could therefore be biased to be exactly wrong. May as well call it invalid data and save the time thinking about it.
- dredmorbius 5y agoOpinion polls, properly constructed and conducted, measure opinion. They do not measure any truth other than the truth of a specific opinon. Polling for the value of e is rather like polling for the piloting of a jetliner. You could certainly do it. It would end rather badly in virtually all instances.
- roenxi 5y agoThe point is the poll wouldn't be picking up the opinion of the crowd. It would be picking up the least representative sample of people; those who have an incentive for the poll to mis-represent popular opinion. I only picked exp() as an example because it can't start a political argument.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI think we're largely in agreement, if discussing different elements of the same question.
- pessimizer 5y agoHN is very representative of the type of technologists that frequent HN.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIt's the kind of thing that's very popular among those who like that sort of thing.