2 ms·
Why don't we have public peer reviews? Post the paper publicly and anyone can comment about the validity of the paper. Then if it gets accepted it gets the stam
by Jensson 5y ago
Why don't we have public peer reviews? Post the paper publicly and anyone can comment about the validity of the paper. Then if it gets accepted it gets the stamp of approval of the "journal" to publish it.
Why don't we do this already? Probably because the "journals" still calls themselves publishers, so posting the paper before it is accepted would be seen as publishing, and they want to "publish" it first. But scientific journals are no longer valuable as publishers, just for their stamp of approval, the idea that they need to be publishers is holding science back.