3 ms·
> Is your point to bring down those who have made it to the top on their own merit because you believe someone somewhere in their ancestry gave them a "massive
by lolinder 5y ago
> Is your point to bring down those who have made it to the top on their own merit because you believe someone somewhere in their ancestry gave them a "massive leg up"? How do you prove that? And even if you can prove it, what is the fault of the person who was born into privilege? Do you mean to fault them for being born into it?
No, no, and no. I'm not proposing that we should tear anyone down, nor that we should stop hiring qualified people on the grounds that they were privileged. I agree with you 100% that that would be unfair and counterproductive. What I'm arguing for is not a policy change, it's a paradigm shift.
I believe that the first step to effecting real change in generational cycles of poverty is to acknowledge that generational cycles exist at all. Wealth does not simply flow to those who have merit--merit is in most (but not all) cases a product of wealth. It's a feedback loop.
We cannot place full credit for success on the shoulders of the privileged without also placing full blame for failure on the shoulders of the downtrodden. To acknowledge and fix the generational cycles that keep people down, we have to first acknowledge and study the generational cycles that prop people up.
- KrishnaShripad 5y ago> acknowledge that generational cycles exist at all I agree with your sentiment. However, what typically happens is, when we do acknowledge the generational cycles, we have a reactionary attitude towards the issues of the past. The downtrodden feel "betrayed" while the privileged feel "guilt". At this point, you need to be able to resolve the issue in a manner in which both are not left feeling discriminated again. However, the situation is different in India. Reservation system is not the same as Affirmative Action in US. Rather, Reservation System is now practicing reverse discrimination[1] with official stamp from Government of India. [1]: https://thelogicalindian.com/story-feed/awareness/affirmative-action-the-system-of-reservations-and-quotas-in-india/ https://thelogicalindian.com/story-feed/awareness/affirmativ... So what ended up happening is that instead of giving a leg up to the downtrodden, we reversed discrimination and now discriminate on upper castes through reservation quotas while also giving a leg up to the downtrodden. Most upper castes don't complain and instead just migrate abroad for greener pastures and typically occupy high positions in Western companies. Which is also one of the reasons why Western firms have more Upper Castes as opposed to Lower Castes. Lower Castes prefer Government jobs. Government jobs have a lot of social value in India as it comes with promise of security and prestige. Especially if you get into Administrative Services.