4 ms·
Am I wrong in thinking that just because you're employee #1 (after the founder) that that doesn't make you a co-founder. I don't think it matters if the company
by pedalpete 15y ago
Am I wrong in thinking that just because you're employee #1 (after the founder) that that doesn't make you a co-founder. I don't think it matters if the company had been legally formed yet or not.
I think a co-founder is about what you do, not when you join. If Mr. Kaplan was key in strategy and envisioning the business, that would go a long way, but if he was responsible for implementing Bezos plan, I don't think he should be considered a co-founder.
- borism 15y agoIt's not like in startups founders sit in a closed room and "envision" strategy and plan, then come out and hand it over to their minions to implement. Startupping is a creative process in which all levels of company should participate, good ideas might very well have come from below ranks. He mentions he didn't get founder's stock though, so that kinda answers your question.
- binarycrusader 15y agoThe person being interviewed addresses that in his first response: “Well, you could either consider me the first employee or a co-founder depending upon how you want to think about it." So he's not claiming to be one; and if you look at the headline of the article it says "first employee".
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- gojomo 15y agoIn practice, the terms founder/cofounder/founding-employee are fuzzy and granted based on mutual agreement among those present. Every early pivot or talent-acquisition or rebranding or product launch could reasonably reset the 'founding team', if that's the spirit of the participants. To limit the term only to the person with the idea overemphasizes ideation. To limit the term only to the person who first writes checks would overemphasize finance. Something great didn't exist; a group worked together; then it did exist. We might honor the leader or original spark as 'The Founder' but all the team are also 'founders' in a reasonable, non-hagiographic sense of the word.
- rick888 15y ago"but all the team are also 'founders' in a reasonable, non-hagiographic sense of the word." I suppose, but who is taking all of the risk? A founder takes a loss if the company loses and wins when the company is profitable. An employee doesn't take a loss (in a sense that they are paid a regular salary no matter what).
- barrkel 15y agoMost early employees in startups are investing through opportunity cost - they lose out on what they could be making elsewhere, in a less risky job by taking a salary cut.
- gojomo 15y agoThat's an overgeneralization. Many big-F Founders take salaries starting at the same time as founding employees. Both are likely taking relative cash compensation cuts compared to their next-best options, and 'risking' opportunity costs. Both might forgo salary in a funding pinch or chaotic fume-out. If the big-F Founder has a richer set of post-failure options than founding employees – and gets more beneficial notoriety even in failure – they may in practice be risking less than early employees.
- rick888 15y agoSo, the founders aren't the ones that started the company then? When I say "founder" I mean the person that started the company from day 1: taking no salary in the beginning because the company wasn't making any money, taking a chance for months or even years that the company will go out of business or possibly succeed, or even working on the company during off-hours from a regular 9-5. If a company has enough capital to pay employee #1, then yes, the founder is making a salary. But, at this point, the risk is considerably less and employee #1 shouldn't be getting anywhere near the same payout if the company gets bought out. The founder also most likely has their own money tied up in the company. Employee #1 can always get unemployment if the company goes bust. The founder will have their name and business credit history tied to the company if there are major problems. Employee #1 can just go find another job as if nothing ever happened. "If the big-F Founder has a richer set of post-failure options than founding employees – and gets more beneficial notoriety even in failure" More risk=more reward. If you are employee #1 and you aren't getting paid industry or above industry rates, then you shouldn't be working at that startup. If you want all of the glory when it succeeds, then you need to start your own company. Have you ever actually started a company? It's not easy. Much more difficult (and risky) than being employee #1.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ojbyrne 15y agoSo as a thought experiment, what if Bezos gave him a spec with one sentence "Sell books online?" That's a plan.
- jvehent 15y agoNoun founder (plural founders) One who founds, establishes, and erects; one who lays a foundation; an author; one from whom something originates; one who endows. http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/founder http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/founder Whatever his title officially was, before him, there was no code. He built the foundation of amazon.com. Doesn't that make him a "founder".
- kross 15y agoI would say it is simpler in startup terms. Most founders are pre-money. If you get a full salary on your start date, you are not a founder, you are an employee (perhaps the first).
- byrneseyeview 15y agoThe first time I'd heard of him was when Paul Graham called him a de facto cofounder: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1045781 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1045781
- sidman 15y agoI guess its more about official role and what you officially register yourself as when you join the company, its really the only thing that goes down in history so no one would actually know what you do other then your official role, not the general public anyway (press, media, shareholders etc etc). After reading that whole article i find Kaphlan to be a very interesting guy. I feel i share alot of personality traits with him and from the outcome i can see where those traits has helped and worked against him in the startup world.... Might look into a few things further cause of this article :) Thanks ...