3 ms·
> but what threw people off was the blurry and dark halo surrounding that leaf which looks like manipulation artifacts. That halo is pretty clearly what's left
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> but what threw people off was the blurry and dark halo surrounding that leaf which looks like manipulation artifacts.
That halo is pretty clearly what's left of the subject's head after the phone has tried to get rid of it. It's difficult for me to understand how this wouldn't qualify as "replacing someone's head with a leaf". Sure, the leaf is there. But the head used to be there too, and in the photo it's been removed.
- nawgz 5y agoIf it’s not clear to you, the original claim probably sets critical context. The first thread was spawned by the photographer claiming there were no leaves in the foreground, and that the post processing software had picked some random background content and used that in place of a human face. Clearly, what you say is in some sense true; digital zoom and post processing have left some artifacts. To me it sort of looks like there’s another leaf on the same branch as the first. But when you are digitally zooming a tiny iPhone camera to photograph someone 50-100ft away and there’s multiple depths captured, it seems hard to imagine how the photograph would be crystal clear in that circumstance, and even further it’s crystal clear the post processing only failed to add clarity, and it certainly did not introduce a nonexistent leaf / twig / branch connected realistically as some software bug.