14 ms·
Why Brahmins lead Western firms but rarely Indian ones
- gigatexal 5y agoThe whole premise of this is stupid. The Caste system is silly. Officially it's illegal or something along those lines per Indian law but culturally it's still very much relevant. But it's old, archaic, outdated, not useful...
- phone8675309 5y ago> not useful... Its usefulness, like most things, depends where you fall along it. I'm sure those at the top find it very useful to get the things they want.
- gigatexal 5y agoAin't that the truth with things that artificially reward folks with power and status by just being born in the right place or to the right people.
- roywiggins 5y agoAmerica's race system is stupid too, but it persists anyway. https://www.npr.org/2020/08/04/898574852/its-more-than-racism-isabel-wilkerson-explains-america-s-caste-system https://www.npr.org/2020/08/04/898574852/its-more-than-racis...
- gigatexal 5y agoNot an apples to apples comparison because in your example a black person say could not marry a non-black person (just change low caste for black and higher caste for white or the other way around it still works) in the US when that's not been the case for years and years. Sure, that's true for some families and some people do think like that but on the whole culturally mixed race unions are commonplace -- now try the same with mixed caste folks in India...
- roywiggins 5y agoI didn't say it was the same, just that it's equally stupid and persists anyway. It's easy for Americans to look at caste systems in other cultures and see them as transparently silly, even though our own racial hierarchies can seem self-evidently real and serious to us.
- lsiebert 5y agoOne of the ways racial hierarchies persist in the US in the culture are taught they are normal, natural, deserved when they are instead being perpetuated by culture and institutions and those who benefit from them. The effects of discrimination serve to justify and/or perpetuate the discrimination. My take away from this is that there is nothing natural about one caste having an advantage in business, that success in any field has much more to do with who has financial and social capital than with what caste someone is.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThere have been no inter caste marriage restrictions in India either since 1954. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Marriage_Act,_1954 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Marriage_Act,_1954 Obviously, just like mixed race marriage took a while to be culturally accepted in the US, it is a similar situation in India. More importantly, it almost always comes down to socioeconomic class rather than caste or race. The upper socioeconomic “castes” or “tribes” or whatever you want to call them have been inter marrying forever, and no one cares. I would easily bet if a Brahmin kid brought home a significant other worth a billion dollars, their parents would not give a crap if the SO was a lower caste person. By definition, just being worth a billion dollars would somehow elevate them out of their caste. Same with white and black and Asian and Latin American or any other tribal designation.
- roenxi 5y agoYes and no, there is a bit of nuance to deal with. Any society will have subcultures with different specialities and talents. Recognising that isn't silly, codifying it as a matter of practice is. Work should be done by the best worker, not the person statistically likely to be the best worker or who comes from the family that works the hardest. But it makes a lot of sense that a family with centuries of experience in commerce is more likely produce leading businesses. It would be foolish not to factor that in to decision making as a signal.
- throwuxiytayq 5y agoThere is no nuance. The society where anyone can become the best worker will produce better workers, and more of them. Cast systems aren't for quality signaling, they're for limiting what any given person can achieve. It would be foolish to factor them in to anything, unless your aim is precisely to surpress others.
- thriftwy 5y agoThe indian CEOs who routinely give lip service to diversity and shun privilege, probably do not have any caste diversity in mind and are happy to have privilege, so I have heard: brahmins make effort to know the interviewee's caste status to weed out folk from unprivileged ones.
- gautamdivgi 5y agoDo you have any data to substantiate your claims. Your statement is just plain bigotry and unsubstantiated accusation.
- lmz 5y agoLast sentence of the article mentions a caste discrimination lawsuit.
- gautamdivgi 5y agoSo basically less than 5 Indians in a lawsuit is a representative sample of the more than 4 million in the US. That's basically the reason I called out the bigotry.
- SturgeonsLaw 5y agoThe article presents some numbers stating that the upper castes are overrepresented in the highest echelons of the business world, there must be some mechanism in place that causes this. At some stage, filtering is happening.
- rajup 5y agoYou are just assuming some kind of malicious filtering happening purportedly in interviews and the like. A perfectly plausible and likely the only explanation is that historically, yes the caste system led to the lower castes being denied economic opportunities that translates to them being less likely to have the resources to attain higher education abroad. The above explanation does not require the mental gymnastics of some sort of coordinated effort by upper caste interviewers to filter out lower caste people.
- gautamdivgi 5y agoIts silly and I'm unsure how many people pay attention to it in urban areas. I don't think a whole lot. Fwiw - India's prime minister belongs to what is traditionally lower caste, the president is lower caste and the vice-president is a muslim. The home minister is Jain (not Hindu). The caste system will die as India urbanizes and good riddance to it. Apparently the economist thinks it's relevant because they have nothing else to talk about.
- ashayh 5y agoYup and India had a female PM therefore there is no misogyny in India, and the US had a black President therefore there is no racism in the US.
- aldebran 5y agoNot true. Respectfully I say the following - You may come from an upper caste and so a place of privilege where you weren’t subjected to unfair actions. I’m not upper caste and I’ve experienced it all. My skin, eye color and mannerisms defy the backward caste stereotype. People assume I’m a Brahmin. When they discover I’m not things change. How did they discover this? My colleges thought it was a great idea to post the caste next to exam seat numbers. Yeah… this was in a metro, not a small town. Here in the US, some narrow minded people straight up ask about caste. Some are “smarter” and ask about how you celebrate specific festivals as a way of inferring your caste. It’s deeply systemic in India much like the systemic racism in the US. Only a privileged person can say it’s gone since no one treats anyone as untouchable anymore. There are many more subtle ways. People don’t get jobs because of their last names. Promotions will be denied or you might be the first to be laid off. Nepotism is rife. My wife is upper caste and her life experience in India is diametrically opposite of mine. She acknowledges my experience but still doesn’t fully comprehend it. Heck my in law still cling to stereotypes and how I’m one of the good ones (cue similarity to racism in America) If you really look carefully you’ll start to notice it everywhere.
- gautamdivgi 5y agoThis may not mean much, but I am truly sorry for all the misery you have had to endure. My hope was that caste should die when we immigrate. But that was too optimistic. The light on the horizon is that it will die with the second generation Indian-Americans.
- wombatmobile 5y ago
- ferdowsi 5y agoIndeed, literal thousands of years of ingrained social privilege and brutal repression of under-castes would tend to have produced nice social benefits for Brahmins. It's stupid, silly, old and outdated.
- lostcolony 5y agoUh, it is. The article lists 7 CEOs. That's hardly statistically significant out of all CEOs in the West, compared with both the number of all ethnicities that are CEOs of Western companies, and potentially also not significant compared with the number of Indian CEOs of Western companies (it gives no data there). And when you consider it's the caste with the most opportunity, well...you're basically saying that gains by those who had greater opportunity somehow justifies the system that gives them those opportunities. That logic would also support any oligarchy, aristocracy, etc, so long as those in power successfully remained in power.
- VectorLock 5y agoSeems like the skills are optimized for corporate ladder climbing as well.
- lostcolony 5y agoI mean, I'll grant even that it could be something hereditary. I mean, CEOs have a notably higher incidence of psychopathy than average. Not sure that's something we should be building into our societies.
- VectorLock 5y agoYes that is a very level playing field they competed on. Imagine how much even better top talent we'd have for late leadership at aging tech companies if the talent pool was broader.
- deleted 5y ago
- freetinker 5y agoWhile what you say is true, the caste system has generation-spanning impact. I’m not drawing parallels here, but as an example – not too dissimilar from the generation-spanning impacts of slavery. This is a sloppy article, and I do find the article’s assertion tenuous. There is an ecosystem of educated Indian elite[1]. Perhaps Brahmin’s are overrepresented as a group in that, but I’m not so sure. There are certainly some underrepresented groups, but the caste system isn’t binary. It’d be interesting to see some unbiased data. [1] Relatively speaking. While more privileged than a large majority of Indians, a lot of them come from modest middle-class backgrounds (by Indian standards, back in 70s, 80s pre-liberalization India), leveraged their privilege of education through sheer grit and work.
- praptak 5y agoSee also how Google got criticised for publishing historical maps of Japan. The reason? Locations where burakumin (untouchables) had lived were visible on those maps. This caused fears that these "bad addresses" would contribute to discrimination against inhabitants. These things really do span generations.
- magpi3 5y agoTribalism is old, archaic, outdated, and not useful (from a global perspective at least)... and yet it's everywhere. We're human, and for better or worse this seems to be a condition that we can't escape. EDIT: I really shouldn't say tribalism is not useful. We wouldn't be so tribal if it didn't have its benefits (evolutionarily speaking). But now that we live in a global world it is increasingly becoming a net negative.
- rajin444 5y agoI think it remains to be seen if the global world or the tribalism is a net negative.
- Ostrogodsky 5y agoLet's see, the global world has brought us international commerce, free exchange of information (95% of a CS curriculum is based on things created in the West), the possibility(limited but existent) of studying and working in a different society, international agreements, standards and organizations. Tribalism has brought us, wars, petty disputes, populist politicians and bigotry. I know which one I would choose in a heartbeat.
- jaldhar 5y agoWhy is it either/or? Immigrants often get a leg up in "working in a different society" by taking advantage of kinship based support networks. The have nots of global society try to attain social justice through tribalist notions of identity. And so on. I would say most people all over the world maintain a weak form of particularist identity and a weak notion of global identity and simply don't think about the contradictions.
- Ostrogodsky 5y agoThat all is true, but I was not the one who created the dilemma, the original parent did. Tribalism like nationalism is good just in very small doses.
- dqv 5y agohttps://archive.fo/gIyHn https://archive.fo/gIyHn
- albatrosstrophy 5y agoNon paywalled, anyone?
- phone8675309 5y agoIt wasn't paywalled when I clicked it just a moment ago.
- jimhefferon 5y agoCertainly paywalled for me.
- deepzn 5y agothe https://archive.fo/gIyHn https://archive.fo/gIyHn link in another comment is non paywalled
- manquer 5y agoEconmist has some free limit /month. Also some universities and other insitutions IPs will get full access without subscribing directly In general, Economist has been paywalled for 10 years now.
- SturgeonsLaw 5y agohttps://github.com/iamadamdev/bypass-paywalls-chrome https://github.com/iamadamdev/bypass-paywalls-chrome
- narrator 5y ago
- kspacewalk2 5y agoNo need to wonder. Many other ethnic minorities in Europe did not share their fate as a permanent, non-integrated underclass. Many are quite successful and well-integrated, like say Armenians in France.
- monocasa 5y agoNearly all of the Roma that were vaguely integrated into European societies were genocided in the holocaust. And that makes a pretty good argument to the rest that becoming more integrated is not worth attempting.
- secondcoming 5y agoDo the Roma want to integrate?
- Msw242 5y agoCulture absolutely plays a role here...
- himinlomax 5y agoThose Romas who have been successful have long integrated and ceased to be a different ethnic group. Romas as a group are in their current situation because they largely keep themselves segregated. I'm not saying they don't face discrimination -- they do. But it's not outside forces stopping them from integrating.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xqcgrek2 5y agoHow does one tell if Indians are Brahmins? Is there some trick to decoding firstname lastname?
- statictype 5y agoGenerally you can tell by the person’s last name. Especially if they are north indian. In the south its also possible but more tricky as the surname tends to be the fathers’s name and not an ancestral name that gets carried down.
- xqcgrek2 5y agoWhat last names correlate with caste?
- hawk_ 5y agoIt's more like a dictionary lookup[0] than some general pattern. Also there are many regional variations. So if you have come across a particular lastname before you happen to know they are brahmin. [0] - https://www.momjunction.com/articles/brahmin-caste-surnames-last-names-meanings_00649615/ https://www.momjunction.com/articles/brahmin-caste-surnames-...
- fault1 5y agoIt depends on area/region/language/place, so it's probably too way too many to list. You can look at common conventions here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_name https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_name
- jazzyjackson 5y agoIn case you were just waiting for the punchline: “they’ll tell you”
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe easy, traditional way is that Brahmins can't eat meat. Indians in America have often discarded that tradition. But I think about 2/3 of Indians in America are Brahmins, so you do pretty well by just assuming everyone is a Brahmin.
- baybal2 5y agoIn 2012 at one local tech event in Vancouver, I've overheard a whole lot of white suit donning guys sitting behind me playing the classic South Asian "guess a caste" game — "Arora, Sharma, Verma... we wanted a Marwari connection on the board... this guy must be a Jat? Remind what varna they were" Sometimes, I'm not sure myself who is more caste obsessed out there these days, Indians, or the India obsessed Western people. How to call it? Inverse casteism?
- postsantum 5y ago>India obsessed Western people What? Is it a thing in Canada? I am sure almost nobody in Europe ever heard of castes you mentioned
- urjika 5y ago
- throwawaysea 5y agoPlease leave such inflammatory comments off HN. See the rules here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html That aside, from what I can tell, you are pointing out that Indian people have caste preferences on matrimony sites. That doesn’t strike me as particularly offensive. Why is it any different from the general, and very widespread desire to marry someone who shares your culture? I don’t view that as an “obsession” as much as an important part of sharing a common experience with a life partner. The parent comment you’re replying to on the other hand, is making the point that there is an unexpected and disproportionate negative focus on caste from Western people, who have little familiarity with the language, culture, history, and experiences that they are critiquing. The West had a long history of being unreasonably judgmental of other cultures despite shallow familiarity and understanding. That’s probably true of humans in general as well.
- beebmam 5y agoI couldn't care less about the Indian caste system and instantly ignore anyone that talks about it. Just because its relevant to you doesn't make it relevant or important to me. I'll treat people as individuals regardless of what class, gender, race, sexuality, or any other qualifier, as long as they have the cognitive capability to comprehend reality and be well informed.
- postsantum 5y agoDo you also ignore people who talk about racism? It's not like casteism and racism are that different
- garbagetime 5y agoYes
- postsantum 5y agoRespect
- temptemptemp111 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wand3r 5y agoNot OP but I do/am. Its actually part of my new years resolution. There seems to be so much racism/race fetishization now. It was not like that growing up for me and I am only a millennial. I don’t have an opinion on the Indian caste system since I don’t know much about it, but this crazy race obsession has to stop IMO.
- webmaven 5y ago> Do you also ignore people who talk about racism? It's not like casteism and racism are that different Not the OP, but you're moving the goalposts a bit here. The OP stated they ignore people who talk about 'caste', not 'casteism'. That's like saying they ignore people who talk about race, not like saying they ignore people who talk about racism. Not that you can entirely divorce discussion of one from the other, but the intent is a bit different.
- mwattsun 5y agoIt wasn't until I retired from the tech industry and drove Uber and delivered Uber Eats for something to do that I realized how many Indian and Chinese engineers are in Silicon Valley. Huge 6 story apartment buildings covering a city block filled with engineers, often doubling and tripling up in small apartments. Some of the Indian engineers would tell to me (they were always friendly, the Chinese would often just go to sleep in the back of the car) that their agency was making most of their money. My hats are off to you guys and gals for working hard in America. I know the death marches and conditions you have to put up with. Caste concerns in America shouldn't be one of them.
- mosdl 5y agoOdd, did you never rent in sv? Most apartment complexes have at least on unit that is tripled like you mentioned.
- 01100011 5y agoI've long felt there needs to be some sort of dramatization of the lives of Asian, specifically South Asian(*), engineers and their contributions to modern technology. I feel like the average westerner just doesn't appreciate the sacrifices and hard work that have gone into the technology they base their modern lives on. * No offense to non-South Asians, it's just those are the folks I worked side by side with in the 00's and saw working multiple jobs and working themselves to death in a foreign land. Certainly this is nothing new in the history of the world, but I feel like the particular angle of their contributions to cell phones and the internet is worthy of a movie or something.
- yunohn 5y agoI think the article present a lot of data, but misses the point entirely. Upper caste Hindus lead TECH firms abroad, as they have access to higher education. Commerce castes lead RETAIL businesses back in India. They miss the massive immigration of blue collar Indian workers too. They do a lot of speculation but completely ignore the business domain aspect, and hence don’t pose a logical answer to the question they themselves present. Quite shoddy journalism.
- amriksohata 5y agoIt is very poor journalism with an intent to make a political point and bring up the caste system
- aldebran 5y agoYup. It feels like someone saw a couple of datapoints and wrote some clickbait article with no meta point.
- pessimizer 5y agoBringing up the caste system is not a political point.
- instagraham 5y agoCalling any discussion on caste an attempt to "make a political point" is patently poor intellectualism, particularly when you're not exactly refuting any of the points in the article. Scratch but a few inches beneath any of the supposed critiques of this articles, in this thread, and we will find precisely the kind of ingrained casteism that pervades the upper caste mentality, convincing them that they are supposedly meritocratic and superior to the "quota" lower castes. Casteists are not the intellectual equals of their modern critics and it shows in the way they try to avoid discussion on it.
- vsskanth 5y agoI agree. Its low quality journalism completely devoid of any actual analysis of data about indians who emigrated and the businesses they run. Makes me wonder if I can trust the Economist to present me an accurate picture on topics I don't know much about. A similar thing happened with Politico where I read an article about an issue I am very knowledgeable about (H1B visas). It was very opinionated, riddled with factual errors, bad sourcing, incorrect or straight up omitting any data that didn't fit a predefined narrative. You just had to Google a little bit to find the actual data from DOL. Completely shattered my trust in them and makes me doubt everything they report on, if they couldn't be bothered to enforce basic journalistic standards.
- techsin101 5y agoI was mind blown when I found my Indian friend fully supports caste system, that was like finding out your old and closest friend is KKK member and fully supports it.
- SturgeonsLaw 5y agoI'm assuming your friend is in one of the "forward" castes?
- dilawar 5y agoThat goes without saying. Indian here (born in high caste family, though in rural India). Rural folks are a bit more crazy about caste than urban folks but much more tolerant of different religions compared to them.
- techsin101 5y agoNow that I think about it, I remember seeing his family photos of village, so his parents must be from rural background.
- jaldhar 5y agoWhy would that be? A caste is an extended family. It certainly can be an instrument of oppression but it doesn't have to be and for most it isn't. Are you one of those Americans who think any expression of e.g. White/Southern pride is a sign of KKK racism? I mean it could be but some people just enjoy being Southern. "Caste System" in India is like "Patriarchy" or "Structural Racism" in the West. Some people are very invested in the idea. Some think it is one of several factors. Some argue it is an invalid concept and some just say la la I'm not listening.
- techsin101 5y agoNo I mean exactly what it means, caste system as in some people deserve to be rulers and we need someone to clean toilets. And it shall be determined via your caste, birth, over which you have no say.
- amriksohata 5y agoThis is demagoguery at its worst, what if we started going through English surnames and seeing who is Protestant and Catholic in Exec Boards. None of these leaders became who they are because of their caste, but only merit It's a nonsense article designed that is designed to instigate gutter level politics.
- lolinder 5y agoVery few people in east or west get anywhere based purely on their own "merit". We all build on the foundation that was left for us by our predecessors. Some of us were given a massive leg up. Others were born into families that have been systematically suppressed and intentionally prevented from making progress for generations.
- KrishnaShripad 5y agoSo? What is your point? Is your point to bring down those who have made it to the top on their own merit because you believe someone somewhere in their ancestry gave them a "massive leg up"? How do you prove that? And even if you can prove it, what is the fault of the person who was born into privilege? Do you mean to fault them for being born into it? If it was Nepotism I would agree with you completely. But if it was purely out of their own efforts that would be immoral. Even if it was built on a foundation left by that person's predecessors. I would rather focus on helping those who haven't made progress because they were systematically suppressed and be given a massive leg up. That shouldn't come at the cost of those who genuinely put their own efforts to climb the ladder in their respective fields. We have enough jobs and money to afford both. To help those who are systematically suppressed as well as continue to hire those who are born into privilege. Definitely not at expense of each other only because we want to check off some morality list. Both are human beings at the end of the day. I would want to see both prosper.
- lolinder 5y ago> Is your point to bring down those who have made it to the top on their own merit because you believe someone somewhere in their ancestry gave them a "massive leg up"? How do you prove that? And even if you can prove it, what is the fault of the person who was born into privilege? Do you mean to fault them for being born into it? No, no, and no. I'm not proposing that we should tear anyone down, nor that we should stop hiring qualified people on the grounds that they were privileged. I agree with you 100% that that would be unfair and counterproductive. What I'm arguing for is not a policy change, it's a paradigm shift. I believe that the first step to effecting real change in generational cycles of poverty is to acknowledge that generational cycles exist at all. Wealth does not simply flow to those who have merit--merit is in most (but not all) cases a product of wealth. It's a feedback loop. We cannot place full credit for success on the shoulders of the privileged without also placing full blame for failure on the shoulders of the downtrodden. To acknowledge and fix the generational cycles that keep people down, we have to first acknowledge and study the generational cycles that prop people up.
- satya71 5y agoI learned from my uncle, on a recent trip, that my grandfather had obtained a student loan that was subsequently waived by the king (under British Raj) at the time. That got our family on the ladder of economic growth. He could then afford to send his sons to better schools and his children sent theirs to even better schools and colleges. That first step of the ladder was only ever available to Brahmins.
- vsskanth 5y agoLooks like this article is overly focused on public tech firms. The author totally missed the merchant and trader castes from India (many from Gujarat and Kerala) founding and running large firms in the US (chains of restaurants, gas stations, convenience stores, motels etc.). I'm sure there are many keralites in the middle east running similar large firms, most of which might not be publicly traded.
- hnarayanan 5y agoThese are not glamourised.
- atonse 5y agoYup!!! Update: Even companies like Patel Brothers, etc.
- alkonaut 5y agoWhat prevents someone in India who happens to have an unfortunate caste association to switch caste? Assuming family names are easy to change, what else is it that ties you to the caste? Or are family names what underpins the system so the whole system relies on that you can’t simply file some paperwork and switch to some middle-caste name if you were born unlucky?
- chillage 5y agoVast social networks, family, friends of friends. Your identity is tied to who you are and very many people who you know in your town either knows your family or knows someone who knows your family. Indians have very extensive social ties
- alkonaut 5y agoBut it’s also a huge country with lots of people. If I move to a different city (e.g for school) and know no one, then apply for a job. What is the thought process and actions of a hiring manager who is discriminating on caste? Will they try to figure out who my relatives are? How? Would I be asked about relatives in an interview? What happens if I just shrug and say I’m from city X and I went to school in city Y and here I am? I understand that those who have lots of social captital have it tied to a network and a place such as a town. They would want to stay in that network to use their capital. For example move back home after studying. But for those with little or even “negative” social capital (ie you are better off with no background than your actual background), why aren’t they more mobile or even just claiming they are?
- sumedh 5y ago> Will they try to figure out who my relatives are? How? Would I be asked about relatives in an interview? For tech jobs no one is going to ask these questions.
- izacus 5y agoYou're thinking in the wrong direction - if you'd live in such society you'd understand that you're not trying to prove a negative ("you're from the wrong case"), but you need to prove a positive ("you're from the right circles, someone the boss knows knows you"). It's like getting in to american closed society - they'll check your social ties and if noone can vouch for you or know you, you're immediately suspect. And those checks aren't made in your face - it's usually in the background and async.
- dilawar 5y agoI recommend the book "India's new capitalists" by Harish Damodaran to the interested. The remembered village my M. N. Srinivas and anything on caste system written by Prof. Andre Beteille (He is Indian born to French father and a Bengali Brahmin women. "Sunshine on the garden" is his lovely autobiography.).
- kozikow 5y agoAt my work in a tech company there were social circles loosely formed along the lines: "natives", Indians and eastern Europeans. One Indian guy was an exception - he was a part of our eastern European group. Later I learned that he was the only non-Brahmin Indian in the company. Based on that and a few other situations I can say that Caste system is still present, even among Indian tech workers that emigrated to the UK and the USA. Edit: I don't think it's "explicitly" present. Just the thought in the back of the head: "does the other person still cares about the Caste system, even if they say the doesn't?" is enough to erode social interactions.
- xqcgrek2 5y agoThat is sad to hear. How do Indians born or who have lived a significant part of their life in the US integrate versus more recent emigrés?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sumedh 5y ago> How do Indians born or who have lived a significant part of their life in the US integrate versus more recent emigrés? Not sure about the US but in Australia I have noticed that the Western born Indians hang out with the natives while the Indians have their own group.
- sumedh 5y ago> Later I learned that he was the only non-Brahmin Indian It might not be caste related, it might be language related. Hindi speakers stick together, people from South India who speak other languages form their own group.
- jelliclesfarm 5y agoHow is this an example the ‘caste system’?
- normaler 5y agoI first thought of the Fallout universe mutated cows.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- screye 5y agoThe answer to it is quite easy if you know anything about India. Most Tech CEOs immigrated to the US in the 80-90s to study a not so cool academic area of science. Most backwards classes never had the wealth to sit on a plane, let alone study in the US. The pursuit of high positions in someone else's company is looked down upon in merchant communities. Additionally, the forward castes were among the only ones to know English well enough due to history in the British Civil service. (A similar thing happened to the parsis) So, CEO of a tech company is the kind of position that rewards academic pursuit of knowledge, a secondary emphasis on money (for your early years at least), being brought up in privilege and a kind of society that views CEO as the highest status post. The Brahmins satisfy this criteria perfectly. Wait for a generation or two. The most privileged of India are actually staying home. The American dream is a middle class pursuit and the demographics of South Asians at tech companies are rapidly changing. Sauce- a non-forward class Indian immigrant tech dude ______ One new type of discrimination that's going unnoticed is the 'IIT' bias. More and more, top universities use being an IITian as the badge of honor for upperclass Indians. This is visible among the students as well. They often form cliques rather quickly. BitS, IIIT and NIT folks may get honorary entry to these groups if they are 'cool' enough. But, if you went to a no-name school in India, you are always expected to prove yourself in a manner that IITians never are. The removal of GREs for admissions is making this divide more concrete. It is a shame, because the IIT-JEE is a very specific type of examination that requires sacrificing around 3-5+ years of your most formative years for a low probability chance at entering an elite institution (The true geniuses, a minority of the IIT student body are exceptions.). I know a large number of incredibly talented students at mediocre universities with zero avenues for pursuing research or adding some solid achievements to their resume, because the rich keep getting richer, and all the opportunities flow into IITs and some of the other aforementioned colleges.
- strikelaserclaw 5y ago9 people in my family went to IIT, NONE of them are even close to being geniuses, what they are are people with above average intelligence who sacrificed their childhood to grind exams.
- 5y ago
- bravenous 5y ago
- dang 5y agoIt looks like your account has been posting primarily on nationalistic topics. That's against the site guidelines here. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- known 5y ago
- eklavya 5y agoLooks like people in the west are much more interested in castes. I have never once in my career in tech in India ever had a discussion about it at any workplace or ever heard anybody talk about it.
- sanmon3186 5y agoI second that. I have been in the industry for two decades (three continents with most time spent in India) and never in my career I encountered communication around someone’s caste at workplace. Every time I come across such topics, I casually discuss this up with my colleague friends and there is hardly anyone who seems to cares. On the other hand, what i find more visible is regionalism. It is common to stereotype say a Punjabi, a Bihari or Tamil or a Marathi. Both in front of behind each others’ back.
- sumedh 5y ago> I have never once in my career in tech in India ever had a discussion about it Maybe you are from the upper caste, people from lower caste will have a different opinion.
- greatgib 5y agoBased on what is going on inside India and that it is a cultural thing. I easily think that the same thing is going on in US but it is just a different cast that took the lead. The last line of the article could give a glimpse into that: <<For the past 18 months a California court has been hearing a suit filed by a Dalit employee at a Silicon Valley firm, demanding compensation alleged discriminatory treatment by higher-caste bosses.>> When you suddenly see in the last years, a big number of silicon valley CEO to be of Indian origin from the same cast, I can easily think that there is 'relationship' factor that put them there. Especially considering that most of them are not founders or growth leaders of all these companies. Because it would be surprising to think that it is just that India produced much more skilled workers than anywhere else to have such high rate of them in SF.
- haltingproblem 5y agoThe irony of this article is sorely missed by the Economist and most Western commentators in this thread. On one hand the Economist spreads tropes like "Brahmins have a tendency for bookishness". Replace Brahmin with Jew and it becomes anti-semitic but saying it for Brahmins is ok? Should'nt the fact that the Brahmins who are poorer on average than the other two castes who "follow" them in the hierarchy disprove the notion of hierarchical caste system? If they really did dominate the hierarchy, could they not marshal capital given their abundant intellectual resources to dominate commerce in India? This reminds of the various Jewish world control conspiracies which are simply falsified by pointing to the horrific suffering that the Jews have suffered at the hands of said conspiracy theorists for over two thousand years. Similarly, the fact Brahmins that they do not dominate commerce or wealth generation prove that the so-called hierarchy does not exist? Commerce in India, as the Economist points out but then glosses over, is dominated by guilds just like it did in most of the world including Europe, China and Japan. It is pretty easy to get into the Diamond business if you are from one of the few families who were traditionally in the Diamond business from the State of Gujarat or Rajasthan. Even better if you were from the village of Palanpur [1]. Why? It is easy to apprentice in the industry, get access to capital, know-how etc. etc. Ditto if you want to get into one of the traditional industries that have a long history of being dominated by guilds. This even holds true in the US today - it is easier to start a Motel if you are a Patel because you can find someone in the extended family who is in the business, whom you can tap into for advice, funding or partnership. Same for starting a Donut join in SoCal if you are SE Asian, Retail if you are Syrian Jewish, etc. Brahmins have long been dominant in education because their traditional profession requires learning complex concepts and memorizing tens of thousands of pages. This was similar to how Ashkenazi Jews but not Sephardic Jews came to dominate the sciences and the Nobels [2]. I suspect that the selection pressures experienced by Brahmins are similar to those experienced by Ashkenazi Jews. Not a Brahmin, FWIW and neither is Parag Agrawal who is the CEO of Twitter. Another fact that should dissuade people from the notion of Caste-dominated industries is that 3-4 of the top-20 industrial families in India, (Tata, Wadia, Godrej, Shapoorji Pallonji, etc.), are Zoroastrians who came to India from Persia 1500 years ago fleeing Islam and are still practicing Zoroastrians. [1] https://www.rediff.com/business/special/how-palanpurs-diamond-merchants-conquered-the-world/20200207.htm https://www.rediff.com/business/special/how-palanpurs-diamon... [2] https://web.mit.edu/fustflum/documents/papers/AshkenaziIQ.jbiosocsci.pdf https://web.mit.edu/fustflum/documents/papers/AshkenaziIQ.jb...