3 ms·
The reason we object to it is that in reality it's spam. 99% of the time it's not a great article, it's crap. You're not writing it out of joy, it's to get link
by mattmanser 15y ago
The reason we object to it is that in reality it's spam. 99% of the time it's not a great article, it's crap. You're not writing it out of joy, it's to get links and make a computer deep in google think it's relevant. You need to trick google into thinking people like it so you spam wherever you can and pray you get those links.
There aren't 100 great links per day on HN. It's actually extremely difficult to write good content. Yet there are tens of thousands if not hundreds of thousands of companies doing this.
All off-page SEO is grey as you're essentially trying to trick google into thinking your content is better than organic content. But is there any organic content any more?
On the other hand, we have to get off our high horse. Real life is full of spam, TV adverts, radio adverts, billboards, networking events where you have to filter the schmoozers from the interesting.
The web is the same way and if you don't compete to get your content out there, you competitor will. As everyone does it now, you have to do it too.
So I agree with you, but I'm more realistic about the fact that most content produced is going to suck.
- danmaz74 15y agoThere is at leas one SEO element that you can do without compromising your ethics: Study which the most searched keywords are in your niche, and use those keywords in what you would have published anyway (home page, blog posts, press releases, whatever). This is not just SEO, it is adopting the language of your users, which is good in itself.