3 ms·
Cryptocurrency: How $YEAR pulled the rug in under 6 hours
- vgel 5y agoThis shows some of the flaws in crypto "security audits", IMO. This person said they skimmed over the exploit (a mechanism that prevented the contract interacting with the "owner address", which could be set to an exchange address to make selling the token impossible), because they assumed it was "an amateur mistake". But a good review would have required that to be fixed regardless: if you audit a web app and see a vuln that's not part of an exploit chain you still fix it because it can become part of an exploit chain later. But in crypto, the point of audits seems to be assuaging people's fears instead of making actually secure software, and in the rush to invest / FOMO they didn't want to slow things down by not investing until this "small thing" was fixed. So instead of losing gains, they lost everything.
- Melting_Harps 5y ago> But in crypto, the point of audits seems to be assuaging people's fears instead of making actually secure software, and in the rush to invest / FOMO I've said it before a bunch of Corpos pushing for it despite it's obvious flaws and what made me walk, and I will say it here: Soldiity is fucking garbage! The fact that they can hide an exploit like this goes to show just how poor the vetting process is in ETH community. Attributing the (often absurd) misgivings of ETH to the rest of the projects (like Bitcoin) is a mistake that should not be made. Whether it's the DAO, or 2.0 or the proof of stake transition. ETH is it's own cesspool and should be contained to just that--it's also no surprised established corporations and VCs are backing this far beyond anything else in this ecosystem. It's what those who gravitate towards buzzwords will opt for because it sounds promising, rather than actually taking the time to understand what the goals of a particular project is and how it functions. I'll never forget how Bitcoin meetups, with a far larger market cap and more robust developer community, was still hanging out in bars and doing p2p trades and workshops while ETH meetups had VC backing and had their own co-working spaces with sponsorship when I was still frequenting meetups like 4-5 years ago.
- Havoc 5y agoPeople see this sort of thing as a flaw in crypto, but I'm less sure. Sure there is pain there, but also learning and improvement. If a flaw is found in an open source cryptographic library you don't go "well this was all a mistake"...you fix it and try to do better next time. People learn about rowhammer, spectre and what not over time and often the hard way. Don't think these sort of smart contracts are all that different - it is code too after all. I'd wager that there has been a huge jump in knowledge as to how to write code like this. And that's largely unexplored territory. Little of the existing system like banking has this dynamic. So hardly surprising that there are some tough lessons along the way