6 ms·
Was that kind of fast?
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
Was that kind of fast?
- agsnu 5y agoNormally RHEL/CentOS releases are supported for 10y - CentOS 6 was 2010-2020, CentOS 7 is 2014-2024. 8 was released in 2019 so you might expect it to be supported through 2029, a year ago they announced it would be brought forward by 8 years.
- chasil 5y agoConverting to Rocky, Alma, or Oracle Linux will extend support to 2029 with minimal changes to the installed system. Most CentOS 8 users would likely have done this by now. Red Hat also offered a conversion procedure the last time I looked, but it replaced every installed RPM with equivalents from its own repositories. This is quite violent, and it would be far from my first choice for a critical system.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoI can vouch for Alma linux personally, we switched and it was painless.
- bityard 5y ago> but it replaced every installed RPM with equivalents from its own repositories. This is quite violent The whole point of CentOS was to be 100% compatible with RHEL, right down to the packages and binaries. For literally this kind of scenario. I don't see how that's "violent." I'm also not sure how you can expect to convert from one distro to the other without replacing all (or at least most) of the packages.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago> I'm also not sure how you can expect to convert from one distro to the other without replacing all (or at least most) of the packages. The thing is, they were almost exactly the same distro, so in any meaningful sense you could switch from one to the other by switching the release files, some yum support stuff, I think the kernel?, and some miscellaneous branding if you cared. But 99% of packages were functionally the same, so yeah I don't see replacement being a problem per se, but it also didn't seem very necessary.
- dralley 5y agoEhhhhh. The code is the same, yes. The "binaries" are not, necessarily. The build environment isn't exactly the same and there have been bugs experienced in CentOS that weren't in RHEL and vice versa. So it was never 100% compatible, more like 99.5%. The exceptions are rare edge cases but they do exist.
- josephcsible 5y agoIt was a little fast, but that's not why it was a rug pull. It was a rug pull because IBM retroactively shortened its lifespan after a bunch of people had already started using it in production.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoSaw it coming a mile away when CentOS was acquired. You don’t acquire your free competitor to keep them around exactly as is simply out of the goodness of one’s heart.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago> Saw it coming a mile away when CentOS was acquired. That was 2014; if this was the original plan, they took their sweet time with it.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoMaybe it wasn’t but I don’t see how any business acquires their free competitor and then keeps it around to cannibalize their own potential market. Just doesn’t make any sense. It was inevitable - initially intentional or not. It’s just capitalism.
- 5e92cb50239222b 5y agoAnd they got at least two new competitors, three if you count Oracle. You really think they did not foresee that?
- rubyist5eva 5y agoThey probably didn’t expect as much backlash to Stream and expected people to just use that or buy RHEL. I’m sure the amount of users they expected to lose to new forks was part of their risk analysis, they just blew it IMO.