4 ms·
"Some of the most free-thinking people in the United States are in the US Army." This statement brought to you by the 20+ billion dollars the military spends e
by Alex3917 15y ago
"Some of the most free-thinking people in the United States are in the US Army."
This statement brought to you by the 20+ billion dollars the military spends each year on propaganda and PR.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- MartinCron 15y agoI would read it as "the economy is crappy and the US Army is one of the few reliable ways for ambitious free-thinking people to escape from low-opportunity small towns, get work experience, and pay for college" instead of a propaganda and PR thing.
- sspencer 15y agoAnecdotal rebuttal: The soldiers I've met and interacted with are among the most varied group of people I can imagine that all do the same basic job. They show more inherent variance than any other profession I've ever seen. I concur completely with the Atlantic's letter, and sincerely doubt it was a PR plant. Just my .02.
- arethuza 15y agoIs it really accurate to describe it as the "same basic job" - there are an awful lot of different roles in any modern force.
- Alex3917 15y ago"I concur completely with the Atlantic's letter, and sincerely doubt it was a PR plant." It might be, but there's no way to tell. But even if it is 'authentic', it's still coming from someone who was likely influenced by the propaganda machine. When someone is willing to spend literally billions of dollars per year to create a one-truth world, the only safe thing is to treat basically everything you hear from/about them as bullshit. Consider the following: "Sometimes we are [portrayed by the media as] plagued by PTSD and associated terrors. [...] The reality is very different." Except according to statistics, roughly 50% of the soldiers coming back from overseas are on disability. And even that is an undercount because the military often denies people medical care for their injuries, lies about how people got hurt, etc.
- Helianthus 15y ago>It might be, but there's no way to tell. But even if it is 'authentic', it's still coming from someone who was likely influenced by the propaganda machine. News flash: all communication can be cast as propaganda. The right to free speech guarantees that people will try to convince each other of things. Which is to say, this man could be completely honest and correct and speaking of his own free will, and I would still accept that that counts as propaganda--I just wouldn't get my panties in a bundle over it. Propaganda is neither good nor bad--it is merely someone trying to convince you of a viewpoint. Perhaps by using an uncited statistic that presumes the real statistic is something worse, that makes an assertion about a culture that the speaker is _not_ part of. You yourself are part of the propaganda machine: as long as you are unaware of it, however, as long as you do not see how your free speech is also society's voice in you, you will just be arguing talking points. Real dialogue comes from accepting that motivation and bias must necessarily accompany fact, and drawing bounds thereof.
- Alex3917 15y ago>Perhaps by using an uncited statistic "With almost 50 percent of returning troops eligible to receive some level of disability payment, and more than 600,000 treated so far in veterans' medical facilities, we now estimate that future disability payments and health care costs will total $600 billion to $900 billion. The social costs, reflected in veteran suicides (which have topped 18 per day in recent years) and family breakups, are incalculable." http://www.slate.com/id/2302949/ http://www.slate.com/id/2302949/ "You yourself are part of the propaganda machine" Really? Where are my millions of dollars? Where is my government-issued sockpuppet management software? "All communication can be cast as propaganda. The right to free speech guarantees that people will try to convince each other of things." Again, you are leaving out the part where the government is paying millions of dollars so that soldiers can downvote and drown out any comments that are critical of the military on social news sites like this one. Do you really not see any difference between having a conversation where neither party is paid for their opinion, and a conversation where one side is unpaid and the other side has a billion dollar warchest to drown out any dissent? That's not exactly the same as two neighbors having a chat.
- koudelka 15y agoPerhaps because anybody's son will do. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DShDaJXK5qo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DShDaJXK5qo
- run4yourlives 15y agoActually, as a veteran myself, (albeit not in the US) I completely agreed with this one.