11 ms·
Smartbolts
- alhirzel 5y agoThis reminds me of frangibolts: https://www.ebad.com/tini-frangibolt/ https://www.ebad.com/tini-frangibolt/ Conop: an electric heater temporarily modifies the crystal structure and axially overloads the bolt, breaking it. We used these on a satellite that I worked on with deployable panels.
- Doxin 5y agoWhat's the actuation time on these? I can imagine that it'll take a hot second due to it being based on a heater.
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoI don’t ride rollercoasters but if I did I would want them to use these.
- avianlyric 5y agoSmartBolts won’t help if nobody looks at them. Unfortunately most rollercoaster accidents are caused by humans simply failing inspect structures, ignoring the results of inspections or disabling safety systems. Rather than inspections being too difficult to perform.
- qbasic_forever 5y agoI can guarantee a roller coaster track at any modern amusement park in America is inspected far more frequently and is much safer to travel on than the interstate highways and bridges that get you to the parking lot.
- gkop 5y agoWould you say more on this? Curious
- qbasic_forever 5y agohttps://infrastructurereportcard.org/ https://infrastructurereportcard.org/ vs. I worked at an amusement park during summers in highschool and coaster track maintenance was serious business. The entire tracks were walked and inspected end to end twice a day (at open and at close). There was a meticulous paper trail of any and all maintenance, measurements, conditions, etc. Their insurers demanded a high standard because ultimately it would have cost the park millions and millions of dollars in liabilities if there were accidents.
- gkop 5y agoThanks! Forgive me but I gotta ask- how would you describe the socioeconomic class of the folks the park served? Can they afford to sue over small, non life-threatening accidents caused by minor safety breaches? Was the park ever sued, and how did it go? (My line of inquiry is coming from having seen abhorrent safety standards upheld at a major mainstream park, that was the poor people park in the region - the same company had another nearby park for the suburbanites, that was much nicer)
- blamazon 5y agoI’m a mechanical engineer - smartbolts are cool but rarely used in my experience. Much more commonly used are DTI washers: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_tension_indicator https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_tension_indicator Due to the washer style can be used with a wide range of fasteners. The most common type, in my experience, due to the ease of use, has a little bit of colored goo inside the arched cells. The goo squirts out when the specified torque is reached. That being said, there are a lot of approaches to this same problem. Another common technique is breakaway bolts that are driven with a piece that snaps away when a certain torque is reached: https://youtu.be/lrCoi3gaLfU https://youtu.be/lrCoi3gaLfU
- mc32 5y agoI'm not an ME or anything, but it would seem washers attest to pressure (tension) at some point in time (when the nut was tightened -unless the washer is "springy", which I doubt as it seems it simply yields at some point), whereas smartbolts attest to the tension when you look at them --so during maintenance and not only during installation, so from that PoV, they are more useful (informative).
- blamazon 5y agoThat’s true, but you can have a qualified inspector mark bolts with goo with a paint line that straddles to the fastening surface. Then you can just inspect the paint line for movement, which gets you most of the same functionality at significantly lower cost. Of course, that requires a trustworthy inspector, which is one application where smartbolts become useful, if you don’t have a trustworthy inspector available at install time. But many projects that have importantly torqued fasteners (bridges, buildings, rollercoasters) have certified inspectors anyway… which is why smartbolts are a niche product I think. Speaking to the trust problem - if you trust the operator of the torquing install device, you don’t need fancy torque indication at all, just mark the paint line at install. That is the most cost effective.
- mc32 5y agoYes, that seems like a cheaper option; however, I think when you have constant stresses over time, bolts can stretch or simply parts can wear over time and a paint score or even a frozen nut won't reveal lessened tension. Though maybe in this case the issue would have become a concern way before the bolts start to indicate a problem?
- noughtme 5y agoSome crazy canuck cut one in half to show how they (don't) work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ClPwlpa86bY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ClPwlpa86bY
- connor4312 5y agoWhen you said "some crazy canuck", I immediately knew it must be AvE
- arminiusreturns 5y agoReally informative comment on that video: "Nice video. Couple of points: 1: As per the title of your video, its worth emphasizing that these are tension indicating bolts, not torque indicating bolts. 2: With any bolted connection its the tension that is important. Whilst torque and tension should be correlated, that relationship varies considerably from bolt to bolt, lubricant to lubricant, hot to cold, state of corrosion etc... 3: So a bolt torqued to say 100NM may well have a tension variance of over 100%. The result is that bolts are often over or under tensioned, which can compromise the entire bolted connection. 4: Bolts like this (I've personally used Rotabolts, which are similar in concept but in my opinion better as they rely on a mechanical indication rather than a subjective color hue.) are very useful for certain applications, for example, sub-sea connections where divers have limited time and feeling, and sea conditions affect the bolt lubrication. 5: Other uses are for ensuring correct bolted connections on sensitive flanges, again offshore and sub-sea sees a lot of this. 6: Bolts like this are, in summary, brilliant for when you need a good quality bolted connection with correctly tensioned bolts. For most applications however they are unnecessary. Keep up the good work! :-)" - drawingboard82 Side note: youtube mobile when I tried to copy the comment wants me to sign in, to just copy a comment! wtf youtube! I just opened it in newspipe instead and copied from there
- xyzzyz 5y agoOne thing missing here, but talked about (albeit not very clearly) in the video is that it’s not even a tension indicator, but rather, extension indicator. As long as we are in elastic regime, tension and extension are the same thing (Hooke’s law). However, once you go beyond it, tension goes down even as extension goes up. This is what the canuck meant when he talks about people tightening the loose bolt by giving it extra tweak, around minute 3:40 in the video. Once you leave the elastic regime, the bolt holding strength is permanently reduced, and by periodic tightening, sooner or later you’ll see it yield altogether.
- sfifs 5y agoSeems like something that would be very useful for furniture or mechanisms that are self assembled like Ikea, chairs etc by regular people. Easy visual inspection when things are loose.
- ycIsGarbage 5y agoWay too expensive for that kind of application.
- thom 5y agoNo pricing on the site, but I hope it's in the region of five thousand wrappages of Cardassian yamok sauce for a hundred gross.
- oneplane 5y agoI think the bolts listed in the article are less expensive than self-sealing stem bolts.
- dominicdoty 5y agoI've always liked ultrasonic bolt length measurement as the ultra high reliability way of measuring preload. It can also be used for confirming the correct preload is still present, with the downside of having to track the original length of every fastener (which isn't really a big deal in high reliability applications)
- rsync 5y agoI consult with a seismic expert at UC Berkeley about once yearly and he's pretty cavalier about pre-loading ... Which is to say, he wants me to "pre-load the shit out of it". Which is to say, our "indicator" is that we start to bend the HDB with the threaded rod. For instance, if we have two of these, horizontally, on either end of threaded rod: https://www.strongtie.com/boltedholdowns_holdowns/hdb_holdown/p/hdb https://www.strongtie.com/boltedholdowns_holdowns/hdb_holdow... ... he tells me to tighten that threaded rod between them until we just start to see the hold downs bend (toward each other). So, not very scientific at all, but easy to tell that you're pre-loaded ...
- moreati 5y agoIn the UK (and elsewhere?) Lorry tyres have plastic caps on the bolts, with arrows aligned to each other in pairs, or some regular pattern. It's easy to see at a glance if a bolt has loosened. e.g. https://mechanics.stackexchange.com/questions/29690/what-are-the-yellow-triangles-on-truck-wheels-for https://mechanics.stackexchange.com/questions/29690/what-are...
- dalrympm 5y agoI would love to see these on chair lifts. I wonder if the indicators can remain valid with the types of temperature swings you see on a ski mountain.
- rsync 5y agoIn my experience, the most common safety practice on chairlift (poles) is a double-nut. It's very common to see all through North America - no washer, just two nuts stacked. I've never inspected them to see if they have indicators painted on, etc. - one would assume they should ...
- dalrympm 5y agoI've also noticed that the nuts go on top. I've always wondered if this was so it was completely obvious if a bolt dropped out (i.e. sunlight coming through the hole).
- karaterobot 5y agoIt's annoying that, as you scroll down the page, the bolt animates to show it turning, but it scrolls out of view before it gets to the point where the main feature of the product would be shown.
- disposableuname 5y agoNot just me, then. I played around with scroll, with zoom, doing everything I could to try to see the actual main feature.
- alphabet9000 5y agolol i just noticed that here is the desired effect they were looking for (added margin-top to <body>) https://i.imgur.com/tehEWx9.gif https://i.imgur.com/tehEWx9.gif
- GistNoesis 5y agoI am surprised there aren't already some chip for it, or is there ? Something based on RF-energy harvesting, you beam it with radio waves, it uses the energy to take a pressure measurement and send you back the result, along with the id of the bolt. And you inspect all your factory bolts in a matter of seconds, and everything is nicely logged, even those hard to inspect bolts. To measure the pressure either some piezo-resistance, or some capacive-sensing between two washer separated by a squeezie dielectric (Could a FR4 pcb-washer hold the pressure ?), or an integrated MEMS-pressure sensor. If your technician needs to tighten the bolt, he has to get close so he can transmit more RF energy so you can even have a led, that could turn on when the pressure is right.
- Breadmaker 5y agothere is: IoT bolts https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29123301 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29123301
- RivieraKid 5y ago> Incredibly advanced. Surprisingly simple. > Unmatched Benefits > Unprecedented Value They think they are Apple, lol.
- dmkolobov 5y agoI was one of the folks who put together the steel for a waterslide in a certain amusement park in California. Our method consisting of putting a mark across the bolt and nut after tightening it all the way down with a spud wrench, and then using a breaker bar until the mark on the nut was at the 4 o'clock position( or maybe it was 8, I don't recall ). The inspectors would then use a telescope to check every mark. Completely blew my mind that they relied on this method, rather than something that measured the force directly.
- choonway 5y agoor you could use a drone with a sufficiently zoomed in and stabilized camera.
- dmkolobov 5y agoTotally, but the crazy part is that there is nothing preventing you from making these marks without following the appropriate tightening procedure. When the project is several months late and people are working 16 hour days, the temptation to cut corners is high.
- hinkley 5y ago> making these marks without following the appropriate tightening procedure If you didn't torque the bolt tight enough then it will come loose sooner, and the lines won't line up. I'm sure there are situations where the torque of the bolt is critical for handling peak load on the system, but for a lot of situations where a torque wrench keeps you from damaging by over-tightening, and makes sure you got it tight enough that it stays tight. I should say there's one other failure mode a torque wrench can test that that the paint doesn't by itself, and that's a failing bolt. If you've ever seen a broken bolt, and the entire surface isn't uniformly shiny, then you've seen a bolt that cracked a long time ago and then failed recently. That crack is going to show up as less torque. So if the bolt hasn't spun but the torque has dropped, you might have a problem, rather than having a freak incident where the nut spun exactly 360° since you checked it last. I could see an argument for using paint and smartbolts for fasteners with epic failure modes, like people dying or generators exploding.
- hexnuts 5y agoWe need self sealing stem bolts.
- jamesakirk 5y agoGot anything to trade for them?
- hinkley 5y agoIf you think the head of a bolt with an indentation in it is going to stay clean, especially one that has to stay tight, then you have not held a wrench often enough, my friend. Once that red spot gets dirty, you're not going to be able to tell if it's brick red because it's loose, or brick red because it has dirt on it. It's probably going to take you longer to clean the bolt than to get the torque wrench on it.
- ycIsGarbage 5y agoMost dirt isn't red though. I'd worry more about dirt obscuring the red and making it look black.
- hinkley 5y agoLook at the pictures on the website and I think you'll follow me. I was thinking of brown specifically but black has the same effect. When it's partially covered the color will be the average of the two. Probably black if it's near pavement, brown if exposed to nature.
- Prcmaker 5y agoNot all tension controlled scenarios are dirty though. Working with a lot of stainless recently in controlled environments, galling is a big friction variable so instrumented bolts can be crticial.
- WalterBright 5y agoAt Boeing, I learned that bolts should be lubricated before torquing them in order to ensure an accurate torque. I initially thought wouldn't the lubrication allow the bolt to unwind itself? Surprisingly, no. Since then, on my car, I always put a bit of grease on a bolt beforehand. It keeps the water out, preventing the bolt from rusting itself together. It makes for an accurate torque. I've never had one unscrew itself, and I can always get the lug nuts off! Of course, you still need to use lock washers. For critical bolts, use a cotter pin or a safety wire.
- globular-toast 5y agoI grease all the threads on my bicycle ever since I had a bottom bracket seize into a frame and lost the frame. I have heard that you shouldn't grease lug nuts on a car, though. I'm not sure why, so take it with a a large pinch of salt. It might be simply because most people don't regularly check the torque on the nuts and in that case it's more desirable to have them seize than fail.
- WalterBright 5y agoI've been doing this for 40 years. I've never had a lug nut loosen, or rust in place. But this, of course, is anecdotal data. Do what you judge is best for your situation.
- auxym 5y agoAnecdotally, I've been using loctite C5A (copper anti-seize) on lug nuts for years without an issue. I also torque them to the manufacturer spec with a torque wrench twice a year (when I switch summer/winter tires).
- WalterBright 5y agoI use hi temp wheel bearing grease for the lug nut lube, as it won't melt and run when hot. Don't want grease dripping on the brakes! The amount is also a tiny dab, half a drop is plenty. I don't use a torque wrench, just give em a hard twist, lower the tire to contact the ground, then twist them all again just to be sure.
- gannon- 5y agoCould be interesting to apply this to crew boats which A) people are used to paying a lot for the equipment and B) people often have to assemble and disassemble with bolts, and loose bolts are certainly a point of failure during a race.
- asimjalis 5y agoHow do SmartBolts work?
- alkonaut 5y agoWait I didn’t read anything about requiring a subscription to a cloud service before I can tighten the bolt. Nor how my phone will be involved in the process. And no blockchain? This isn’t “Smart” as I have understood we define it now.
- deltaonefour 5y agoThis is a bad name. The word "smart" implies the bolt can connect to my phone via bluetooth and I can download an app that will tell me the status of the bolt.
- thomasjudge 5y agoI was just thinking that these don't have wifi, an ip address, contact the mothership via aws to make sure the maintenance contract is paid up and TOS clicked...such a missed opportunity...
- deltaonefour 5y agoImagine replacing the batteries. The business opportunity here is highly lucrative.
- CRConrad 5y agoIt does imply that... Nowadays, unfortunately. This is bad, because "connect to my phone via bluetooth and I can download an app" is often not a very smart way at all to do something. Yet another example of how marketing abuse of language fucks up everything.
- KamiCrit 5y agoTorque is bolt stretch! In some real deal applications like connecting rods on engines you can stick your head into. Techs will measure when a bolt has reached a correct torque spec when the bolt has stretched to certain dimension measured with a micrometer. Torque is also very misleading depending on material. Steel bolts stretch in what feels very linear. Stainless steel bolts, when those are tightened up it's like hitting a wall going from loose to tight. Click sticks (torque wrenches) also have something to say. Where you hold your hand on the wrench will affect the torque value. Usually there is a line on the handle showing you exactly where your hand should be placed and pulling from.
- silisili 5y agoI guess I don't see the practical application. These will fill with grime in days if not seconds, depending on application. A torque wrench and loctite more or less make something like this unnecessary. If it's for some specific scientific applications, more power to them. But let's not pretend they just saw something so obvious everyone else has been missing. Edit to add: I actually feel like these should be reverse designed. A small tit that sticks up would probably be much more evident than a hole in most applications.
- Too 5y agoVery smart until you put a socket wrench over it so you can't see the indicator? This would only be useful with open spanners.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]