6 ms·
For a case that could potentially embarrass the state, I'd think the prosecution would try hard to make sure the case appears on the right judge's docket.
by rchaud 5y ago
For a case that could potentially embarrass the state, I'd think the prosecution would try hard to make sure the case appears on the right judge's docket.
- jbullock35 5y agoWhat ability do prosecutors have to maneuver their case onto a particular judge's docket? How would they do that?
- pixl97 5y agoYou talking about the cops, the DA, and the judge that eat lunch at the same table, attend the same parties, and go to the same church? You tell me how indirect influences could possibly happen in separated and just legal system. Sorry for the snark, but your post seems very naive on how the legal system works.
- DarylZero 5y agoThey just asked how. They didn't say it's impossible. The question of how is interesting. The question of whether is also interesting.
- jbullock35 5y agoThank you for the explanation. Yes, I know almost nothing about how the legal system works.
- sgjohnson 5y agoThey can try all they want, but do they have a shred of evidence of any wrongdoing?
- netizen-936824 5y agoThis is the point. Even if it gets before a biased judge, any lawyer worth their salt will see that they have no case and will call for a jury trial
- badRNG 5y agoIANAL, but the local Missouri computer crime statute is very broad [1]. Technically, the reporter seems to have factually "Accessed a computer, a computer system, or a computer network, and intentionally examined information about another person" without "authorization." Considering the conservative PAC for the state has already pushed attack ads against the reporter [2], and the fact that the prosecutor is elected (potentially supported by conservative PACs), I definitely see a possibility of this going to court and potentially arriving at a conviction. Again, IANAL, and I don't know the jurisprudence or case history behind this particular statute. [1] https://revisor.mo.gov/main/OneSection.aspx?section=569.095 https://revisor.mo.gov/main/OneSection.aspx?section=569.095 [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9IBPeRa7U8E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9IBPeRa7U8E
- ensignavenger 5y agoThe reporter did not access anything they did not have permission to access! It was on a publicly accessible website, posted publicly, for the purpose of public dissemination. The statue is even more restrictive than that- the part you didn't quote: "A person commits the offense of tampering with computer data if he or she knowingly and without authorization or without reasonable grounds to believe that he has such authorization" No one could possibly prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the reporter did not have "reasonable grounds to believe that he has such authorization". The reporter did not know that the website had private information on it when he accessed the page. The law does allow for a civil action to be taken by the owner of the computer system (In this case the state) which would lower the standard of evidence to more likely than not- but given the facts of the case, I don't think it comes even close to meeting that bar.
- badRNG 5y agoI totally agree with you in principle. Everything the reporter accessed was publicly accessible. That said, it seems like a prosecutor could articulate an argument that the reporter accessed information he had no reasonable grounds to believe he was authorized to access because he deliberately decoded some Base64-encoded strings that the reporter expected to contain sensitive information. Further, that because the reporter knew the site was using encoding to "protect" this information, by decoding the information he had believed might contain unauthorized information, he had "examined information about another person" that he had no "reasonable grounds" to believe he was authorized to access. For every objection that is coming to your mind reading this, think to yourself whether you are confident you could convince a tech-illiterate prosecutor (who is looking to "hold fake news accountable") to see things your way. Further, is a jury or a judge going to be able to find salient AND relevant differences between "decoding" and "decrypting" or "client-side" vs "server-side" software? And are those differences great enough to affect their interpretation of the reporters actions in the context of the statute? Judges, prosecutors, and juries cannot be relied upon to unwrite bad tech laws.
- tshaddox 5y agoWhy would it embarrass the state any more than the governor’s public comments already have?
- jvanderbot 5y agoJust because you understand it to be a ridiculous charge and view the gov as embarrassing himself, does not mean all have made that judgment for themselves. Those holdouts would latch onto a verdict as truth and view the gov as vindicated. That's basic legal harassment 101.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoI’m sure the governor would rather see this all the way to the end, lose and then cry foul than just admit he is wrong too. He probably already knows he is wrong but no politician would ever admit it. Politicians will dig in their heals until they’ve dug their own grave than admit fallibility. They are incapable of it.
- rsynnott 5y agoI think the ship has sailed on avoiding embarrassment to the state… My feeling is that this is deliberate; the American right wing appears to rather like performative stupidity these days.
- DarylZero 5y agoStrategic ignorance is the basis of religion and much social power.