3 ms·
I briefly ran a home server on desktop grade hardware. Ryzen 5 with 2 hard drives. The thing was pulling a constant 70w while basically idle. Insanely inefficie
by Gigachad 5y ago
I briefly ran a home server on desktop grade hardware. Ryzen 5 with 2 hard drives. The thing was pulling a constant 70w while basically idle. Insanely inefficient compared to adding an extra user to an existing app/service.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- southerntofu 5y agoFollowing this rationale, many people run small hosting coops from home, for example as part of the chatons.org or libreho.st federations. The author of the article even acknowledges they host some services for their sister and some other people. That's a great way to mutualize resources (reduce waste) and at the same time is arguably much greener than datacenter/cloud services which require dedicated infrastructure (a great source of energy/pollution), and often have layers and layers of user tracking/profiling and detailed logging which consume great amounts of resources.
- detaro 5y agoThat sounds quite bad for "doing nothing", modern desktop class hardware can do quite a bit better than that.
- Gigachad 5y agoI had to stick a little GPU in it since there were no built in graphics and the machine refused to boot without a GPU. That would explain some of the power. The rest I assume went to the fans and hard drives.
- lucb1e 5y ago> modern desktop class hardware can do quite a bit better than [70W idle] If a €1200 built-from-parts desktop from March 2020 counts as modern desktop class hardware... this system uses 85W idle. It has an AMD CPU+GPU, is Intel and/or Nvidia any better in this regard or are you talking about more low-end hardware?
- detaro 5y agoA lot of it is usually setup issues, i.e. either not enabling power saving features or hardware incompatibilities causing them to not be used. E.g. some mainboards ship with efficient power states disabled in BIOS. EDIT: e.g. for an optimized system with Ryzen 9 5950X and RTX 2070 Super apparently 40 W is doable for "sitting idly on Windows Desktop" according to reputable tests. Lower-class hardware can do less.
- lucb1e 5y ago"40W is doable" is honestly not what I expected from your comment (I got the impression of both less and it being the default), but then again you didn't say it was "good", just "better". Fair enough, but this achievable idle consumption is still double of the peak consumption of a mid-range laptop. Either way, thanks for putting a number to it!
- detaro 5y agoRyzen 9 with 16 cores and fancy-ish GPU is not really a mid-range setup, as I said, you can go lower with weaker components. (the other numbers I had at hand quickly were from way below the 1200€ mentioned in the comment I replied to, and I thought it was a useful upper mark). And in reverse, 20W peak is low for a laptop - my Thinkpad 480s (which I guess you can argue is not a mid-range laptop, but not exactly a workstation beast either) peaks more at 40. The desktop comparison to many laptops is more a mini-ITX based, embedded-graphics box with e.g. a quad-core CPU. There idle <=15W is realistic. (And the laptop idles at ~5, so still more efficient of course). And the range between for components inbetween that and high-end. Desktop is going to be worse than laptops, but people tend to overestimate how much power a desktop system actually has to use if it's built well. Modern CPUs are efficient at power-saving, PSUs have gotten better, ...
- ekianjo 5y agoif you use a NUC you can get less than 30W easily.