6 ms·
Americans seeking to renounce their citizenship are stuck with it for now
- ggm 5y agoThe increased exposure of risk to the consular staff is insignificant compared to normal life in the economy they're located in, and interviews could very easily be conducted in less harmful ways. Other (Judicial) processes including stat decs, evidence, cross examination all take place online when required. This is lie-detector class legalistic bullshit about f2f requirements. Specious. This is a pretty bogus decision. But, not an unusual one. US consular services are notoriously finicky to deal with, as any applicant for a complex visa (Iranian nationals, indonensians) or citizenship/residency can attest. (Not affected party in any way btw, I only go on what my friends who have dealt with US embassies and consulates tell me, and their stories are universally consistent)
- addicted 5y agoThe Consular services have been extremely poor throughout the pandemic. A lot of people have been waiting months, if not years at this point, beyond regular processing times for things that were basically formalities in the past.
- someguydave 5y agoWhat is worse is that there is no recourse other than to visit an embassy. My understanding is that you cannot renounce citizenship on US soil. It’s obvious this was a planned decision to turn off the only available exit.
- desdiv 5y ago>My understanding is that you cannot renounce citizenship on US soil. I know nothing about this except 5 minutes of googling, but seems like USCIS does process renunciations on US soil: >Further attempts by prisoners to renounce under 1481(a)(6) continued to be stymied by a United States Citizenship and Immigration Services policy that applicants had to attend an in-person interview and demonstrate that they could leave the U.S. immediately upon approval of renunciation. [0] Reading between the lines though, the process seems far harder than doing it aboard because you must demonstrate "intent to relinquish U.S. citizenship", meaning cutting off all US ties and establishing foreign ties, and that's hard to demonstrate when you're physically inside the US. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relinquishment_of_United_States_nationality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relinquishment_of_United_State...
- someguydave 5y agomy learning level is about the same, it seems the process is governed by https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1481 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1481 The gist is that the us gov pretty much has full discretion to “not believe” your renunciation if they desire. In practice the us gov seems to be unwilling to officially entertain renunciations except through very narrow processes.
- someguydave 5y agoClarifying the above I found this: https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/when-us-citizens-can-lose-us-citizenship.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/when-us-citizens-can... The important quote is this: “ For all the acts listed above, it is not enough to appear to commit the act—even voluntarily—to lose U.S. nationality; the person must also commit the act in order to relinquish the nationality.” It seems US gov policy is to interpret the law linked in the parent comment such that nearly no one (even traitors and rebels!) have the intent to renounce US citizenship and furthermore it is almost impossible to unambiguously prove that intention. Since no other nation is going to presume to tell the US gov who its citizens are (not), there is very little recourse or due process available.
- Pixeleen 5y ago> “Coronavirus made me realize that in the US, if you’re not a member of the moneyed elite you’re left to fend for yourself with virtually no help from the federal government,” he said. Most poignant quote in the article. I am a US citizen and my passport renewal came up during the pandemic. I thought that's fine, I'm not traveling anyway. Well I am also a US citizen with the complexity of a sex change in my distant past. I've had the right passport decades ago. After I sent in my routine renewal, I got a letter back saying that the US Department of State lost my old passport in processing. They wrote that I would need to send in seven pieces of identification, an explanation of why my passport was lost(!), have somebody come in person and vouch for me, in addition to a letter from a doctor confirming specific, very personal details of my sex change. I don't even have a doctor or health insurance, or seven IDs. It went back and forth in a humiliating, kafkaesque nightmare until I wrote them a letter saying I'm not sending anything more. My senator did not even give me the courtesy of a reply (bite me, Chuck Schumer, I bet your party will still talk about how you are God's gift to LGBTs). > "I wish you the best of luck getting rid of that passport. Good riddance." That was written by somebody below in this thread. I was trying to keep mine. Somebody told me that State Dept. has a backlog of a million passports. The American government, and administration, is utterly failing. Citizens at home cannot get basic services, meanwhile Biden is getting ready to play army in Asia again. I guess he never watched The Princess Bride.
- vaidhy 5y agoThat sounds horrible. Hope you get this resolved soon.
- Pixeleen 5y agoThank you. I did, five months start to finish for my renewal.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoDid they really ask for seven forms of ID? Exactly seven? In addition to your passport, you said they just lost it, did they say this in the letter? Did what they wrote say "7 ID's" or "seven ID's"? Not the same thing. Government-issued IDs right? Dual citizens only have six, they wanted your library card, your bus pass, like what are we talking about here? Did they give any examples of what you could provide? What do you propose they're trying to do, break a tie between the IDs of each gender (not kidding)? And you don't have a doctor. Or health insurance. But you're trans. Do you take no hormones then? You know what, as for the specific, very personal details of your sex change, I ask nothing. > "I wish you the best of luck getting rid of that passport. Good riddance." I wrote that. I thought of editing what I wrote for clarity. It doesn't mean what you think it means. Not good riddance of the passport. Good riddance of you as a citizen. Well I guess both. It's not pejorative, it's win-win. You don't want to have that passport, and I don't want to stick up for you if you won't stick up for the team. I'd like to but it's too much liability, I have to help only people who would in principle help others too. Evidently you don't care about that. And you wrote a letter telling them you're not sending anything more? And you're insulting a senator for not writing back, publicly? Did you vote for that senator from abroad or did you vote against him, did you not vote? Do you think the State Department will be more helpful now? How can I interpret what you said in the best possible light, like where to begin? Just make two pieces of the puzzle fit together. I generally believe people's stories regardless of whether they're lying. I think it's good for people to be believed, even if it's by one person, just for a little while, just to know someone can trust them. Later I reevaluate and maybe change my mind. I want to believe. Help me.
- MandieD 5y agoGetting the Consular Report of Birth Abroad, passport and then Social Security number for my child was an eight month adventure that I started on as soon as we got home from the hospital. I will again brag on how wonderfully easy it was to get the kid’s German passport by comparison.
- pyuser583 5y agoJust try voting abroad. That’s freaking insane. And don’t even think about registering to vote.
- MandieD 5y agoImportant reminder for many Americans abroad who are already registered to vote: you might need to make a request for ballots to be mailed (or emailed) to you every year - it’s separate from voter registration in many states.
- pyuser583 5y agoKeep in mind, balloting the US is based on place of residence. You’ll have a different set of elections to vote in from municipality to municipality (or ward to ward). So you need to have a specific address in the US. This makes sense. You shouldn’t be able to vote for an alder person in a different ward. But it requires a specific, “in US” residence. If you don’t have a specific address in the US, (you’re permanently residing outside the country) your last state of residence should be able to provide you with “President Only” ballots. I’ve never heard of this actually happening though. The US embassy has no involvement in any of this whatsoever. They will refer you to the clerk of courts (or whatever). Realistically, do everything you can in the US (including absentee voting if possible). Edit: keep in mind, many places have over a dozen distinct election events over a 4-year cycle. Presidential, presidential primary, mid-term, mid-term primary, non-partisan, non partisan primary, local school board, etc. Some states combine this into as few elections as possible, some as many elections as possible. I once tried to vote in every election. Lack of publicity made this impossible. For many minor elections, there was no public info on the candidates for, say, clerk of court primary elections.
- anshumankmr 5y agoFascinating. I never really knew that many people are eager to give up their American citizen, though of course, as a percentage of the population, their percentage is quite low. Some reasons make sense, like the people who have moved to a different country but are unable to get a citizenship there due to them being American citizens. >Marie Sock, the first woman to stand as a presidential candidate in the Gambia, was forced to pull out of the race recently after she failed to get any response to her request to renounce her US nationality from the US embassy. >She explained in a video posted on Facebook that under Gambia election law, presidential candidates must be sole Gambian nationals. Although cases like these should be fastracked IMO.
- geek_at 5y agoI have been thinking about giving up my citizenship too. I was born in TX in the late 80s but been living in Austria since the early 90s. I recently married but it was not easy to do so because I was born in the US as the gov here didn't like my birth certificate (missing an "apostille") and I needed a document from the US that they couldn't give me in time (or at all because they said I need to be there in person but they're not open for in person visits) because of Corona. I ended up finding a loop hole meant for war survivors that can't get a hold of documents which allowed me to marry my Austrian wife without the apostille. Didn't get easier though because all shared banking accounts we have, she has to report to the IRS too, we both have to sign a waiver to be excempt from banking confidentiality and I have to send them my tax papers every year despite never having earned a single dime in the US any paying full taxes herein Austria. Also Austrian banks and even European trading sites won't give me access to the stock market (they just say you were born in the US, we can't let you trade stocks over their platforms) but I don't have an address in the US so I can't do it on an US site either. This article gives me less hope of fixing these things in the future
- mapmap 5y agoHave you tried getting a US address with a mail scanning service? Is that accepted by banks?
- skinnymuch 5y ago
- londons_explore 5y agoHow necessary is it to wait for the US government's reply on the matter? Can't you write a letter to a US official saying "As of 31st Dec, I renounce my citizenship". If the USA can't organise an interview before that, that's their problem...
- genocidicbunny 5y agoUnfortunately, the US will likely come after you for taxes and penalties. And due to the pull that the US has on financial institutions outside of the country, its very likely they can get their hands on your money.
- londons_explore 5y agoSure, but typically they won't take your money before some court hearing, and at that hearing you just present the letter.
- genocidicbunny 5y agoAnd you would provide the court with a fun story to tell over beers that evening after they laugh/fine you out of court.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoYou don't just improvise with this stuff. There's a process and it's a mess and you follow it to the end with counsel that must be chosen with a lot of luck, but when it's over it's over and you can leave those nasty old taxes behind. There's good reasons for it, the embassies actually deal in bomb threats and hostage situations and the like, and if it were that easy to drop your citizenship there would 100% be coercion to forfeit the protection of the Department of State. They might not always help you, but in principle they would, unless of course you're no longer an American. That's why you have to forfeit citizenship inside the embassy, where you can signal if you're being coerced. Same as getting a passport renewed, it's a process, it's made in USA and shipped to your embassy. If you don't pick it up within the time window, I forgot how many days, it is destroyed and you have to start the process over again. Forgetting for a second the unique personal characteristics of America, the apple pie, the baseball, etc. In historical terms, you know how unique it is to be a citizen of the dominant state of the time, no matter which it is? Like being a Roman in Rome's heyday. The vast majority of people in history did not have that amount of freedom. Even today most don't. And if you're an American overseas and can't deal with the times America isn't on a winning streak, or you feel the taxes are too great a burden for you, or you can't trade the stocks on your app, I wish you the best of luck getting rid of that passport. Good riddance.
- redis_mlc 5y agoOne of the largest groups is retirees in Canada. Finding an accountant to do both US and Canada taxes is both difficult and expensive (over $2000/year), so they want to renounce ASAP. Also there's huge legal jeopardy for undeclared foreign retirement accounts.
- accidentalUSian 5y ago
- PhantomGremlin 5y agoThis isn't really about renouncing citizenship, it's more to do with how lazy and/or corrupt government employees are, and how we the sheeple have allowed them to get away with that for so long. For example, in Oregon, our Department of Motor Vehicles basically decided to shut down for 18 months. Good luck taking a driving test, transferring a car title, etc. In contrast, my local supermarket, staffed with people who are paid a pittance compared to government employees, didn't even have 18 hours of of downtime because of Covid, let alone 18 months. Doubtlessly all those "frightened" government employees were quite willing to take their full salaries during their high stress 18 month sabbaticals.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yob28 5y ago
- bmitc 5y agoDealing with the embassies and consulates during COVID is a nightmare. I was separated from my fiancée for 15 months due to consular ineptitude, mainly driven by higher level government policies on COVID. They even held my fiancée's passport, a non-US one, for over a month, which prevented her using the passport to travel to other countries to get back into the U.S. I've described it as intentional incompetence. We couldn't even sell her car due to lack of government support in terms of policies, so we were forced to pay for a car and insurance for a car we didn't want and wasn't being used. And I would say that COVID didn't start all this, it just gave these agencies another excuse. Even my application for Global Entry has been a nightmare, where it's been practically impossible to schedule an interview. I tried getting my application reviewed sooner by contacting the department twice before traveling back from a foreign country, because if you've been conditionally approved, you can interview upon return at the airport. I had applied like seven months before this international travel. I contacted them before leaving and then another time before I was coming back. They responded saying that there's nothing they can do, that I just need to wait. Well, they conditionally approved my application literally one day after I arrived back in the U.S. Since then, it has been impossible to schedule an interview, unless you want to drive eight hours and trust the appointment will be upheld, and they don't accept walk-ins. I've basically thrown away $100.
- MandieD 5y agoAnd people Back Home wonder why I never even attempted to put my husband through the whole Green Card process. Permanent residence in Germany was an absolute breeze, and all of the Foreigners’ Offices I’ve worked with have been anywhere from acceptably competent to outright helpful.
- vaidhy 5y agoHow did you get the global entry sorted out? My application is struck for last 2 years and you cannot withdraw the application either and reapply either.
- bingohbangoh 5y agoThe United States has been _uniquely incompetent_. Early on when the world was in flux circa March 2020, my friend needed to get in touch with the US embassy because countries were shutting down so suddenly. He was in Brazil at the time. The US embassy decided that day to close early due to concern about the pandemic and that they needed the off-office-hours time to work (or something like this). They wouldn't reopen for about a week. By contrast, my friends in the old country have had zero issues getting a hold of their embassies while living abroad. All very prompt. I had a passport renewal that took a month to process in the summer 2020. Very bizarre. This whole pandemic has made me blackpilled on the US.
- mpnex 5y agoGood luck with Social Security as well. As far as I can tell, their physical offices closed in March 2020 and haven't re-opened. My local office number will reliably drop my call after 10m 30s on hold (line just goes silent) and I have no idea how long hold times actually are on the nationwide number, but I've gotten to the 90 minute mark several times. It appears that you can do some select things online, but if not? Alternative is to send your documents (which usually involve things like passport, and sometimes state ID aka driver's license) and hope they'll return it in 10-14 days... Just putting both of those things in the same envelope seems like a huge risk to me. I've been able to submit civil court proceedings at my local district court (in CA), have them get processed and resolved. Sure, there was a break or two in there for temporary closures, and things got delayed. (It closed down for a while back in Dec 2020 but hearings were processed when it reopened in the spring, for example.) Point is, it still /happened/, even with some delay. So why can't the SSA or State Department process anything at all? The amount of institutional failure in the federal government offices right now is pretty alarming, and I haven't seen a lot of attention to this fact.
- olliej 5y agoSo convenient that they still have to pay taxes :-/
- Havoc 5y agoSame thing with other governments. UK side it took me year+ to get the equivalent of a SSN(NIN) and taxpayer number. Both of which are well establish processes requiring limited actual work. In contrast the EU settlement scheme process was fast and efficient despite being objectively more work to process (arbitrary pdfs like bank records, lease contracts etc that basically require human judgement) and obviously not battle tested. ...I conclude it is a matter of motivation. The latter had huge political exposure and pressure to make sure it gets done