3 ms·
Distinguishing correlation and causation is the constant challenge and peril of all social science research, where mechanisms are complex and measurements indir
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Distinguishing correlation and causation is the constant challenge and peril of all social science research, where mechanisms are complex and measurements indirect. There are a few methods which do offer some insight, the two most effective I'm aware of being identical-twin studies and qualification-test cut-off divisions.
In twin studies, the goal is to study twins (identical genetic inheritence) either from the same household (similar socioeconomic environment) or separate ones (often foster-parent settings or other forms of adoption), and comparing life trajectories, educational attainment, and employment history. I'm not specifically aware of education-related studies of this form, though I'd strongly recommend literature search (Google Scholar, etc.) on keywords such as "twin studies education".
On test-cutoff studies, there was one I ran across recently in which individuals who tested just at the cutoff of the qualification threshold for advanced academy entrance. That is, students scoring above the threshold attended the schools, those below did not. The findings were of comparable subsequent lifetime attainments (employment, income), suggesting that innate ability was a stronger predictor than educational history. I can't find the study presently, though I'm pretty certain it addressed the Specialised High Schools Admission Test (SHSAT):
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialized_High_Schools_Admissions_Test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialized_High_Schools_Admis...
Far more studies look at basic demographic or geographic data. To a large extent this constitutes an availability heuristic: the data are far more abundant and more readily available. How predictive they are on a causality basis is harder to determine. One example (turned up whilst searching for the entrance-exam study):
"Money, Race and Success: How Your School District Compares" (2016)
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/04/29/upshot/money-race-and-success-how-your-school-district-compares.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/04/29/upshot/money-...
Another school of thought (so to speak) is on what education's impact socially is, at least along economic-performance measures. (There are of course other legitimate outcomes of education, including its roles in culture and democratic institutions.) Such viewpoints often come from the right, though may also be found among more liberal economists. One such, Ha-Joon Chang addresses this in chapter 17 of 23 Things They Don't Tell You About Capitalism, "More education itself is not going to make a country richer" (2010). Dr. Ha-Joon notes that:
1. Many poor countries have high educational attainment.
2. Many rich countries have comparatively low attainment.
3. Numerous countries (particularly in east / southeast Asia) have made remarkable economic progress without especially high educational attainment.
4. Mechanisation has a far greater impact on per-worker productivity than education.
5. Businesses generally prefer de-skilling work in order to make labour more substitutable. This of course reduces the benefits of education.
Additional points (Ha-Joon does not address these directly) are that infrastructure counts for a great deal, and "brain drain" --- economic migration by the more educated --- can siphon off a country's most educated citizens, essentially subsidising the economies of other countries.
See: https://www.worldcat.org/title/twenty-three-things-they-dont-tell-you-about-capitalism/oclc/1090920534 https://www.worldcat.org/title/twenty-three-things-they-dont...
Among Ha-Joon's more interesting citations:
L. Pritchett, "Where has all the education gone?", The World Bank Economic Review, 2001, vol. 13, no. 3. https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/859821468180273788/pdf/773740JRN020010l0the0Education0Gone.pdf https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/85982146818027378... (PDF)
Harry Braverman, Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century (1974) https://nyupress.org/9780853459408/labor-and-monopoly-capital/ https://nyupress.org/9780853459408/labor-and-monopoly-capita...
Stephen Marglin, "What do Bosses Do?", published in two parts in The Review of Radical Political Economy, 1974, 1975. https://scholar.harvard.edu/marglin/publications/what-do-bosses-do https://scholar.harvard.edu/marglin/publications/what-do-bos... https://scholar.harvard.edu/marglin/publications/what-do-bosses-do-part-ii https://scholar.harvard.edu/marglin/publications/what-do-bos...
- gnicholas 5y ago> The findings were of comparable subsequent lifetime attainments (employment, income), suggesting that innate ability was a stronger predictor than educational history. I can't find the study presently, though I'm pretty certain it addressed the Specialised High Schools Admission Test (SHSAT) Isn't the SHSAT a test that measures a mix of innate ability and effort expended learning (both in general, and prepping for the SHSAT)?
- dredmorbius 5y agoThat's not what the study is assessing. Rather, it's looking at individuals with all-but-identical scores on the admissions exam, but on either side of the admissions line, one of whom attended a specialised high school, and one of whom did not. The difference in scores is well within the measurement error of the exam itself. (Caveat: If I'm remembering the study correctly.) That is: even if test prep is a factor in score, the scores considered were not differentiated, and those meeting or failing the cut-off could have equivalent access to test prep. I don't know whether or not such prep was specifically considered, and would have to track down the study to confirm or deny.