5 ms·
> One of my biggest pet peeves is when I tell a mom something her son did and she turns, looks at him and asks, "Is that true?" Well, of course it's true. I'd
by peteretep 15y ago
> One of my biggest pet peeves is when I tell a mom something her son did and she turns, looks at him and asks, "Is that true?" Well, of course it's true.
I'd almost certainly ask my son that. Seems like a good way to get them talking about the issue, and hear any mitigating factors they might consider. A teacher who took that as a me questioning their authority ... grow up and deal with it.
- mavelikara 15y agoWhile I agree with many points the article raised, > Well, of course it's true. I just told you. this is a very dangerous attitude for a teacher to have. Aristotle said that men have more teeth than women, but that does not make it so.
- sliverstorm 15y agoMy mother is a teacher, and she has several anecdotes about teachers falling into traps like this. My favorite: Teacher, to parent: "(You need to listen to me.) Who do you think knows your child better? Me, or you!?"
- mavelikara 15y agoI was not advocating taking the child's word over the teacher's. What I found disturbing, as I explained elsewhere in the thread, is the teacher getting upset by the very act of me asking my child's opinion about the incident at hand.
- slmbrhrt 15y agoThey're not speaking as a teacher, but as a person with integrity, someone who endeavors to tell only the truth, especially in a situation as grave as the discipline of a child under their watch.
- ZipCordManiac 15y agoThey are human like the rest of us, good and bad. Do not assume integrity simply because of somebodies profession.
- slmbrhrt 15y agoI already said the profession wasn't part of the consideration. Asking the child if what the teacher said is true is seen as an affront on the author's character as a person, not as a teacher, so it's reasonable for them to take offense at the accusation. It's entirely reasonable not to trust the teacher's authority by default--I'm not challenging that. I'm only defending the author's position on taking offense to being challenged on something that was just said.
- mavelikara 15y agoYes, I understand. After all, I am paying for their professional, expert advice about my child and I want to give it due consideration. Nonetheless, I want to give my child a fair chance to explain her side too. If I do not do that, I fear that it will alienate my child from me. So I seek her opinion. Of course, once I hear her side, I will not trust her blindly either. The very act of doing this seems to irritate the author - which I find very disturbing. Trust, but verify, is the principle here.
- scarmig 15y agoIt's definitely pretty thin-skinned for the teacher to get upset over that. The reason that the teacher sees that repeatedly is that its an effective technique. It establishes a level of trust between the child and parent--the parent is willing to hear out the kid. And it immediately puts the kid in a tough position unless s/he fesses up to the misdeed. Getting buy-in from the child about the legitimacy of what's happening is very useful when trying to figure out how to deal with it. Of course, implicitly by asking for the kid's word that this happened the parent is opening up the possibility that the teacher is lying. But it's necessary, and even if the kid rejected it I'm sure most parents would almost certainly still believe the teacher's narrative. It's just a pro-forma verbal tactic to get appropriate buy-in from the child. I'm not surprised that a teacher would superficially feel a bit miffed by that, but they should understand and (however grudgingly) accept the reasons its helpful.
- lucasjung 15y agoI had a teacher in elementary school who regularly asserted that I had done things which I had not. She wasn't directly lying: there was another boy who I did not get along well with (to put it mildly), and he would regularly tell her lies about things I had (not) done, and she would always take his word because they were German and I was American, even though he had been caught lying about me repeatedly. I was actually referred to social services based on a track record of fictitious misbehavior, and was evaluated by a government psychologist. She was extremely puzzled by the disconnect between my official record and her observations of me, so she pushed to bring the other boy in for evaluation. I don't know the details, but he disappeared from our school shortly after the psychologist evaluated him. Unfortunately, that just made the teacher hate me even more, so while I no longer had someone making up stories about me, every minor infraction was blown out of proportion and reported to my parents with significant embellishments. Bottom line: not only is it a good way to engage with the child, sometimes the teacher really is making false accusations.
- ams6110 15y agoRather than ask "is that true," ask: "what do you have to say about that". Will achieve the same effect without putting the teacher on the defensive.
- lightcatcher 15y agoI can barely see how the teacher would find this mildly offensive. What's wrong with the parent obtaining more perspectives on an event? The wording of "is this true" is a bit odd, because its very unlikely the student would just say "no". There is almost definitely some explanation required. Hearing the student's opinion is valuable on its own, and parents don't ask to test the integrity of the teacher. Also, it has some value by making the student admit his actions.