3 ms·
I think the problem is that the main way of testing for Lyme is to test for the antibodies. So what if you fall in the 20%? How will you know? You'll still end
by giantg2 5y ago
I think the problem is that the main way of testing for Lyme is to test for the antibodies. So what if you fall in the 20%? How will you know? You'll still end up being treating whether vaccinated or not.
- coolso 5y ago> You'll still end up being treating whether vaccinated or not. Isn’t the typical treatment a course of antibiotics? In other words the risks from being “unnecessarily” treated should be fairly low.
- throwawayboise 5y agoAny unnecessary use of antibiotics should be avoided, as it can create an environment for the development of antibiotic-resistant bacteria.
- coolso 5y agoYes, but I believe the most common antibiotics prescribed for Lyme disease are doxycycline and monocycline, two antibiotics that are used by millions daily (on a somewhat long-term basis) already for the management of things like acne. While certainly not ideal, with 8 million prescriptions in the US alone, I'm not sure an additional potentially unnecessary course of doxycycline is the worst thing in the world when compared to the possibility that the alternative is full blown Lyme disease.
- giantg2 5y agoIt's sort of the inverse. If you're treated either way, then the vaccine is unnecessary. There are risks, even if rare, associated with vaccines. Basically, there's no value added and a very slight increase of risks.
- CorrectHorseBat 5y agoCould we not check for the type of antibodies just like we do with covid?
- steffen84 5y agoThis how it’s done in germany. Just got tested for Lyme disease. Tick bite was in late summer no rash. The skin in the area changed to red/blue after 5 months, so i got tested and the test was positive. Antibodies IgG 46, IgM 5. Now 3 weeks of antibiotics.
- theptip 5y agoI’m far more more concerned about “undetected tick bite => lifetime incurable Lyme disease” than “detected tick bite => unnecessary course of antibiotics”.
- inglor_cz 5y agoLast summer, I noticed an odd spot on a leg of my female colleague when she arrived at work in a short skirt. Fortunately, we are good friends and I could tell her without any kind of trouble. Yes, she had a tick on that precise place a week before. Yes, it looked like erythema migrans, a typical early sign of a Lyme infection (borreliosis). No, she never heard about that and was a bit reluctant about doing anything about it. Yes, I persuaded her to see her doctor now. She got antibiotics immediately and seems to be fine.
- giantg2 5y agoThat makes sense, except how does one have an undetected tick bite?
- theptip 5y agoOne reason Lyme disease is so scary is that it’s really common to not notice that you got bit. How often do you inspect the back of your knees? (If you live in tick country, it should be “every time you get back from being in the woods”, but many don’t know/practice this.) It’s a common story to hear about people who don’t connect the dots, and don’t get properly diagnosed early when it’s more treatable.
- giantg2 5y agoOk... and you think the people that don't know to check for ticks will know to get a Lyme vaccine? This doesn't seem logical to me. Most people in those environments know to check for ticks in my experience. The ones who don't are not the type to request a vaccine that they probably don't even know about.
- 5y ago