3 ms·
Why would a vaccine only be useful if it stops the spread? It's a medical treatment like any other, and we universally recognize the importance of medical treat
by woodruffw 5y ago
Why would a vaccine only be useful if it stops the spread? It's a medical treatment like any other, and we universally recognize the importance of medical treatments that reduce severe illnesses to manageable levels even when they are not themselves cures.
(And moreover, this has been true for all vaccines ever made: no vaccine guarantees 100% protection from its illness, but nearly all significantly reduce the severity of breakthrough cases.)
Edit: to emphasize: there are other ways to prevent severe illness from COVID, like monoclonal antibodies (at least, the ones that still work against Omicron). But none of them counter what you've posited (making pharma companies money), and none have as mature, reliable, and freely available of a supply as do vaccines.
- kyruzic 5y agoBecause as I said, there are other treatments that are effective at treating covid. We can simply use those instead without need for mandates.
- woodruffw 5y agoCould you elaborate on which treatments you think those are? I'm aware of monoclonal antibodies and other antiviral treatments, which are generally more difficult and expensive to distribute compared to vaccines, and are more susceptive to variant changes. To reiterate: that doesn't mean that people shouldn't get antibody treatments, only that we should continue to practice "needs based" care: vaccinate everyone, and use the more drastic (expensive, logistically complex) treatments on those who need it the most.