3 ms·
Well... Let us assume that 1) the more people who get vaccinated, the less the disease spreads through the population, 2) the old are at greater risk from the
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
Well...
Let us assume that 1) the more people who get vaccinated, the less the disease spreads through the population, 2) the old are at greater risk from the disease, 3) the young are at greater risk from the vaccine than they are from the disease. And 4), which is not an assumption, that the young have more to lose - if they die, they miss more of the life they could have had; if they have permanent damage, they have to live with the damage for longer.
Should we ask the young to take the risk? It depends on how much risk they face from the vaccine, and how much the vaccine reduces the spread (and therefore the risk to the old). Does the total damage (measured in "quality years of life lost" or some such) increase or decrease if we vaccinate the young? I don't know if we have the data to answer the question; I'm fairly certain that if we do have the data, it isn't solid yet (that is, it could significantly change as we get better data).
Should we force the young to take the risk? That's a similar question, but the standard for "forcing" should be significantly higher than the standard for "asking". (In the same way, we'll draft the young if the military situation is dire enough, but until then, we have a volunteer military.)