3 ms·
How do you go to jail if there is no one to sue you?
by charcircuit 5y ago
How do you go to jail if there is no one to sue you?
- shakna 5y agoWinnie-the-Pooh hasn't belonged to the Milne estate for a very long time. Most of the rights rest with Disney. The estate has been involved in a multi-decade legal battle to get the books back, so that they could be released to the public domain. Source - I'm a Milne.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kragen 5y agoYou can't go to jail in the US or most countries for a civil case (a civil case is what happens if someone sues you), only a criminal case. Since the No Electronic Theft act, even copyright infringement without profit motives can be criminal copyright infringement, and so for example Aaron Swartz was hounded to suicide by state prosecutors even against the apparent will of the copyright holders. I don't know who owns Milne's copyrights, but given how profitable they are, I am sure they are jealously guarded.
- Spooky23 5y agoThe Swartz case was more about an overzealous US Attorney looking for scalps than copyright. It also highlights the ridiculously broad law at the Federal level that essentially allow US Attorneys to function like medieval inquisitors than prosecutors of a democratic state. Copyright happened to be the pretense.
- vanderZwan 5y agoI would be very surprised if the Disney company wouldn't be protective of their adaptations, at the very least. How would that interact with the book and its illustrations entering the public domain?
- kragen 5y agoIt's going to be interesting. Most of the copyright infringement going on is clearly of Disney's adaptations; so, for example, when a couple sold me a house in 01999 with a Pooh painting on the wall of the children's room, that was probably criminal copyright infringement of Disney's version, because the painting looked nothing like the illustrations in the books. (And I'm sure she didn't get a license from Disney to do her painting.) This legal situation is appalling; it makes a mockery of justice and humanity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Jon_Lowtek 5y ago> that was probably criminal copyright infringement sounds more like "Fair Use", unless you imply the painting was made for the purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain. As in: they painted it right before selling and used the image to advertise the house to young couples.
- kragen 5y agoPossibly. The thing about fair use is that you can never really tell. Commercial intent is only one of the four factors. The market-effect factor would also weigh in her favor. The other two factors — the nature of the work and the substantiality of the copying — plausibly weigh against her. Of course I don't think she'll be prosecuted, or I wouldn't think about posting this, but that's partly because she's not a well-known political dissident who the FBI has a pre-existing grudge against.
- axiosgunnar 5y ago
- dang 5y agoAttacking another user like this will get you banned here, regardless of how you feel about their taste in date formats. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.
- pjc50 5y agoActually getting jailed for copyright infringement is quite difficult, but getting sued is quite likely: the copyright is now owned by Disney. Like everything else. (Weirdly, the UK has a special law granting permanent copyright in Peter Pan, with the royalties going to Great Ormond Street children's hospital. https://www.gosh.org/about-us/peter-pan/copyright/ https://www.gosh.org/about-us/peter-pan/copyright/ )
- kragen 5y agoHopefully it isn't actually quite likely that you will get sued for copyright infringement just for copying some files onto a USB stick. That would involve the use of something like Apple's dystopian surveillance system being used for copyright enforcement, which I think is still two or three years out.
- lr1970 5y ago> Actually getting jailed for copyright infringement is quite difficult... May be actually getting in jail is difficult but a threat of jail in a criminal copyright infringement persecution can be devastating as the tragedy of Aaron Swartz [0] so vividly illustrates [1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Swartz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Swartz