3 ms·
Why does that need to be an either/or situation? The US government has made it abundantly clear that printing money is not a problem. The government could ver
by _heimdall 5y ago
Why does that need to be an either/or situation? The US government has made it abundantly clear that printing money is not a problem. The government could very easily move all student debt and homelessness-related debt (if that can be tracked down and categorized) onto their own books to keep the securities propped up without ever actually collecting on the debt.
Also, you are being very dismissive of student debt. Yes some people go to college and party for 4 years, but saying that means everyone with student debt should be left out in the cold is no different than saying welfare should be abolished because some people take advantage of it. That's a totally reasonable stance to take, but you can't easily make your argument against student debt without throwing out all other needs based government aid since it can go to those who you don't think deserve it.
- fortran77 5y ago> The US government has made it abundantly clear that printing money is not a problem. Well, it is. We have inflation. But one alternative (helping homeless persons get back into society) may increase our tax base, and the other is just a handout for privileged people who got to go to college.
- _heimdall 5y ago> Well, it is. We have inflation. That's a whole other can of worms. Do you trust how inflation is calculated, and agree that the basket of goods used for the CPI is a valid measure of consumer prices across the country in all kinds of different situations? There were plenty of people warning of inflation before the money was created last year, do you think the government actually didn't know the risk existed? Or did they decide to spend the money despite the risk of inflation, meaning they determined printing the money wasn't a problem? I'm torn here cause I 100% agree that we should be helping the homeless if at all possible. I just can't say the problem is as easy as wiping away debt - these are massive, complex systems that can't be easily understood and modeled. In the meantime, an easy step that I think everyone would agree with is to not allow these types of predatory debts to exist in the first place. As for student debt, I'm not sure what your experience has been that lead you to view college loans as a privileged handout but I have seen plenty of situations where that wasn't the case. Spending four years on a degree only to end up with a job at Enterprise Rental Cars and $80k in debt is not a privilege. To be clear, I only call out Enterprise here because they spent years marketing themselves as the largest employer of new college graduates. Nothing against a job there, it actually seems like a well run company and I would argue the thankless service position behind the counter is way more difficult and important than many office jobs I've seen. But the idea that they are (or were) the largest employer of new grads is terrible.
- raffraffraff 5y agoThe idea that someone can get a huge loan and walk away from it... Great for them, but what about all the other people who have loans? Do they get to walk away too? Had anyone worked out how it's supposed to work? Where is the a detailed paper explaining the legal/social implications? Or, wait, is "cancel student debt" just another Twitter soundbyte that a million people liked and retweeted, but nobody has thought through? For the record, I think that the cost of education in the US is ridiculous, and I don't understand why people put up with it. But making selective debts simply disappear? "Hmmmmm" If America started out by making education free (at least for your first run thorough college), then there may be a case to make for debt forgiveness for recent graduates. Otherwise I can't see how this is supposed to work. It's feels kinda like notions like "property is theft". I'm from a country with a reasonable social net, free-ish healthcare! I'm all-ears! Go on! Explain how this is supposed to works without causing a civil war? Who exactly has the right to live in this the house I paid for?
- _heimdall 5y agoI 100% agree with you hear. I have never actually understood the argument for how cancelling debt could work, my point was only that it can technically be done and in fact wouldn't be the first instance of the US government taking on bad debt to prop up markets. I've seen first hand how willing the education, banking, and political systems are to pile student debt on people who can never reasonably afford it. The check on bad debt, though, is supposed to be lender risk. When a failed loan directly hits the lender's books they are more careful about what loans they write. The government helped ruin the housing market by effectively underwriting ever bad loan. They've done the same with the college loan market. To tour point, no one can possibly know what blowback there would be by cancelling loans. They government could sweep up the loans to protect any securities backed by them, but that adds even more federal debt and creates securities markets that are truly based on smoke and mirrors. Allowing those loans to be closed or moved without default also gives a green light to the banking industry to keep writing more and more bad student loans, and to the colleges to keep increasing tuition and fees.
- CogitoCogito 5y agoMany kinds of loans can be discharged in bankruptcy and no civil wars have broken out to date (for that reason). So for a start, changes could be made to allow student loans to be more easily discharged as well.