4 ms·
Still, it is interesting to look at questions that most people failed. Apparently in the 2003 round of evaluations only 16% of participants could answer the que
by jeffbee 5y ago
Still, it is interesting to look at questions that most people failed. Apparently in the 2003 round of evaluations only 16% of participants could answer the question "What is the purpose of the Se Habla Espanol expo?" after reading this short magazine article.
https://nces.ed.gov/NAAL/sample_imgtxtequiv.asp?Imageid=164 https://nces.ed.gov/NAAL/sample_imgtxtequiv.asp?Imageid=164
- jakear 5y agoI love that the article I presume you got that from [1] states: > Acceptable answers include statement such as: > To enable people to better serve and sell to the Hispanic community; to improve marketing strategies to the Hispanic community; and to enable people to establish contacts to serve the Hispanic community. Which is not only grammatically incorrect, but grammatically incorrect to the point of message-shattering ambiguity. Is the triplet of statements required for an acceptable answer, or would any individual statement from that list suffice? If all three would be required I doubt I'd have been marked correct - I would have just listed the most important one then moved on to the next question. [1] https://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/07/stupider-than-you-realize.html https://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/07/stupider-than-you-rea... (first search result for "Se Habla Español Hits Chicago" besides the link you gave)
- thaumasiotes 5y agoAny individual statement from the list will suffice. This is already clear in the Overcoming Bias post, but it's equally clear in the source, which says this: > Correct Answer: > Any statement such as the following: to enable people to better serve and sell to the Hispanic community; to improve marketing strategies to the Hispanic community; and to enable people to establish contacts to serve the Hispanic community It is technically true that "Acceptable answers include statement such as:" is grammatically incorrect, but the error is so obvious that it would normally be called a "typo" and not a "grammatical error".
- jakear 5y agoWhat "source" is this? I found https://nces.ed.gov/Pubs2007/2007480_3.pdf https://nces.ed.gov/Pubs2007/2007480_3.pdf, which is considerably more clear as it lists the three statements as entirely separate list items: > Any statement such as the following: > To enable people to better serve and sell to the Hispanic community > To improve marketing strategies to the Hispanic community > To enable people to establish contacts to serve the Hispanic community I truly disbelieve you can claim in good faith that that is "equally clear" as: > Acceptable answers include statement such as: > To enable people to better serve and sell to the Hispanic community; to improve marketing strategies to the Hispanic community; and to enable people to establish contacts to serve the Hispanic community. I think interpreting the semi-colon'd sentence as a single "statement", especially given the ambiguity introduced by their grammatical error, is entirely reasonable. I was genuinely unsure as to the correct interpretation. Who's to say that the correct edit is adding an `s` to the end of `statement` versus adding an `a ` to its beginning?
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe source is the same one linked in the post you're trying to slam. The URL has changed from http://nces.ed.gov/NAAL/sample_question.asp http://nces.ed.gov/NAAL/sample_question.asp , as written in the post, to https://nces.ed.gov/naal/sample_items.asp https://nces.ed.gov/naal/sample_items.asp . You can easily find the question by using the Text String Search field. > I was genuinely unsure as to the correct interpretation. Who's to say You're arguing at the level of this handless guy now. https://xkcd.com/169/ https://xkcd.com/169/
- jakear 5y agoYou seem to be confusing your argument for my own. I'm the one claiming that the text is ambiguous and shouldn't be, you seem to be outright denying that it's ambiguous at all? You're the handless guy feeling smug about their innate knowledge that the author's intention was "Acceptable answers include statements such as:" rather than "Acceptable answers include a statement such as:", I'm the top-hat dude calling you out.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- marcus0x62 5y agoI would question how many people "failed" to answer this question because of poor literacy versus a lack of domain knowledge in the subject matter. The article is full of sales and marketing jargon that most people -- in my experience -- just don't have experience with.
- jeffbee 5y agoIt has the same fundamental problem as standardized tests that frame questions around how many polo ponies Alistair and Theodora have at their summer stables. Some people are disadvantages by having just literally no idea what the passage is talking about.
- hervature 5y agoI cannot even find one piece of jargon in that passage. Here is a list of marketing jargon [1]. Just because you are not exposed to a topic does not make any conversation about the topic contain jargon. If I say "baseball is a sport where you use a bat to hit a ball to score points", the word "bat" is not jargon because we only use that definition in the context of sports. [1] - https://www.precisionmarketinggroup.com/blog/a-quick-glossary-of-marketing-jargon-for-the-inexperienced-marketer https://www.precisionmarketinggroup.com/blog/a-quick-glossar...
- marcus0x62 5y ago> I cannot even find one piece of jargon in that passage. "the Hispanic market." "brand conscious" "brand loyal" ""It’s all contacts . . . contacts . . . contacts!"" "media play" "sponsor visibility" > Just because you are not exposed to a topic does not make any conversation about the topic contain jargon That is true. It is also true that people who are familiar with a particular subject and vernacular tend to not recognize when they aren't explaining something clearly. (For the record, I've worked in sales, alongside marketing colleagues, for almost 20 years.) > If I say "baseball is a sport where you use a bat to hit a ball to score points", the word "bat" is not jargon because we only use that definition in the context of sports. At no point does the article contain anything like a clear description analogous to your example.
- darkerside 5y agoWhat percentage of people started reading that crap and quickly decided, I don't care?