3 ms·
If you compare Apple TV to what it could be, or what you might have expected out of Apple given their reputation, it's pretty meh. If you compare it to a typic
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
If you compare Apple TV to what it could be, or what you might have expected out of Apple given their reputation, it's pretty meh.
If you compare it to a typical smart TV, it's pretty okay, because a typical smart TV is designed by a distracted child and shipped without testing and any customer bug reports are sent directly to an incinerator.
But that shouldn't be the bar.
- tptacek 5y agoI honestly don't know what more I could realistically ask of my Apple TV. It's got device-wide search over all the services/apps I have installed. It plays all the music in my Apple Music account and keeps playlists synced. It does Airplay and Screen Mirroring from all my devices. It has a rock solid phone remote app. There's really only so much I need my TV to do; I don't immediately see what else Apple TV could do without trying to build a half-assed PS5 or Xbox One. It's a weird thing, to me, to be jaded about. There's a lot to be said for just getting the job done and getting out of my way.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoI think the comparison to the game consoles is the problem, because it isn't one. But if it's just Apple's version of a Chromecast then why does it cost five times as much?
- tptacek 5y agoExtremely good remote (both the physical remote and the apps), several HD movies worth of disk space, gigabit ethernet. You can probably get all of that from a Roku device that costs half as much as the Apple TV, and if price is most of what you care about, you should do that. My point is that ~$200 is basically below the noise floor for this kind of component; you're going to use it every time you use the TV, or, for that matter, play music in your living room. It earns its keep.
- piva00 5y agoAnd contrary to many other consumer gadgets/electronics, it holds its usefulness for long. My mom still uses my old Apple TV 3rd gen as she doesn't need more than Full HD resolution, it's been 9 years since I bought it. My current Apple TV 4K 1st gen is perfectly capable for everything I've used it for the past 4 years, and I see it lasting another 5-6 at least.