2 ms·
The example from [1] is misleading because it assumes that multiple ECC errors will hit the same block, which is unlikely in practice. It also assumes that the
by wmf 5y ago
The example from [1] is misleading because it assumes that multiple ECC errors will hit the same block, which is unlikely in practice. It also assumes that the alternative to ZFS is hardware RAID which might have applied to servers ten years ago but is not the case now.
- j1elo 5y agoThis question doesn't seem to be getting any traction so thanks for getting to write and pointing that out. I'll keep looking for resources to learn about pitfalls of ZFS on small device setups like mine
- db48x 5y agoMy recommendation is to use ECC memory on _all_ of your computers, no matter what you use them for. Spend the extra $50 or $100 or whatever on ECC ram; it is worth it. > I might prefer running Ext4 with something like hashdeep [6], so I can detect the issue […] This setup will have the same risks plus more. I know that the article you read says that this risk applies to all ZFS implementations, but you should not take that to mean that it doesn’t also apply to other forms of redundancy. If you don’t have ECC memory, then that is the weakest link in the chain of custody (as it were) for your data.