6 ms·
Clearly, GCC needs a new GPL licensing exception: "You acknowledge that the Program is not designed or intended for use in the design, construction, operation o
by zozbot234 5y ago
Clearly, GCC needs a new GPL licensing exception: "You acknowledge that the Program is not designed or intended for use in the design, construction, operation or maintenance of any nuclear facility." If Java does it...
- Jach 5y agoSeems useless given the existing clauses with the disclaimer of warranty and limitation of liability.
- iso1631 5y agoWhy? GPL is a license to permit you to modify and distribute the source code which is normally illegal under copyright law. Nothing more, nothing less.
- st_goliath 5y ago> Nothing more, nothing less. Well actually, 2 more things: distribute the modifications as well, and to use it without restrictions (Well that, plus making sure anybody who gets a copy gets the same rights). The latter of the two points happens to be the retroactively added freedom #0 in the FSF's definition of free software[0], which is also repeated in the GPL license text, IIRC somewhere at the top. The Open Source Definition used by the OSI has clauses to a similar effect (See points 5 and 6)[1]. GP's suggestion, adding restrictions on how the software could be used, would run counter to that, conflicting with the very philosophy from which the GPL originates. Bruce Perens, who originally wrote the Debian Free Software Guidelines[4] (the OSI OSD is based on that), also commented on that in 2019, when the idea to put forward to add ethics based usage restrictions to software licenses[2][3]. [0] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html [1] https://opensource.org/osd https://opensource.org/osd [2] https://perens.com/2019/09/23/sorry-ms-ehmke-the-hippocratic-license-cant-work/ https://perens.com/2019/09/23/sorry-ms-ehmke-the-hippocratic... [3] https://perens.com/2019/10/12/invasion-of-the-ethical-licenses/ https://perens.com/2019/10/12/invasion-of-the-ethical-licens... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debian_Free_Software_Guidelines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debian_Free_Software_Guideline...
- iso1631 5y ago17 U.S. Code § 117 means any copying of the program from disk into memory (for example) is not a copyright breach, therefore you do not need to agree to a license like the GPL to run a copyrighted program, only to create additional copies. Therefore any term saying "You acknowledge that the Program is not designed or intended for use in the design, construction, operation or maintenance of any nuclear facility" Would be completely meaningless as you wouldn't have to agree to it to run the software.
- janto 5y agoWell, they might need to distribute the code on the "device" it's running on :P
- marcodiego 5y agoGPL is a free software license. For a license to be a free software license, it must guarantee the 4 essential freedoms: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html#four-freedoms https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html#four-freedoms
- chrsig 5y agoGNU generally considers those types of clauses in opposition to libre software[0] [0] https://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-list.html#JSON https://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-list.html#JSON
- jahewson 5y agoAs phrased in the parent comment it’s a disclaimer, not a restriction. So it’s acceptable but carries no weight.
- biryani_chicken 5y agoThat would stop the GPL from being a FLOSS license, which would be against the philosophy of its authors.
- zozbot234 5y agoNope, it wouldn't. It's already implied by the general disclaimer of warranty in existing FLOSS licenses; adding that express provision would merely bring some much-needed clarity.
- marcodiego 5y agoThat clause would hurt freedom 0: the freedom to user the software for whatever you want.
- zozbot234 5y agoHow so? "You acknowledge that X is not designed or intended for use in Y" is not a restriction on using X for Y: it's just telling you in no uncertain terms that the developers of X will not be helping you with any issues if it turns out you are using it for Y. This looks like the exact situation that OP is in, and that the Java provision is designed to guard against.
- InGoodFaith 5y agoThe confusion stems from how you initially worded it as > GPL licensing exception If you instead replaced "exception" with a warranty disclaimer then your intent would've been more clear in your original post.
- Arch-TK 5y agoI think everyone misunderstood your suggestion as an ethics clause when in reality it's just fluff, as you state later, something to this effect is already mentioned in the warranty clause. But, I should point out: Someone can acknowledge that something is not designed or intended for a certain purpose but then recognize that despite this, it is perfectly suitable for it. i.e. a butter knife is neither designed nor intended for opening paint cans, but it's perfectly suitable for the task (at least some are). Moreover, as software is not often stationary these days, what something is designed or intended for changes over time. Does this clause mean that no patches which intend to make the software explicitly usable in the context of a nuclear facility will ever be accepted? Does everyone sign a document saying: "While writing this patch, I made sure that I didn't accidentally think about nuclear facilities and how this patch may make the software more useful in those contexts." ?