4 ms·
> The HDMI Forum’s argument is that ... that optional features allow manufacturers to have flexibility in what functionality they offer... > That argument does
by xg15 5y ago
> The HDMI Forum’s argument is that ... that optional features allow manufacturers to have flexibility in what functionality they offer...
> That argument doesn’t really hold up, though. The whole point of standards is that they’re meant to simplify this sort of thing by, you know, standardizing it across devices — if you have to dig into a spec sheet to figure out if the specific refresh rate feature you want is supported on a new TV, why bother with the HDMI 2.x branding in the first place?
I wonder if the Forum has much of an option here. Standards are not laws and if a standard mandates features that manufacturers are not interested in, they can and will break it without consequences.
So, it might be that the actual choice was between "chaotic incompatible mess" and "chaotic incompatible mess with some semblance of structure".
I have no understanding for the brand confusion though. That was already a horrible idea with USB and it doesn't become less horrible by repetition.
- netizen-936824 5y agoHow about making different specs for different features instead of lumping everything under "HDMI 2.1a" It smells like another episode of USB C 3.2 and their handling of video capabilities Re: a shitshow
- xg15 5y agoIt's still a single cable, so all the features will necessarily be interconnected with each other. Of course you could make an "extension standard" instead of a whole new version, but I don't see how that would make any difference except in formalities.