4 ms·
> Suddenly, in a Ph.D - not only do you not know the answer, you don't know the question too. Mirroring what tasogare said: There are a lot of research profess
by BeetleB 5y ago
> Suddenly, in a Ph.D - not only do you not know the answer, you don't know the question too.
Mirroring what tasogare said: There are a lot of research professors who will not give you the flexibility of finding the question. They often are paying you to be an RA, and will want you to work on their topics, not yours.
This may vary per discipline. In the circles I was in, this was the norm, though. Some professors were open to you choosing your own topic, but the "contract" was similar: If they are funding your research, then you should work on your own topic "on your own time".
- yt-sdb 5y agoI'd frame it this way: a good senior researcher knows when to give a junior researcher the question or not. First-year grad student? Pair them off with a postdoc for fast iterating on an established project. Fourth-year grad student? Push them by letting them flounder a bit and learn to find their own questions. I agree that in practice, this simply varies a lot by discipline and advisor.
- mirker 5y agoYou missed the most fun option: pair them up with a problem that leads to nowhere!
- tchalla 5y agoI know what you and tasogare refer to and I've seen it happen. I had to fight to change my thesis topic 3 times and also change advisors. Of course, it is not simple. I wouldn't change anything from my initial comment though. Flexibility is not binary - it's a gray scale. If you have ZERO flexibility, you should accept the implication that such a Ph.D will be stripped of some valuable lessons. On the other hand, you can always decide to not do it and move to a different professor. You could also decide if the broad area is ok with you before you take an admission to a lab.