6 ms·
I think what many here and the writers of the article are missing is that you can both be truthful and misleading. These are not mutually exclusive. Let's start
by godelski 5y ago
I think what many here and the writers of the article are missing is that you can both be truthful and misleading. These are not mutually exclusive. Let's start with the title: "The Study That Convinced the CDC To Support Mask Mandates in Schools Is Junk Science". If you just read this (titles are very important and most people only read these) what will you take away? What the authors are trying to say is that this one study has problems.
But reading further in the article they rise doubt about masks in general, which is something we know is highly effective (purely from a physics point of view). They don't say masking is effective, they continually question if it is. This is really problematic. The study being wrong doesn't question _if_ masking is effective, but _how_ effective. There's a major difference in these statements and they can have readers, who are not experts and don't know scientific vernacular, to doubt and distrust more science than the article _technically_ draws into question. The article is suggesting that this is the norm and because this study is bad we get to question all the others.
So the problem here really is that while yes, the article only questions the one study they do so in a way that questions more fundamental knowledge that we have. Masking works. How much? Harder to say. There's a few old sayings such as "the devil never tells a full lie" or "the devil sows doubt" (often with truth). These are the errors that the authors are making here.
I would conclude that they aren't inaccurate, but are misleading.
- goodluckchuck 5y ago
- crisdux 5y agoYou are coming to this article with your own biases. You seem to be basing your analysis that we "know" masking is highly effective. That is not true. The evidence used to justify this policy is low quality(don't you remember the CDC hair salon study) and dependent on the precautionary principle. High quality evidence on masking has either low effect sizes or is inconclusive. It is certainly not settled science.
- flerchin 5y agoWe do know masks prevent the spread disease. Look in any Operating Room. If masking by the general public is shown to be ineffective, that only argues for further education on how to mask properly.
- crisdux 5y agoYou are obviously conflating the use of surgical masks in operating rooms that are for stopping droplets with using masks to stop a respiratory airborne virus. How can this possibly be the basis of your argument? It's utter nonsense.
- harpersealtako 5y agoI see the "surgeons use masks in operating rooms, this proves public masking prevents the spread of COVID" argument nearly every time a mask debate appears on this site or others, and it just seems so...obviously fallacious and absurd to me on a dozen different levels, that I almost feel like I'm missing some fundamental point about it.
- mike00632 5y agoThe point is that masks are obviously effective. It requires a lot of mental gymnastics to reach the conclusion that masks are not effective despite the overwhelming evidence in support of masks. Even the Reason article admits that masks are effective despite its misleading headline that suggests masks are not effective.
- harpersealtako 5y agoI would like you to consider the possibility that the evidence in favor of masks is probably overwhelming as you might believe. The studies that have been done have so many cofounders as to be flawed at best, useless at worst. The "overwhelming evidence" line not even consistent with the studies that do strongly support maskin. In addition, the arguments have become political/partisan which muddies discussion (i.e. even if you or I had a study that proved it 100% beyond a shadow of doubt, many people would refuse to believe it nonetheless), and in general even though I personally believe that masks are effective at slowing down the spread of covid, I don't believe it particularly strongly and my belief has a lot of qualifiers to it. The phrase "overwhelming evidence in support of masks" overstates your point.
- merpnderp 5y agoWhat article are you talking about because the one you mentioned doesn't say what you state it does? It does not go on to make further judgements of masks as you stated. And it's not very long. Are you conflating an article from somewhere else?
- relaxing 5y agoThat article linked to this article https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abi9069 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abi9069 on a controlled randomized study that claims "Mask distribution and promotion was a scalable and effective method to reduce symptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections."
- godelski 5y agoThe article is talking about another article. I'm talking about the other article. The one that was originally flagged.
- Arnavion 5y agoI assume merpnderp understands perfectly well which article you were talking about. You said: >But reading further in the article they rise doubt about masks in general, which is something we know is highly effective (purely from a physics point of view). They don't say masking is effective, they continually question if it is. There are five parts of the article that contain the word "mask": 1. On September 28, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Director Rochelle Walensky shared the results of a new study that appeared to confirm the need for mask mandates in schools. The study was conducted in Arizona over the summer, and published by the CDC's Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report: It found that schools in counties without mask mandates had 3.5 times more outbreaks than schools in counties with mask mandates. 2. "You can't learn anything about the effects of school mask mandates from this study," Jonathan Ketcham, a public-health economist at Arizona State University, told me. 3. Masks may well help prevent the spread of COVID, some of these experts told me, and there may well be contexts in which they should be required in schools. But the data being touted by the CDC—which showed a dramatic more-than-tripling of risk for unmasked students—ought to be excluded from this debate. 4. For these and other reasons, Zweig argues that the study ought to be ignored entirely: Masking in schools may or may not be a good idea, but this study doesn't help answer the question. Any public official—including and especially Walensky—who purports to follow the science should toss this one in the trash. 5. Hopefully, we see something similar [death rate not rising in DC despite a spike in cases, as with delta] with omicron, though everyone should prepare for Democratic officials to bring back mask mandates (and maybe lockdowns) in response to rising cases. Mayor Muriel Bowser will probably reinstate D.C.'s mask mandate—just as soon as her own holiday parties are over. None of these are, as you claimed, "continuously questioning if wearing masks is effective". (1) describes the study that is the subject of the article. (2), (3) and (4) are specifically saying, exactly as the submitted article describes, that they don't think wearing masks is ineffective, just that this study doesn't prove that they are effective. (5) is just saying people should expect masks to become mandatory again for everyone soon. (And to be clear, the parts of the article that I didn't quote above don't question the effectiveness of masks either. In fact, the part about college campuses being closed due to omicron specifically points out that vaccines have not been sufficient to prevent that from happening.) You're welcome to say that you think the article's title is suggestive of something the article doesn't claim. I happen to agree; I think it's clickbait. But your points about the content of the article are unfounded.
- umvi 5y ago> which is something we know is highly effective (purely from a physics point of view) This in itself is a tricky claim to make with confidence. I agree we know certain types of masks (N95) are highly effective at preventing spread of airborne illness if worn properly. But... in the context of the article you referenced, are you prepared to defend the claim that cloth masks which haven't been washed for months and are frequently touched, adjusted, and worn incorrectly by kids and teens are "highly effective at preventing spread of airborne illness"?
- LorenPechtel 5y agoJust because inferior masks poorly handled aren't worth much doesn't mean masks aren't worth much.
- merpnderp 5y agoBut it does indeed mean the mask mandates weren't worth much.
- HWR_14 5y agoIt means mask mandates that allow cotton masks as opposed to surgical masks or N95s aren't worth as much.
- Wolfenstein98k 5y agoWhich is what they were. So we all agree they weren't worth much.
- HWR_14 5y agoThey're still worth a lot. For one, mask mandates are going to encourage some people to wear non-cotton masks who would otherwise skip masks. For another, cotton masks are still better than nothing. But I agree, we should statrt having stricter mandates.
- 5y ago
- relaxing 5y agoI had to scroll pretty far to find someone willing to address the substance of the article. Kudos to you.
- syshum 5y agoYour very statement of "which is something we know is highly effective (purely from a physics point of view). " is misleading As both this story, and the "fact checked" story (as well as the position of many others) is not really talking about masks at the physics level (though new data about omicron is placing that in question now as well) but masking as a POLICY it may be true that masks themselves are effective, but due to human nature masking POLICIES, including masking POLICIES in schools are not. Human interactions with the mask have we have seen countless times are far far far from perfect, people pulling on the masks, masks around chins, removing the mask to cough or sneeze, etc. Children will be even less disciplined So I dont think they are questioning the mask as a technical barrier to stop covid, they are questioning the masks as a public policy given that humans are involved
- axiosgunnar 5y ago> They don't say masking is effective, they continually question if it is. This is really problematic. Forbidding questioning is really problematic.
- mike00632 5y agoThe Reason article makes perfectly clear that masks are very effective and should be worn in school. It's then totally dishonest for the article to have that headline which seemingly questions the effectiveness of masks. The author knew what they were doing.
- sinuhe69 5y agoIf we question the motive or even the eventual consequence of an article but not the truth, that’s NOT fact-checking anymore but purely intention-checking, whose intention and what the hell it might be. At least at that point, “fact-checking” is becoming a propaganda machine, no more, no less. Communist countries have even “security law” to put people in jail based purely on intention and eventual consequences. Btw, the “fact-checker” labeled the article as “false information”, not as “misleading”.