4 ms·
It's a good argument; but I question how many have believed this was not the case all along. Look at how the Marines got their start; was that Grand Strategy or
by h2odragon 5y ago
It's a good argument; but I question how many have believed this was not the case all along. Look at how the Marines got their start; was that Grand Strategy or short term popular politics driving one of the nation's Founding Fathers to discard principles for realistic expedience?
There were a couple years in WW2 where our government acted with a "Grand Strategy"; insofar as possible, and that probably didn't involve as much of the government as we like to remember now. Afterwards, the people who had stepped up and got shit done purged the deadwood to an extent, but we don't really analyze that part of the 50's and "Normalcy" movements anymore, we just decry the excess that grew from them.
One of those excesses was the narrative of the Grand Strategy; that there's a Destiny of Greatness we're supposed to be working towards, as individuals, communities, as a nation and a species. Why can't we just muddle along as we have been for thousands of years, doing what we can, raising kids, and enjoying the world as far as possible without hurting others? Is that not an ambitious enough goal?
- civilized 5y agoI agree that grand ambitions in foreign policy are not necessarily desirable. But (and I think we agree on this) deliberate do-no-harm policy would be vastly preferable to what we do today, selling policy out to the people who get money or prestige from war. To your other point, other commenters are already demonstrating how many people fundamentally don't understand Hanania.
- mythrwy 5y agoIt could be if you just muddle along enjoying the world eventually the Mongols show up and take your stuff and put your skull on the skull pyramid. Or at least that's the fear.