9 ms·
Renewables and electrification are the primary solution to the climate change problem. This book contains a very practical roadmap on how we can do this quickl
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
Renewables and electrification are the primary solution to the climate change problem.
This book contains a very practical roadmap on how we can do this quickly, cheaply and practically: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/electrify https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/electrify
In this thread from yesterday I answer most of the standard objections: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29721417 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29721417
P.S. The people agreeing with me mostly got upvoted and the people disagreeing mostly got downvoted, so read from the bottom if you want to see answers to objections.
- gwright 5y ago> Renewables and electrification are the primary solution to the climate change problem Not until grid-scale energy storage is widely available and affordable.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoOne might reasonably consider "grid-scale energy storage" to be an implicit part of "renewables and electrification".
- gwright 5y agoI don't think that is reasonable as an interpretation because grid-scale energy storage doesn't yet exist. An assertion that "renewables and electrification" solves our energy problems is just circular reasoning. It requires a non-existent technology (grid-scale long-term energy storage) and so doesn't fall into the category of "solution" and more into the category of "speculation".
- iso1631 5y ago> grid-scale energy storage doesn't yet exist The New Zealand south island electric grid is almost entirely grid-scale energy storage, in the form of hydro. Easy to recharge (pump water uphill, although NZ doesn't need that), easy to tap (open gates).
- cinntaile 5y agoWhat do you mean when you say grid-scale energy storage doesn't exist? Is this different from utility-scale which has existed for many years?
- pydry 5y agoWhat exactly are these 2.2GW of battery installations in California then? https://www.energystoragejournal.com/southern-california-edison-agrees-three-grid-scale-battery-installations/ https://www.energystoragejournal.com/southern-california-edi... Or the 1GW they already have?
- stymaar 5y agoThe power (in W) isn't the relevant value when talking about batteries, it's the stored energy (in Wh) that matters (it's the opposite for dam storage, where energy is plentiful but power is limited). Just do the math and check how many minutes the installation would stay up under significant load from the grid. BTW I'm baffled to see a website called “energy storage journal” mixing up energy and power like this …
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWe certainly do have grid-scale technology. Whether it can be, or is, or will be deployed is another question.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoYup, that's in the book I linked. A lot less storage is needed than most people think. We only need about 3 hours worth of storage. That's a lot, but it's feasible. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z
- ftth_finland 5y agoOh, please. Up north, like here in Finland, you’d be hard pressed to get by with 3 months of storage.
- gwright 5y ago> We only need about 3 hours worth of storage This doesn't align with the analysis that I've seen. For example in this post (https://www.manhattancontrarian.com/the-disastrous-economics-of-trying-to-power https://www.manhattancontrarian.com/the-disastrous-economics...) the analysis shows that California would have to spend about $5 trillion on battery storage to have a solar+wind+battery grid. If the book you reference was accurate we would be seeing headlines about power companies bragging about these new grid arrangements but instead I just see headlines about how India an China are moving ahead with enormous amounts of coal power plants, rapidly increasing energy costs where intermittent power generation is a significant fraction of power capacity (i.e. Germany), and power outages when base load generating capacity isn't sufficient to keep the lights on when the sun sets and the wind dies.
- missedthecue 5y agoIs there even enough lithium on earth for global grid storage, nevermind electric vehicles?
- fukpaywalls2 5y agostationary batteries do not need to be from lithium. please search for iron or rust batteries.
- RobertoG 5y ago
- hannob 5y agoThis is really thinking it backwards. You don't build the storage before you have the renewables to store. And almost no country is at a point where they need storage in large amounts (as long as that's an option it's cheaper to add flexibility by exchanging with neighboring countries). E.g. hydrogen electrolyseurs + gas plants that can use H2 exist and aren't particularly challenging. The reason you don't see that yet is that we don't have the huge amounts of renewables that would need this infrastructure yet.
- 7952 5y agoThe UK pipeline for battery storage is over 20GW.
- gwright 5y agoI don't think the units are correct here. My observation has been that even reputable news sources seem to go all wonky with energy units. I believe the appropriate units for consideration would be GWh = gigawatt-hours. This article, https://www.environmentalleader.com/2021/01/worlds-largest-utility-scale-battery-energy-storage-system-now-online/ https://www.environmentalleader.com/2021/01/worlds-largest-u..., suggests that the largest battery storage system is 1,200 MWh or 1.2GWh of storage (at a cost of $400 million) For comparison, all generation capacity in California is 272,576 gigawatt-hours https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/california-electricity-data/2020-total-system-electric-generation https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/califo...
- iso1631 5y agoA grid battery has two numbers that are of interest One is how many Joules it can deliver in a second (Giga/Mega/Kilo/watts) One is how many Joules it can delivery completely (Giga/Mega/Kilo/watts) it can deliver If I'm running my 10kW shower for 5 minutes, I can do that from a battery that only has 1kWh of storage, but I can't run it from a battery that can only deliver 1kW. This is all high-school level science, and it's an indictment on the lack of diversity in news reporting how badly they get it wrong
- edhelas 5y agohttps://app.electricitymap.org/zone/DE https://app.electricitymap.org/zone/DE Germany: 2x the French nuclear capacity in wind and solar + coal and gas (edited): 398gCO₂eq/kWh France: nuclear + a bit of hydro and renewables: 46gCO₂eq/kWh
- c0balt 5y agoThe thing is that coal+gas ist still a massive driver for German electricity generation. Goal is to get coal off the grid until 2035 but has to be seen how they actually handle this has to be seen. The nuclear part in both countries also face the problem of long term storage that isn't solved by either one of the countries.
- gostsamo 5y agoWhere do you count the coal?
- edhelas 5y agoSorry, I didn't put it in the example. You have all the numbers in real-time on the link. My point was more to show that even you have a huge quantity of renewable, that doesn't means that is the correct path to go CO2 wise. Except if you accept that your society adapt itself to a non planned and highly variable electricity production.
- teekert 5y agoGermany should have kept their nuclear power plants just a bit longer, just to get through the transition. Closing them all as fast as they did is just difficult to defend.
- Eric_WVGG 5y agoAlright, I’ve got one that I don't see on your list, it’s been on my mind for years. What about the goldfish problem? Goldfish grow to fit their containers. Keep a little 1-inch goldfish in a bowl, it’ll stay that size. Toss it in a koi pond and in no time you’ll have something approaching the size of a housecat. People are like this. A family might be scratching by on $40k/year. Dad gets some windfall or promotion and is making $60k/year. So did he finish out the year in the same house with $20k in the bank? Of course not, he’s paying for all the clothes and goods that he couldn’t afford before. Ten years later he’s gotten promoted to making $120k/year. Now is there money in the bank, or are they living in a bigger house and driving a nicer car? This is what worries me about any climate plan that is only based on clean energy. If driving, for example, gets cleaner, do we use 50% less petroleum, or keep burning the same amount of petroleum on different projects? (And what about all the non-tracked pollution caused by tire wear?) This problem is even more stark when people talk about atmospheric carbon capture. If we're emitting X tons of carbon per year, and recapture Y tons, will we continue to emit X, or start emitting X + Y? None of this is reason not to pursue renewables and electrification, but I think it’s inescapable that any "primary solution" has to be a reduction in consumption.
- oezi 5y agoThis is all fine as long as all externalities are included in the price of consumption. Currently burning fossils is just way too cheap for the damage it does.
- pyrale 5y ago> This is all fine as long as all externalities are included in the price of consumption. Just like a software team scaling a product is going to discover new scale issues, we discover new externalities on a regular basis. Hoping that we can discover all externalities ahead of time and price them is an impossible objective.
- edhelas 5y agoBig +1 on that one. France goal to meet Paris agreement is actually to reduce by ~5% per year ALL energy consumption. -5% is roughly what we had with 3 lockdowns in 2020. So it's basically a COVID added to a COVID each year, for 30 years. That's no matter what you do in your actual energy deployment and investment.
- chr1 5y agoWhat do you think about ocean thermal energy conversion plants [1]. It seems to be a promissing technology that both produces energy during whole day, and captures carbon by increasing the biomass of the ocean. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_thermal_energy_conversion# https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_thermal_energy_convers...
- trebligdivad 5y agoThe UK is doing pretty well today - 39%/13GW Wind energy at the moment which is great; but we have whole months when we'll have near to nothing when there is very little wind (e.g. less than 2GW for a long time), when that happens in the winter when we've not got much Solar, I'm not seeing how Renewables keep us going - maybe if some of the tidal systems get working. Energy storage works great for daily peak/troughs - but not for weeks. So, at the moment I'm assuming we're going to need more nukes to get rid of gas. Roll on Fusion.
- aembleton 5y agoIt is one of the reasons for the new undersea cable to Norway. When we have excess wind then we can pump water up a mountain there, and when we don't the we can release it and recapture some of that energy. Problem is, that is currently only 1.4GW of capacity. We'll need a whole lot more of it to get fully off gas or nuclear.
- jlarocco 5y agoI really have no idea if this is possible, but is there any possibility that with enough wind turbines, we might discover a down side to them? Each wind turbine essentially transfers power out of the wind and into our electric grid, right? Is it possible we could build enough turbines for that to be a problem?
- nootropicat 5y agoYes, there are significant downsides: https://acp.copernicus.org/articles/10/2053/2010/acp-10-2053-2010.html https://acp.copernicus.org/articles/10/2053/2010/acp-10-2053... The short of it is that since wind exists because of temperature differentials, each wind farm increases them. >Using wind turbines to meet 10% or more of global energy demand in 2100, could cause surface warming exceeding 1 °C over land installations
- xxgreg 5y agoThanks for taking the time to write these comments. In my opinion, existing tech is able to solve the climate crisis. Breakthroughs can make the solution cheaper and sooner. In my view the main problem is the attitude of doom amongst the general population. If people felt there was a solution, and were excited and energised by the challenge, they'd be more willing to support political changes. I.e. pushing back against entrenched obstructionist industries, pricing externalities, and investing in infrastructure.