4 ms·
It might be the article struggling to find the perfect frame, but what also stands out is the reason a lot of excellent executors get locked out of strategy dec
by roenxi 5y ago
It might be the article struggling to find the perfect frame, but what also stands out is the reason a lot of excellent executors get locked out of strategy decisions is that they don't want to be involved. It isn't a source of regrets.
People don't generally sign up for an engineering role because they want to provide strategic direction to others. Such people exist, but are rare. There is a clear bias in Engineering disciplines towards people who really enjoy executing and don't particularly care what they execute.
And seconding the manager-speak angle. This article will be nearly useless to someone who doesn't already know how to identify and balance conflicting needs to make a decision. This is a rehash of the usual advice - take a step back, breath deeply and ask if what you are doing is leading to outcomes you value.
- rramadass 5y agoYour points are valid and i agree with you. The problem with the article is that it tars the "Engineering Discipline" and practicing Engineers with the brush of implicit incompetence as if they are incapable of "looking at the big picture" and burying their Head in the sand. Nothing could be further from the Truth. The Complexity of the Problem/Solution demands that each of us focus only on our area of Specialized Expertise thus allowing the "Whole System" to be built from "Components". Analyze/Design Top-Down but Build Bottom-Up. Our "Modern World" is dependent on Technology all built by Scientists and Engineers. PS: Take a look at the works of Jacques Ellul for a fascinating study of the relationship between Technology and Modern Society.