5 ms·
LastPass says no passwords were compromised following breach scare
- sersi 5y agoAnd this is why I'm not happy to see 1password moving to an online only model. If it's only local vaults, I can understand the threat model, I have more control over it, as soon as it's in the cloud, it becomes quite a bit harder for me to feel safe.
- manicdee 5y agoOnce it’s in the cloud, it’s already compromised. Best way to keep a secret is don’t share it. Cloud storage is by necessity sharing the secret with the cloud server and everyone with access to it.
- lokedhs 5y agoIn general, I agree with you about avoiding cloud storage, but it's important to remember that the secret is the cleartext data. The encrypted data is not secret, and that's the whole point of encryption. As long as you store the encrypted vault on a cloud service, your secrets are not shared. The problem in this case is that you are running the vendor's code on your local machine to perform the encryption, and that's where the real issue is. You have to trust that that code is completely bug free. This issue is made worse by the fact that things are uploaded to the cloud, but it's not the underlying problem.
- AbuAssar 5y agoTime to migrate from lastPass Any good alternatives?
- TheChaplain 5y agoI use Bitwarden and have no complaints so far. But being a bit paranoid the most important passwords I keep in a KeePass-file on a USB.
- RamRodification 5y agoA USB what? Don't leave us hanging.
- tuwtuwtuwtuw 5y agoMouse. He stores them in his USB mouse on a piece of paper. No one would look in his mouse.
- piaste 5y agoMany modern mice have onboard memory, actually, to store sensitivity settings and occasionally macros. I doubt they need more than a few kb's for them, but being 2021, maybe the cheapest onboard memory chip can still hold 16MB or more, and a sufficiently cunning hacker could use it as a storage of last resort.
- wruza 5y agoAnd I have. “Lock now” function is hidden among other items in the settings menu, when it must be accessible. Editing and using password cards is far from intuitive, and their entire autogenerated(?)/tabled(?) UI feels off in ways hard to describe. I’m constantly getting confused using it. And it is not a baby duck syndrome, as I am using it for more than two years. There is still no better alternative if you want to leave lastpass, but what lastpass really has is a good UI.
- madspindel 5y ago> There is still no better alternative if you want to leave lastpass, but what lastpass really has is a good UI. 1Password. Love the Chrome extension UI coupled with the desktop app. Way better than Bitwarden in my opinion.
- ghosty141 5y agoWhy migrate? It seems like there isnt a problem with Lastpass itself. Apart from that: bitwarden.
- tmikaeld 5y agoThere’s two options: 1. they found the breach and patched it, lies about it to save face. 2. there was no breach Even if it’s option two, would you want to gamble on it?
- jamespo 5y agoBecause most users will have an inferior setup to Lastpass
- willis936 5y agoMost of the effort is in moving off an insecure set of passwords. The details of the solution don't add much incremental effort. Why not do it the right way and avoid trusting a company with an awful track record? Everyone I know has a google account and a smartphone, and by extension access to google drive for cloud backup/sync of a keepass database. Lastpass cannot justify its existence.
- londons_explore 5y agoOption 3:. There was a breach, but lastpass didn't keep enough logs to know that anything went wrong.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoMe as a still somewhat techie individual? No, keepass works just fine. But you have to realistically consider what are actual alternatives. For everybody else in my family, it's not lastpass vs some cryptographycally excellent local solution. It's last pass or 1password as uphill battle vs same password of your cats name over all of your accounts. Shared by your family members. My sister in law doesn't even have to wonder what her mom's utility or bank password is - they all literally use their old dead cat's name. For everything. So moving them to Lastpass or 1password with differentiated passwords has been my life's mission for past several years. they are the norm. Average HN poster is empathically not :-/
- zapdrive 5y agoI have a NextCloud server for backing up and syncing my personal data. I use the PassMan plugin to store my passwords. The user interface could really use some work. Other than that it's really good.
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoBitwarden is really nice.
- feistypharit 5y agoSelf hosted bitwarden (well, vault warden) is pretty good. With a lot of passwords (600) the browser extension is a little slow, but not bad. I left 1password once they moved to cloud and subscriptions and haven’t missed it. Plus, set hosted BW gets you all the premium features, like shared vaults for the wife and family.
- Wonnk13 5y agoThere was some speculation over at /r/sysadmins that this was a dump of passwords that came from the compromise five years ago. I have no way to confirm/deny that. I have MFA enabled with the google auth app- has there been any discussion that accounts with two factor auth are pwned as well?
- londons_explore 5y agoLastpass used to run a phpBB forum where the login system used your lastpass master password to log in. phpBB is notorious for security flaws. It doesn't seem unlikely that someone hacked the forum and modded it to leak user master passwords. More info: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29706579 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29706579
- foxfluff 5y agoThat speculation is in direct contradiction with everyone here who claimed their much more recent passwords had also been compromised.
- cout 5y agoNot necessarily. The 5 year old master password could have granted access to a service that made it possible to intercept the password change.
- foxfluff 5y agoThis was also happening to accounts that did not exist 5 years ago.
- robbedpeter 5y agoIt might be that the previous leak completely or partially exposed the algorithm of LastPass's password generator, or some other commonly used tool, and people being targeted show up on other lists. Credential stuffing with a targeted list of generated passwords. If passwords from other breaches fit the characteristics of a weak or compromised generator, that could also be used for targeting.
- destitude 5y agoInteresting that they claim no passwords were leaked and yet just two days ago someone posted here on HN asking how their master password for LastPass could have been leaked: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29705957 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29705957 (which the linked article references as well)
- raverbashing 5y agoPassword reuse and stuffing is the most likely explanation
- boringg 5y agoRead the comment thread
- raverbashing 5y agohttps://twitter.com/kevincollier/status/1476188359605334027 https://twitter.com/kevincollier/status/1476188359605334027
- Schiendelman 5y agoThere are users claiming their master password was not reused for anything else, so I’m not sure how stuffing could explain the attack. Unless LastPass had a previous breach.
- Proven 5y ago
- KSPAtlas 5y agoI personally use GNU Pass as its a simple local password manager, no strings attached. It can also generate passwords.
- phoe-krk 5y agoProps for pass. (Is it GNU pass though? I can't see a mention of it being a GNU utility anywhere on https://www.passwordstore.org/ https://www.passwordstore.org/ - I only see it's a "Unix" password manager.) I have a rented VPS whose main two uses are being my IRC host (irssi running in a tmux) and hosting my Git repository containing the pass password store. As long as only I can SSH into the VPS, my encrypted password collection won't leak; as long as there is no keylogger or clipboard logger on the machines I use pass on, my passwords are secure. (I assume that SSH and GPG are unbreakable, which seems good enough of an assumption for the time being. Perhaps I'll switch to passage instead of pass some time in the future.)
- doomrobo 5y agoDo you find that the lack of a browser extension makes it easier to get phished by failing to accurately read the URL? That's one of the stronger arguments I've heard for a browser autofill feature
- phoe-krk 5y agoNo idea, honestly. I think I am lucky and I do not get targeted by many phishing mails. (Let's see how much things will change now that this comment is public.)
- foxfluff 5y agoThat might be the case for normies who click phishing links or SEO-optimized phishing sites that appear on Google search results (instead of, you know, just typing the URL of the site they want). I tend to navigate by URL or browser history, so I just don't enter phishing URLs. An extension could save my ass in the scenario where a legit site (e.g. a shop) has been compromised and the redirect to payment services has been replaced with a malicious site, but I don't believe that's very common?
- pydry 5y agoI remember when lastpass had a security hole that could expose any password in your vault by visiting a web page. They thanked the security researcher who found it with a paltry sum of $1,000. https://www.theverge.com/2019/9/16/20868111/lastpass-bug-exploit-password-manager-malicious-website https://www.theverge.com/2019/9/16/20868111/lastpass-bug-exp... >In a statement posted on its blog, LastPass downplayed the severity of the bug. The company’s Security Engineering Manager, Ferenc Kun, said that the exploit relied on a user visiting a malicious site and then being tricked into clicking on the page “several times.” This was what led me to dump them and delete my account. I thought at the time that A) they're sloppy and B) the next exploit will 100% be sold on the black market for minimum an order of magnitude higher price. If there were a common exploit among the people on the HN thread like a compromised chrome extension I think they would have discovered it. There were a lot of people on that thread, a bunch of invalidated hypotheses and no clear commonalities. Edit : i made a mistake - it only exposed the last used password in the vault. Pretty bad but not quite as awful as I first thought.
- tuwtuwtuwtuw 5y ago> I remember when lastpass had a security hole that could expose every password in your vault by visiting a web page. I remember when KeePass browser plugin had the same issue. The security researchers were not paid.
- pydry 5y agoI'd avoid using that too then.
- tuwtuwtuwtuw 5y agoWould you avoid using any password storage where either the system itself or the underlying foundation has had serious vulnerabilities at some point? Or only bad vulnerabilities triggered using JavaScript? Or would you only accept a history with vulnerabilities if security researchers were paid properly for the work they invested into finding the issues?
- sam_goody 5y agoOT: The fact that Chrome offers to bring my passwords from browser to browser, means that they are being stored in plaintext by Google. Aside from that I probably gave them permission to log in as me in one of the EULAs, why is it OK for them to store my passwords unencrypted. Who guarantees that there are no leaks at Google? Who guarantees that some malicious browser plugin (there have been MANY) has never figured out how to access my passwords - especially as if such a plugin can get the password to identify myself to Chrome, it can login anywhere to get the passwords. Anyways, whenever I hear of leaked 1Passwords, I figure it is in such a vector - login on the browser. And the fact that they are doubling down on browser login, makes me less secure. Paranoid, much?
- foxfluff 5y ago> The fact that Chrome offers to bring my passwords from browser to browser, means that they are being stored in plaintext by Google. Why do you think that they cannot bring encrypted passwords from browser to browser?
- georgyo 5y agoAll password managers need access to the plaintext version of the password at some point... They need to put that into the login field. Chrome syncing across browsers does not mean they are being stored in plaintext. Your login is likely given you access to a key to decrypt them. Chrome does have an ability to encrypt the password store with a different password of your choosing. In this case syncing still happens, but each browser install requires you to enter in the second password to unlock the store. A malicious browser plugin does not need access to your password store to steal your password. Sooner or later you are going to log into a website and it will just steal it then.
- 15characterslon 5y agoYou can set your own passphrase in sync settings. This will enable end-to-end encryption and Google won't be able to read your synced data (not just passwords but also history and other synced data).
- causi 5y agoThe fact that Chrome offers to bring my passwords from browser to browser, means that they are being stored in plaintext by Google. Not necessarily. For example, Google could be encrypting your passwords using your Google account password.
- ksec 5y ago>Our investigation has since found that some of these security alerts, which were sent to a limited subset of LastPass users, were likely triggered in error. Thank You. We can now all go back and enjoy our holiday. Edit: Hold on a min. "likely triggered" means they think it is triggered in error but still not sure? Side Note: I really dislike these "updated" articles with new reference that are not "clearly labeled at either the top or the bottom of the news. I have no idea when that LastPass statement was added to this piece, was it before the HN headline submission or after? I have no way to know if comments or HN readers here are reading the same as I am.
- Proven 5y ago
- karmakaze 5y agoI haven't looked into this, but are there any self-hosted solutions that anyone could recommend? The minimum might be a browser extension (Firefox) and to let me replicate to at least two different local/cloud instances (directly or indirectly).