3 ms·
The Tokamak hype machine is in overdrive. But no commercially viable power will ever be generated with a Tokamak. Such a reactor would be much more expensive to
by ncmncm 5y ago
The Tokamak hype machine is in overdrive. But no commercially viable power will ever be generated with a Tokamak. Such a reactor would be much more expensive to operate than a fission plant, and fission plants get less competitive every year.
We may hope that the plasma physicists employed on these projects are learning things that will later be applicable to actually-practical fusion. It seems like a Good Thing to be keeping plasma physicists employed, but I hope the crash when reality catches up to the projects does not leave them suddenly unemployed, as has often happened to (particularly) aeronautical and electrical engineers over the past 60 years.
- freemint 5y agoI think the improvement they made is orthogonal to the Tokamak Vs Stellarator issue do an improvement for magnet cooling in one is gonna help the other too.
- ncmncm 5y agoTwo economically uncompetitive systems is no better than one such and one even more such.
- freemint 5y agoYou are aware that those all a research designs, designs optimized to probe the parameter space of reactors efficiently not produce energy efficiently. Huge difference. If everything is designed for energy ROI it wouldn't be a research reactor and have better efficiency today
- ncmncm 5y agoThe point is, even after they work out all the kinks, it will still be dead-end tech. They will just have wasted a lot of money that, e.g., could have more productively been handed to me to spend wherever I liked. A fraction of the money goes to support plasma fluid-dynamics physicists, which is not a waste, except insofar as they work on that and not something that has a future.