3 ms·
You can build a more expensive a nuclear reactor to quickly adjust power output across a wide range just look at nuclear subs. You can’t however do that and me
by Retric 5y ago
You can build a more expensive a nuclear reactor to quickly adjust power output across a wide range just look at nuclear subs. You can’t however do that and meet close to 100% of annual demand by keeping average power output below 50% and sell electricity at under 25c/kWh without truly monumental subsides.
That’s why nuclear isn’t load following in practice. Sure you can build reactors that occasionally dip few a few hours each night without breaking the bank, but something else needs to be covering your daily peak demand let alone extreme demand.
PS: The more expensive bit relates to both design changes to deal with reactor poisoning (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_poison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_poison) etc and thus construction cost increased alongside increased maintenance costs due to increased thermal cycling etc.
- littlestymaar 5y agoFrance produces 70% of its total electricity from nuclear, and has one of the cheapest electricity in Europe, AND uses nuclear to adjust production to demand (no we don't do that with fossil, because modern fossil plants have a yield that is widely affected by the stability of the production, with a big warm-up time: just look at french production in winter, gas is mostly constant during the day and nuclear is taking half of the variation with hydro doing the rest). Varying the power output of a nuclear plant (regular 2G plant) between 40 and 100% is straightforward and needs no specific design changes, and you can even go as low as 10% if need be. Xenon poisoning is a real thing, but it is relatively easy to deal with (simply by tweaking the Boron concentration the position of the control rods) even though it requires a bit of practice to master the skill. It is done routinely every day in all French nuclear plants! You are simply living in a parallel universe which seams to share very few similarities with the real world…
- Retric 5y agoFrance has low retail electricity rates because the government massively subsidized nuclear power. That doesn’t mean cheap electricity, that means hiding the costs for electricity. Also, it doesn’t use 70% nuclear power, it currently exports ~20% of the nuclear power it generates and imports almost exclusively non nuclear energy. Net result it’s customers actually use about 55-60% nuclear power meanwhile average nationwide nuclear capacity factors actually fell below 60% and only recently reached 70% when they started to phase it out.
- littlestymaar 5y agoSo you're not responding on the Xenon poisoning and power variation, I guess you stand corrected. > France has low retail electricity rates because the government massively subsidized nuclear power. That doesn’t mean cheap electricity, that means hiding the costs for electricity. No. The impact of nuclear electricity on public finances is a clear net positive over the lifetime of the park. And for the past 10 years, nuclear has actually been anti-subsidized by the political will to boost RE and competition in the french electricity sector (see ARENH if you're interested). > Also, it doesn’t use 70% nuclear power, it currently exports ~20% of the nuclear power it generates and imports almost exclusively non nuclear energy. Net result it’s customers actually use about 55-60% nuclear power This makes no sense. You can't just discount export from nuclear and count import as non-nuclear… First of all, most of our biggest neighbours also have nuclear electricity (UK, Belgium, Germany) so we are definitely also importing nuclear (well, when it makes sense to actually export nuclear, see the next point). Second, most of the time when we export we're actually producing electricity from other means than nuclear (gas, wind, hydro) why would you count only nuclear as being exported? If you want to draw an accurate line, you'd need to count the electricity at the marginal price as the one being exported and most of the time it's not nuclear. Third, what about the past few days? We've artificially reduced nuclear production to import wind, because the weather leads to a massive overproduction of wind power in Europe. It's not that nuclear couldn't have produced this energy right, just that we had to turn it down to protect the grid from a collapse. Yet in your calculations you are somehow counting it as a liability for nuclear.
- Retric 5y agoI agree with the statement that “between 40 and 100% is straightforward and needs no specific design changes” it’s not wrong. But to be clear a minimum of 40% is nowhere near enough if someone wanted to go close to 100% nuclear. He then mentioned one of several such changes needed in France which does go outside that range and again I agree with what was said. He even mentioned that France regularly goes below 40% output, but below 10% has much more serious issues. Again nothing I disagree with. I am not sure how you think it’s a refutation of my point? > You can’t just discount export from nuclear and count import as non-nuclear I didn’t. They do export some non nuclear generation, but the majority is nuclear which you can verify by looking at the generation during times of export. ~20% nuclear is just what the actual number is. Similarly, they import almost zero nuclear power simply based on when generation occurs and when new power is brought online by the countries involved. > No Feel free to dig into hard numbers such construction costs, liability for accidents, and funds set aside to pay for decommissioning and where they came from etc. You obviously feel strongly about this so I can only assume you have exact numbers and a nice economic breakdown. It takes some doing including digging into Areva‘s finances before and after it’s restructuring (bailout) etc.