5 ms·
> . If a person's own writing shows that they lie, rewrite reality, or otherwise engage in cognitive distortions, they're abusive. Period. Instant kill shot. I
by aidenn0 5y ago
> . If a person's own writing shows that they lie, rewrite reality, or otherwise engage in cognitive distortions, they're abusive. Period. Instant kill shot.
If you haven't dealt with someone with NPD or BPD, I'd like to clarify this a bit. I'm sure that any of the prolific commenters on HN could be found to have contradicted themselves and/or distorted reality occasionally. This is about patterns of behavior, and it's usually coupled with minimizing any specific examples of the behavior while never engaging with the fact that the problem is the pattern of behavior, not any one example.
I've dealt with someone with eBPD who was unable to get through a 45 minute therapy session without contradicting themselves. They also habitually selectively report facts to distort reality[1]. If the estranged kid(s) really were the ones with personality disorders, I suspect the emotional responses to being cut out would be something along the lines of "Sad, relieved, guilty about feeling relieved."
1: Here's an example with details changed: "Joe drank too much last night and we got in a car crash." Reality, Joe was in the passenger seat, and the driver hit a deer that jumped out in front of them. On confrontation: "I never said Joe drove drunk!"
- michaelbuckbee 5y agoAlso, from context, I believe that's really focused on observable patterns in the forum. If someone is lying and contradicting themselves so plainly on the forum (with relatively low stakes) it's quite likely that they do so elsewhere.
- DarylZero 5y agoAgree that they're doing it elsewhere, but not that these are low stakes social situations just because they're online forums. They may be very important social scenes in the lives of the participants.
- fragbait65 5y agoIs that actually a good example of what you mean? There is no contradiction? The first statement does not say that Joe drove drunk?
- tptacek 5y agoObviously, it strongly implies that Joe drove drunk. That's the point of the hypothetical.
- hinkley 5y agoIf you state two facts of equal import, they aren't necessarily linked. But if they are of different levels, and one happens before the other, only people who are implying a connection or who have a clinical condition lump those together. Yesterday my uncle died and my dog got hit by a car. versus: Yesterday my shoelace broke and my dog got hit by a car. Why am I bringing up the shoelace? And why first? For want of a nail the kingdom was lost? There are people who can't filter events by intensity. That's a separate diagnosis from BPD or NPD, but it's still something to keep an eye on. You either don't know you are saying something salacious, you do and you don't care, or you do and you are enjoying the buzz it creates.
- tptacek 5y agoThere's really just no amount of message board writing you're going to be able to do to make "Joe drank too much last night and we got in a car crash" not imply, to a reasonable audience, that Joe drove drunk. I get that you can have a lot of fun making a sport out of ever-more-elaborate arguments saying it doesn't imply that at all, or that we can't really know whether an intent to imply it was present, but none of that matters.
- kempbellt 5y agoThe only fair assumption from hearing either of those two statements is that yesterday contained two events. Either "uncle died and dog hit by car" or "shoelace broke and dog got hit by car". It's a common tendency to link related subjects together. So people infer that sharing a sentence/utterance means the two are directly related. Causing inferences like, "Oh, did he have a heart attack and run over your dog??". It is true that some people prey on these inferences and use them to lie/manipulate but it is also very possible that they are just two things that happened on the same day - related only by their traumatic impact. TLDR: Yesterday sucked because these two separate things happened... To a person who experienced these events, it's completely possible that you don't know people think your uncle ran over your dog. When he actually died in his sleep and your dog was run over by the neighbor.
- kempbellt 5y ago> 1: Here's an example with details changed: "Joe drank too much last night and we got in a car crash." Reality, Joe was in the passenger seat, and the driver hit a deer that jumped out in front of them. On confrontation: "I never said Joe drove drunk!" Continued: "It was Joe's birthday he got a bit tipsy. He was feeling a bit full of himself and hit on my girlfriend all night. Afterwards I still decide to drive him home so he didn't die. I mean, what kind of friend would let his friend drive himself home after drinking on his birthday? And even then he continued to be a complete ass. I was so enraged that I didn't even see the deer jump out in front of my car" Hence: "Joe drank too much last night and we got in a car crash" could very well be a valid interpretation of the evening if you consider all possible context. Especially if you are trying not to throw Joe under the bus as a sleazy friend to your therapist. But also, it could definitely be the drivers fault in this hypothetical scenario. Hard to say. The problem here is that humans have a tendency to believe they have all the information they need to pass correct judgment (source: life experience, and if I'm wrong about this, that means I'm probably right, right?). Usually, they don't. In my experience, everyone embroiders details to make themselves look innocent, and often without even noticing. It's very difficult to parse truth from people's tendency to simplify and exaggerate based on personal bias. If there is a conflict there usually is a good reason - but sometimes that "good reason" is based on a misinterpretation that others won't understand. I can't place fault on Joe or the driver in this situation because: I wasn't there and I don't know all of the context.
- tptacek 5y agoThe comment you're responding to starts by saying these aren't the actual details; they're trying to illustrate a pattern of abusive arguments that provide misleading narratives, and, when contradicted by evidence, proceed to lawyer out from under the deception. That's obviously a real phenomenon; the example is just meant as an illustration of it. I'm not sure what the point of litigating it is.
- kempbellt 5y ago
- testfoobar 5y agoDealing with lying and contradicting adults as a young person profoundly disorganizes your sense of reality.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]