4 ms·
> Now, can't pay someone market rate because that would be going out of band. While at the same time, people who come in as "headline" hires from external are g
by ryandrake 5y ago
> Now, can't pay someone market rate because that would be going out of band. While at the same time, people who come in as "headline" hires from external are given not nearly such scrutiny and instead get $Ms and hiring bonuses and directorships.
This seems like a common, growing problem in BigTech: It's often easier to interview and get L+1 at another company than it is to get promoted from L to L+1. Hell, it's probably easier to quit and immediately re-interview for L+1 at your own company than to go through the arduous promotion grind. When you go for promotion, you generally have to have some chain of evidence, peer reviews, performance history, etc. to show you should be at L+1, whereas when you interview at that L+1 role, you merely need to talk your way through a few interviewers and bedazzle them sufficiently. I mean, the bar is already high for the interviews, don't get me wrong, but believe it or not, it appears to be even higher for promotion.
- diob 5y agoSo true. I don't understand the logic of why companies do this. It's not limited to big tech, I'd say it's true anywhere the company grows beyond 40 or so employees.
- tqi 5y agoI think it comes down to how incentives are structured. In my experience, if someone who is promoted from L to L+1 fails to succeed at that new level, that person's manager is dinged for pushing a promotion that the person wasn't ready for. Conversely, an external hire who comes in at L+1 and fails to succeed is chalked up to the difficulties of hiring, with no negative consequences for the hiring panelists. As a result promotions are much more conservative than hiring. Which definitely sucks.
- mgkimsal 5y agoI can't get any sort of loyalty discount from big telcos or cable companies either, but they'll gladly give me 3 months free service to switch to them. You been a customer with us for 8 years and want the $10/discounted rate we've plastered billboards with? Get lost. Or... go switch to a competitor, then we'll court you back with freebies.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>Or... go switch to a competitor, then we'll court you back with freebies. Obviously going to a competitor comes with its costs, and hence people do not do it just for the $x discount. Just like with employment. If there were no switching costs, then you would not see these types of "misaligned" incentives.
- digianarchist 5y agoThis applies to salary as much as it does to titles and roles.
- masterof0 5y agoThis have been so far my experience. The L5 on my team, was L5(L4 at Google scale) at Amazon, couldn't get the promo, then interviewed with us , and got L5 with TC at the top of the bracket. I know is just one data point, but I have heard of similar stories.
- amzn-throw 5y agoThat could also be based on a difference of expectations in skills for a job family at Google vs. Amazon. An Amazon Sr. SDE (L6) is expected to have strong leadership skills, which means interpersonal tech lead abilities - including mentorship of others, communication with stakeholders, etc. This person may not have had the abilities or interest in having this so they went to Google which seems to focus exclusively on leetcode-esque abilities. (My data is ~5 years stale, but I interviewed with Google a few years back and didn't get a SINGLE "behavioural" interview question, or anything about my prior experience. It was 100% "solve this problem on a whiteboard").
- alienthrowaway 5y agoHow many interview stages did you go through at Google?
- masterof0 5y agoMaybe, but I will take his TC at Google over a L6 TC at Amazon any day, talking from the experience of being at Amazon, and seeing people with string LP evaluations and EE performance getting only a 3% comp boost, so yeah.