3 ms·
He left off the word Operating, and everyone assumed he meant something else... there really are no new operating systems these days, they're all clone of Unix
by mikewarot 5y ago
He left off the word Operating, and everyone assumed he meant something else... there really are no new operating systems these days, they're all clone of Unix in some fashion.
Containers and virtual machines are stopgap measures we're all adopted because nothing new has come along, and the Unix model of security isn't up to the task.
We need to be able to download code from the internet, and run it against X, where X is a folder, or a photo, or a URL, and know that the Operating System will only let that code access the things we gave it, and nothing else.
We don't have capability based Operating Systems, all we have that's even close is the ham fisted "capability" flags that allow an "app" on a phone to access or location, or not.
Analogy time: If I'm making a cash purchase, and I owe $14.21, I can pull out exact change, or hand over $20, knowing full well that the other party isn't going to magically be able to sell my house, or otherwise cost me more than that $20 capability I chose to exchange with the hope of getting $5.79 in change.
Linux/Unix has no easy way to say... here's a file, run this code with this file as input. The security model of Linux isn't suitable for the any date after the Eternal September of 1993.
The only thing close is to put the code in a virtual machine, or container, to try to limit the scope of the damage a piece of code can do. It's massive overkill, and does the wrong job anyway.
I think he was right, perhaps someone here can convince me otherwise.