4 ms·
Solar and wind are only cheaper when you don't count the adaptation the network needs to make to accommodate them (storage or gas plants to deal with intermitte
by littlestymaar 5y ago
Solar and wind are only cheaper when you don't count the adaptation the network needs to make to accommodate them (storage or gas plants to deal with intermittency, but also regional interconnections, frequency stabilization mechanism, the “smart grid” thing, etc). And people usually bring that “nuclear doesn't account for the decommissioning cost”, as if renewable did…
It's the same issue as trucks vs trains: trucks are cheaper because they don't pay for the roads at all.
- Retric 5y agoNuclear isn’t load following either. To get close to 100% you need to have vastly more power plants constructed which then mostly sit idle, but trying to do that is horrifically expensive. It’s actually cheaper and safer to pair Nuclear with batteries than it is to have that many idle nuclear power plants which makes it directly comparable to wind and solar. Unfortunately, in a head to head competition to fill batteries, Nuclear simply loses. It would even loses when directly compared to solar + batteries in most areas for a grid with steady 24/7/365 power demand.
- pyrale 5y ago> Nuclear isn’t load following either. That's simply not true. [1]: https://www.oecd-nea.org/ndd/reports/2011/load-following-npp.pdf https://www.oecd-nea.org/ndd/reports/2011/load-following-npp... > To get close to 100% you need to have vastly more power plants constructed which then mostly sit idle There's a difference between being forced to build enough capacity to provide 100% of your power, and have some idle when usage is at the cycle's low point, and not being able to load-follow i.e. not being able to adjust within that cycle... > to have that many idle nuclear power plants [which] makes it directly comparable to wind and solar. ...And that's where that difference is important: a renewables production system has to install way more capacity than what's used on average, because they can't control the load factor, not just because they have to adapt to consumption cycles.
- Retric 5y agoYou can build a more expensive a nuclear reactor to quickly adjust power output across a wide range just look at nuclear subs. You can’t however do that and meet close to 100% of annual demand by keeping average power output below 50% and sell electricity at under 25c/kWh without truly monumental subsides. That’s why nuclear isn’t load following in practice. Sure you can build reactors that occasionally dip few a few hours each night without breaking the bank, but something else needs to be covering your daily peak demand let alone extreme demand. PS: The more expensive bit relates to both design changes to deal with reactor poisoning (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_poison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_poison) etc and thus construction cost increased alongside increased maintenance costs due to increased thermal cycling etc.
- littlestymaar 5y agoFrance produces 70% of its total electricity from nuclear, and has one of the cheapest electricity in Europe, AND uses nuclear to adjust production to demand (no we don't do that with fossil, because modern fossil plants have a yield that is widely affected by the stability of the production, with a big warm-up time: just look at french production in winter, gas is mostly constant during the day and nuclear is taking half of the variation with hydro doing the rest). Varying the power output of a nuclear plant (regular 2G plant) between 40 and 100% is straightforward and needs no specific design changes, and you can even go as low as 10% if need be. Xenon poisoning is a real thing, but it is relatively easy to deal with (simply by tweaking the Boron concentration the position of the control rods) even though it requires a bit of practice to master the skill. It is done routinely every day in all French nuclear plants! You are simply living in a parallel universe which seams to share very few similarities with the real world…
- Retric 5y agoFrance has low retail electricity rates because the government massively subsidized nuclear power. That doesn’t mean cheap electricity, that means hiding the costs for electricity. Also, it doesn’t use 70% nuclear power, it currently exports ~20% of the nuclear power it generates and imports almost exclusively non nuclear energy. Net result it’s customers actually use about 55-60% nuclear power meanwhile average nationwide nuclear capacity factors actually fell below 60% and only recently reached 70% when they started to phase it out.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> Nuclear isn’t load following either. To get close to 100% you need to have vastly more power plants constructed which then mostly sit idle, but trying to do that is horrifically expensive. You mean France doesn't exist?
- philipkglass 5y agoFrance meets its peak electricity demands with fossil fuel generation, hydropower, and imports. It doesn't have enough nuclear capacity to service annual peak demands without fossil power because that would leave expensive reactors idle much of the year, as the grandparent post said. Throttling down nuclear is not technically difficult but the high cost would sink a commercial reactor that operates at only 50% of its technically achievable capacity factor.
- pas 5y agoWhat'd be the best way to have reliable and clean peak capacity? Batteries (gravity or chemical)? So how come large consumers' usage is not shifted to smooth out the peak? (Or it's simply not enough or too unpractical?)
- pyrale 5y agoThat, however, is an economic decision unrelated to load following. Being able to load follow but deciding not to build the last plant that would be used 5% of the time is not the same as not being able to load follow, and being forced to have batteries or alternative production means. > France meets its peak electricity demands with fossil fuel generation, hydropower, and imports. Hydropower is used for peaks a lot, because France has a lot of reversible hydro, but fossil plants and imports aren't routinely used for peak use.
- Retric 5y agoTake a second look at those imports, they only did that when nuclear was unable to meat demand which was every single weekday. Exact numbers get tricky as they would export and import at the same time due to grid balancing still they needed to export ~1/5 of all nuclear power generated at a loss and import ~30+tWh just to meet demand. Even then utilization tells the story it was in the 60% range in 1988 while the US saw utilization in the 90% range, and again that’s with exporting below costs. Low utilization increased prices by about 30-50% depending on year and that’s with heavy dependence on fossil fuels and a relatively low percentage of nuclear consumption in the country. Nuclear simply doesn’t scale across an electric grid unless you want to more than double the price of electricity or provide subsidizes on that scale. Just look at what happens to the EU grid if Germany and every every other country outside off France was 1/3 nuclear.