3 ms·
> Jared Diamond posits the first theory, as well, in Guns, Germs, Steel. No, he doesn't. GGS explicitly rejects any sort of pseudo-racial theory of civilizatio
by woodruffw 5y ago
> Jared Diamond posits the first theory, as well, in Guns, Germs, Steel.
No, he doesn't. GGS explicitly rejects any sort of pseudo-racial theory of civilizational superiority. The entire book is a methodical dissection of why different regions experienced different paces of development in the pre-colonial era, with climate, geography, and endemic food species being the leading factors.
- beaconstudios 5y agoBut that's what I was saying as well - that civilisational development is not driven by some concept of racial traits, but that it's driven by material conditions.
- woodruffw 5y agoYes, I think we're on the same page. Racialized theories of civilization are, on face value, absurd (and, well, racist). GGS goes to significant lengths to debunk them, including thoroughly collapsing the racial categories that colonial and post-colonial Westerners use.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoI don't think they're absurd. Humans are tribal to the core of our being. Race matters, culturally, genetically, and is how we typically organized throughout history and even today. The Irish, French, and British are pretty similar racially but divide pretty significantly on the tiny differences in that race. To cast aside race as an arbitrary characteristic seems inaccurate view of reality. Race is one of the most important attributes that makes us human.
- chillacy 5y agoThe question of whether race or location is the causal factor seems to just be different dimensions of the same thing, no? Given that they pretty much correlate though most of history.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoNot if the same race relocates to a different location and has similar outcomes.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoIf you reread my comment I said Jared Diamond takes the first theory of resource abundance as the reason. It's still just a theory. It also begs the question of why African Am. and Latin peoples don't do well when integrated into western society statistically as a whole. Whereas Asians and Indians appear to do well. This is probably inappropriate conversation for a place like HN, so I'm bowing out. ;)
- woodruffw 5y agoSubstantively editing your comments is considered a faux pas on HN.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoAs long as someone doesn't change their point, if someone wants to make their comment more clear by simplifying phrasing or adding more detail or examples, it's fine by me. I'd rather a fleshed out idea than a off the cuff rough draft. That's actually one of the best parts of digital communication.