3 ms·
> are there are "hard" skills from an MBA that transfer? You are asking a genuine question that has a lot of backing research. Before I became a Quant, I was a
by dxbydt 5y ago
> are there are "hard" skills from an MBA that transfer?
You are asking a genuine question that has a lot of backing research. Before I became a Quant, I was a student at the University of Chicago, getting the Masters in Financial Math. So the professor who taught the Options course at MSFM told us one day - Now I have to teach this same material to the MBA class, but at a 10,000 feet level.
One of the students asked him to elaborate. So he says - If you have a scale of 1 to 100, with 100 being the hardest, then a UChicago Finance PhD is like 100. A UChicago MSFM is about 50. A UChicago MBA is like 10. A regular (non-UChicago) MBA is a 1.
More concretely, someone like me, the 50, can put up the Black Scholes on the blackboard from memory. I can derive it, solve it, code it up in C++ and price your options on a real equity & tell you whether you should buy/sell the damn thing. But that's as far as I was taught.
The Finance PhD i.e. the 100, can derive and solve not just the BS but a whole family of models - the Heston, Derman, SABR, BDT, HJM, HW etc etc - there's like a dozen of these PDEs & it gets seriously complicated very soon. So supposedly this Finance PhD can do all of that & more.
The UChicago MBA, which is the 10, knows Black Scholes, knows what the Greeks are & can eyeball the value of the Greek & tell you whether the option is overpriced or not, but can't derive/solve/code up the PDE.
The non-UChicago MBA has heard of something called the Black Scholes but that's about it.
Ofcourse that's his opinion & you should take it with a grain of salt. That said, during my time in the investment banking industry, I have worked with a boatload of MBAs, some quants(MSFMs) & a few PhDs - his opinions bore true.
- Moodles 5y agoMy experience too (in a completely different field to finance).
- in3d 5y agoThis sounds like something a biased physics professor who values his own field more than others could also say about teaching quantum computing to financial math students. You don't need more than an overview and it's hard. What percentage of MBAs will need to analytically solve PDEs?
- Moodles 5y agoOk. So to ask the original question again: are there any transferable hard skills in MBAs?