3 ms·

Internal chat history? I mean you literally can have history with your client if you choose. Discord famously is avoiding that very feature... You can also sha

Internal chat history? I mean you literally can have history with your client if you choose. Discord famously is avoiding that very feature... You can also share files through urls...

luckylion 5y ago
> I mean you literally can have history with your client if you choose. Unless you were not connected when the message was sent. > You can also share files through urls... You could also share them by mailing a usb drive. Both are a lot more annoying than just copy pasting them into a chat.
- noobermin 5y ago
  Have a bot connected to the channel that records the conversations to a text file and you have history. The bot can run anywhere if you don't want it to run on your own computer of course. Also, for pings to you if you want notifs bouncers exist, Also, people need to be a little more precise regarding sharing files. OP just said "share file" they didn't say host files or whatever. Often times the file I want to share isn't hosted or can be embedded (in the past I had to pass around multi-GB binary dumps and you can't embed that in slack and I definitely think you can't do that in discord).
  - dmitriid 5y ago
    > Have a bot connected to the channel that records the conversations to a text file and you have history. The bot can run anywhere if you don't want it to run on your own computer of course. Also, for pings to you if you want notifs bouncers exist Or, you know, just use a product that has all that built-in freeing you to do other things
MarcellusDrum 5y ago
Sharing files via URL while possible, is: 1) Impractical. You have to upload files to third party services that usually require an account. So you have to leave the chat, upload the file, and then get back to paste the link. 2) Bad integration. Some sites work better on mobile than others. Some barely work on slow internet connections. Some required logins, or show ads. And you have to leave the client just to see a GIF.
- smolder 5y ago
  1) Why do I want discord to have a perma-copy of everything I share? Where's the peer 2 peer file send? 2) Clients can auto integrate URLs, like IRCCloud. It works just as well as server side integration.

Internal chat history? I mean you literally can have history with your client if you choose. Discord famously is avoiding that very feature... You can also share files through urls...

luckylion 5y ago

> I mean you literally can have history with your client if you choose. Unless you were not connected when the message was sent. > You can also share files through urls... You could also share them by mailing a usb drive. Both are a lot more annoying than just copy pasting them into a chat.

noobermin 5y ago
Have a bot connected to the channel that records the conversations to a text file and you have history. The bot can run anywhere if you don't want it to run on your own computer of course. Also, for pings to you if you want notifs bouncers exist, Also, people need to be a little more precise regarding sharing files. OP just said "share file" they didn't say host files or whatever. Often times the file I want to share isn't hosted or can be embedded (in the past I had to pass around multi-GB binary dumps and you can't embed that in slack and I definitely think you can't do that in discord).
- dmitriid 5y ago
  > Have a bot connected to the channel that records the conversations to a text file and you have history. The bot can run anywhere if you don't want it to run on your own computer of course. Also, for pings to you if you want notifs bouncers exist Or, you know, just use a product that has all that built-in freeing you to do other things

MarcellusDrum 5y ago

Sharing files via URL while possible, is: 1) Impractical. You have to upload files to third party services that usually require an account. So you have to leave the chat, upload the file, and then get back to paste the link. 2) Bad integration. Some sites work better on mobile than others. Some barely work on slow internet connections. Some required logins, or show ads. And you have to leave the client just to see a GIF.

smolder 5y ago
1) Why do I want discord to have a perma-copy of everything I share? Where's the peer 2 peer file send? 2) Clients can auto integrate URLs, like IRCCloud. It works just as well as server side integration.