4 ms·
I recommend a book called "Selfish Reasons To Have More Kids" by Bryan Caplan. It's a short read, and very interesting. The basic argument is that we've turned
by lemming 5y ago
I recommend a book called "Selfish Reasons To Have More Kids" by Bryan Caplan. It's a short read, and very interesting. The basic argument is that we've turned modern parenting into a stressful chore, much as you describe. But by looking at separated twin studies, he argues that what we do as parents has much less impact on how our kids turn out than we would probably like to believe. Essentially, if your parenting is within decent normal parameters (i.e. there isn't an abusive situation or anything like that) your kids will probably turn out ok, and if they don't, it will probably not be because of anything you did.
This argument really goes against accepted wisdom, especially if you tend to the theory that your kids are malleable clay for you to shape as you wish. But intuitively, it makes a lot of sense. My brother and I were essentially raised in the same environment, and we could not be more different. So, which of us did my parents' input produce, and why didn't it work for the other one?
It seems counterintuitive, but embracing the idea that what you do doesn't make as much difference as you'd expect is very liberating. Like all parenting books, I'm sure some of the data is cherry picked to make a point so I take it with a grain of salt, but I've definitely changed my attitude as a result and it's made parenting much more pleasant. I'm not totally checked out, I'm still doing the best I can, but I'm not as anxious about how what I'm doing affects my daughter. Basically, it's much easier to enjoy the ride if you're not constantly stressing about what you're doing wrong, and counterintuitively (or not, perhaps) that has made me a better father.
- georgewsinger 5y agoI highly second this. Though if I were to critique Bryan's book, it would be to question whether he followed his own advice: https://www.econlib.org/our-homeschooling-odyssey/ https://www.econlib.org/our-homeschooling-odyssey/. You could argue that Bryan wrote a very persuasive book on why effortful parenting is a waste of time, and then proceeded to engage in a parenting campaign which put him in the top 0.0001% of "parental effort exerted"! To what extent does that mean he doesn't really believe what he wrote? I don't mean this to be a mean spirited question. I still think Bryan is an extremely persuasive , good faith author. Just wondering aloud how to explain this discrepancy.