3 ms·
As other commenters have pointed out, putting a penny across the prongs of a half-plugged-in phone charger will probably kill less than 1% of the kids who try i
by kragen 5y ago
As other commenters have pointed out, putting a penny across the prongs of a half-plugged-in phone charger will probably kill less than 1% of the kids who try it. In many cases it won't shock you at all, depending on exactly how you manipulate the penny, just make a big spark and trip the circuit breaker. In the cases where it does shock you, it usually won't be a dangerous shock, just a really nasty sensation in your hand.
In some cases, it will be fatal, either because your circuit breaker fails and you get a fireball, or because you manage to touch the penny to the live prong while standing barefoot on wet concrete or something. So making this suggestion to a lot of kids will probably kill a number of people. But, if you wanted to kill somebody, tricking them into trying this wouldn't be the way to do it.
- klipt 5y agoIt's probably not deliberate, but it is dangerous negligence, especially at Big Tech scales. If Alexa suggests this to 10,000 kids even a 1% chance could mean 100 deaths.
- kragen 5y agoI'm surprised this implication was so unclear in my original comment (which did, after all, say, "In some cases, it will be fatal") that you thought it needed saying, so I've edited the comment to make it more explicit. I'm sure it was deliberate on the part of whoever posted the original suggestion; perhaps they didn't expect kids to be reading it, or perhaps they just didn't care that some of them would die, or perhaps they didn't think the kids would really do it (like Soupy Sales: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/greenmail/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/greenmail/). Certainly Alexa is designed deliberately to give kids minimally filtered access to the internet memepool; probably that does a wide range of harms, and killing hundreds of kids isn't even the biggest one. It also does some good, although probably most of that good is undermined by the pervasive surveillance implicit in the platform.
- Bud 5y ago
- kragen 5y agoIn US law, I think it's "a failure to behave with the level of care that someone of ordinary prudence would have exercised under the same circumstances"? Perhaps you believe that this is not applicable, but you seem to be begging the question by implicitly accusing your interlocutor of believing that words do not have meanings, rather than making an argument for that position. I find that contemptible. Your comment is the kind of comment that makes me not want to comment on HN.
- Bud 5y agoInstead, I merely think that my interlocutor has perhaps not fully considered what negligence means, in this particular very complex context, and what it might take to fully avoid being judged as being "negligent", and how truly difficult that is. I think I have given my interlocutor a fair shake. Perhaps you do not. I respect that.
- kragen 5y agoYou still haven't given an argument that this doesn't amount to negligence.
- Bud 5y agoThat's easy enough to do: Alexa or any such system is extraordinarily complex and there are all kinds of edge cases that can be imagined where such a system might give out some stupid facts. As long as there is no evidence of recklessness, and as long as cases like this get corrected promptly (and Amazon did that), I can't see negligence here. Looking to a more codified legal definition of negligence comes out even more strongly in my favor, because there was no injury and no victim, here.
- userbinator 5y agoIn complete agreement; but the shock (no pun intended) of the experience will definitely instill some much-needed distrust of "that lady in the box", especially for those parents who still have the notion that corporations and governments can do no harm.
- kragen 5y agoThis is IMHO not a sufficient justification for killing children.
- kingcharles 5y agoAs someone who has lived his life through misadventure I can attest that you probably won't die from this. You might get a sore or shaking arm for an hour if you get a full belt from it. Just don't put the thing in your mouth. Otherwise you won't taste anything for a week. So I, er, heard.
- JohnWhigham 5y agoWouldn't be HN without our resident Big Tech apologists!