4 ms·
Is there evidence that these snake oil people: 1. Exist as a significant force? 2. Are being stopped by these restrictions? 3. Would do more harm than the FD
by roenxi 5y ago
Is there evidence that these snake oil people:
1. Exist as a significant force?
2. Are being stopped by these restrictions?
3. Would do more harm than the FDA promoting ignorance of blood glucose levels?
Because from a comfortable position in an armchair, that perspective seems to be extremely pessimistic about people's ability to make basic life choices. Pessimistic to the point where I don't see how society could function if it is in line with reality.
- ok_dad 5y agoRead the history of the FDA, my friend. They’re here for a reason. I’m not going to educate you on something you can Google (but probably won’t).
- ahmedalsudani 5y agoThere's no reason to be this snarky. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_and_Drug_Administration#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_and_Drug_Administration#H... I took you up on it regardless, and it doesn't have much to do with snake oil salesmen according to the Wikipedia article. Either way, nobody is arguing for the abolition of the FDA. The paternalistic attitude and restrictions are what the parent commenters have an issue with.
- ok_dad 5y agoDid you read it? Literally the FDA was created in response to snake oil remedies killing and injuring people. > By the 1930s, muckraking journalists, consumer protection organizations, and federal regulators began mounting a campaign for stronger regulatory authority by publicizing a list of injurious products that had been ruled permissible under the 1906 law, including radioactive beverages, the mascara Lash lure which caused blindness, and worthless "cures" for diabetes and tuberculosis. The resulting proposed law was unable to get through the Congress of the United States for five years, but was rapidly enacted into law following the public outcry over the 1937 Elixir Sulfanilamide tragedy, in which over 100 people died after using a drug formulated with a toxic, untested solvent. > President Franklin Delano Roosevelt signed the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act into law on June 24, 1938.
- ahmedalsudani 5y agoYes I did. That quote does not necessarily mean those cures were fraudulent--it could be pure incompetence. But again, the issue is not deciding what's safe and what's effective. It's finding that something is effective and then telling citizens they can't use effective treatments (or even tests) arbitrarily. I'm glad the FDA is testing the safety and effectiveness of tests and cures. That doesn't mean the grandparent commenter who wants to monitor their blood glucose levels should be dismissed.
- roenxi 5y agoBit of a difference between that and glucose monitoring machines though. I don't think anyone is comparing taking a glucose reading to ingesting radioactive beverages. I'm sure that someone could injure themselves really badly with a glucose monitor, but the risk profile probably isn't that different from the wide range of garden implements we let people run around with (like ladders or hedge clippers).
- bluGill 5y agoSure, just look at all the covid vaccine deniers. And all the cures promoted
- nine_k 5y ago1. Yes, look at the dietary supplements industry. (To say nothing of audiophile gear industry, but it's a different kettle of fish.) 2. Not stopped from selling stuff which efficacy is not proven. Still stopped from selling stuff which is known dangerous. 3. FDA is just enforcing a CYA policy here. It shifts all decisions to doctors who can decide to prescribe a device or a drug, and are personally accountable for malpractice. No administration wants to lose political points and votes because it allowed something obscure, that something led to an accident, and the accident was turned into a national-level scandal by rage-hungry media.
- spurgu 5y agoJust for the argument's sake, audiophile gear is by definition highly subjective and as such, it's the one area where pretty much every product could be defined as snake oil, haha. Regulating that would be a bureaucratic nightmare. Pregnancy/HIV/diabetes tests however should be rather easy to define baseline requirements/tolerances for. And drugs are somewhere in between.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoThere's a lot that is 100% provable snake oil. For 2 particularly egregious examples, see https://www.tomshardware.com/news/nvme-ssd-for-audiophiles https://www.tomshardware.com/news/nvme-ssd-for-audiophiles and https://www.tomshardware.com/news/ethernet-switch-for-audiophiles https://www.tomshardware.com/news/ethernet-switch-for-audiop....
- spurgu 5y agoWith the miniscule differences combined with the subjectivity of it all it's just really hard (or practically impossible) to prove that the developer/salesman actually doesn't hear a positive improvement. Audiophiles salesmen want to believe just as much as the customers. Disclaimer: Built speakers and amplifiers in a previous life and never understood how people would fret so much about cables.
- 5y ago
- smnrchrds 5y ago> Is there evidence that these snake oil people: 1. Exist as a significant force? Dietary supplements, homeopathic "medicine", chiropractic, essential oils, Goop and similar new age stuff ... Snake oil business is thriving and expanding if anything.