7 ms·
I've never understood what part of the crucifixion was a sacrifice. Jesus is literally a god. He knew he would end up on the cross before he even took on human
by criddell 5y ago
I've never understood what part of the crucifixion was a sacrifice. Jesus is literally a god. He knew he would end up on the cross before he even took on human form. He could have left at any time. He can return any time he wants. And how can his death on the cross be actually considered a death? If he was dead, are we to understand that for those few days there was no god overlooking all of creation?
It seems to me that Jesus allowing himself to be crucified is poetic but ultimately an empty gesture.
- alecbz 5y ago> He knew he would end up on the cross before he even took on human form. He could have left at any time. He can return any time he wants. Is any of this actually a part of Christian canon? It's not clear to me that by describing Jesus as "God", we're meant to understand that he's omniscient (is Yahweh/"The Father" God even omniscient in Christian canon?) or omnipotent with respect to his human form.
- riffraff 5y ago> is Yahweh/"The Father" God even omniscient in Christian canon? I think it is canon in all abrahamic religions, based on the fact that there's a ton of literature around how omniscience relates to free will (Boetius, Aquinas, Calvin etc).
- geoduck14 5y ago>He knew he would end up on the cross before he even took on human form. He could have left at any time. He can return any time he wants. The first Messianic prophy is in Genesis. "Eve's seed (Jesus) would crush the snake (satan)'s head. The snake would crush His heel (Jesus on the cross)" He could have left at anytime is evidenced when Jesus is in the garden in Gethsemane right before He was arrested - he had a legion of angels at His command. I'm not sure about "He can return anytime He wants." I'm going to chalk this one up to "He is God of the universe and do what He wants"
- xupybd 5y agoJesus was God in flesh. So God the father is separate but connected. ( I'm a little under qualified to describe the exact nature of the Holy Trinity) So God the father has always been looking over creation. After Jesus ascended to heaven the Holy Spirit was sent to help the church in place of Jesus her on earth. Jesus was God in flesh so he purposely limited himself to experience all that we experience, to suffer all that we suffer. There is nothing that He can't empathize with. There was also the spiritual law that had to be satisfied. The price of sin is death. Under the Mosaic covenant there were sacrificial animals used to pay that price. Jesus payed that price for all who are willing to take up their cross and follow him.
- omarfarooq 5y ago> Jesus was God in flesh so he purposely limited himself to experience all that we experience, to suffer all that we suffer. There is nothing that He can't empathize with. This implies that God is incapable of fully knowing the experience of humans without becoming human, hence God is not omniscient; since now his omniscience is contingent on becoming contingent.
- chernevik 5y agoNo. God already understood the human experience. He became human to prove to us, beyond all doubt, that He does understand.
- omarfarooq 5y ago"Beyond all doubt" is doubtful since, taking your assertions for granted, he only manifested himself to an infinitesimally small cross-section of humanity.
- theonething 5y agoI'm not sure I follow your argument. So because he only manifested himself to a relatively small number of people, he can't prove that he understands us? We have his teachings in writing. Do you only believe in knowledge that is personally manifested to you? If so, then you wouldn't believe in any history.
- jordanpg 5y agoIf I could choose a single word to characterize all of Christian theology it would have to be “underwhelming.”
- skinkestek 5y agoWarning, I'm not a specialist in this. My only qualifications is that Christianity has made me happy and I have read and listened a lot. > I've never understood what part of the crucifixion was a sacrifice. Jesus is literally a god. He knew he would end up on the cross before he even took on human form. All the more agony. (See also below.) > He could have left at any time. Yep, but as far as I understand then it wouldn't have been valid. As far as I understand it seems he knew he had one chance. My best explanation is he went to create a way for us and it wouldn't have been much worth if he did it in "cheat mode"? > He can return any time he wants. See above. > And how can his death on the cross be actually considered a death? True God and true human. According to the sources we have he suffered badly. > If he was dead, are we to understand that for those few days there was no god overlooking all of creation? According to the common translations Jesus prayed to God and speaks of himself as something else than God. I'm not very knowledgeable in theoretical theology but this isn't controversial at all to most people who consider themselves Christian I think. Also death is just the death of the body.
- geoduck14 5y agoI'd like to add some things: There are some that suggest Jesus did A LOT during the 3 days he "was dead". He went to hell. The phrase "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me" suggests he was spiritually separate from God the father - a fate worse than physical death. He delivered previously dead Jews to heaven He poured His blood out on a replica temple in heaven as THE lamb sacrifice for everyone who accepted His sacrifice. This is a LITERAL sacrifice - separate from "being human for 30 years sacrifice". Keep in mind that Jesus is the High Priest, he is THE person to make sacrifice for sins, and he is also THE object that was killed for those sins.
- sam0x17 5y agoI always found this whole bit farcical. Firstly, if God is the one who exercises judgement in the first place in the form of who goes to heaven and who does not, then (as is written elsewhere in the Bible) what God says is good, is good, and what God says is bad, is bad, for no intrinsic reason other than God says it is so. When I do the good, I want to do it because I have some stock in the moral value or principle being maximized, not because some deity arbitrarily commanded it. Secondly, if God is the source of all moral judgement, then he could just arbitrarily decree that repentance is now a thing instead of making Jesus suffer for our sins. In the same breath Christians assert that moral values come from God (if God says it is good, it is good, if God says it is bad, it is bad), but that Jesus had to suffer, to what, to make God decide to be more lenient with how he interprets our sins? How is that supposed to be inspiring? Makes God seem sadistic more than anything. But then when God contradicts his own moral values (i.e. murder in some of the old parables) Christians of course once again say no, this isn't immoral because God says it is not. Which is it? Either morality is whatever God says it is, and Jesus dying on the cross served absolutely no purpose, or God is a sinner and cannot/should not contradict his own moral tenants (but does because there is no one there to "judge" him), in which case Jesus dying on the cross makes some sense because morality is some force above and more powerful than god.
- chernevik 5y agoGod created Time and does not experience it as we do. There is a school of thought that says that, for God, all times are _now_ -- there is no difference between past, present or future. All are equally "present" to Him. In this frame, the Crucifixion is happening _now_. Jesus, as a man, is suffering and dying at this very moment. As humans experience time, He always will be. It seems to me that, for any entity, this eternal experience is a very significant sacrifice.
- sam0x17 5y agoAn entity that experiences all of time at the same time would be pretty used to suffering, as all suffering that has ever and will ever occur is experienced by this entity all the time, so hardly a sacrifice. Jesus's suffering is a small drop in an ocean of suffering experienced at all times by such an entity.
- hermitcrab 5y agoYou are trying apply a rational argument to faith, which is inherently irrational.
- theonething 5y agoI'm not sure I agree with your assertion that faith is inherently irrational, but I will say this: All people everywhere live by faith. This is because no one can know the future. You get in your car and drive to work. You are going by faith that you won't get killed in a car crash. Why do I know this? Because if you knew you would be killed, you wouldn't get in the car. You don't know. But you get in your car anyways, hoping by faith (probably subconsciously) you won't get killed. By faith, I look at the evidence and believe God exists. By faith, someone else looks at the evidence (or lack thereof) and concludes He doesn't. I can't know for sure if I'm correct. The other person is in the same position. When we die, we'll know (technically, if the atheist is correct, we won't know anything at all). Good luck!