4 ms·
They have been experimented with for decades (I remember reading about 1970s prototypes as a kid in the 80s) but I believe it's stalled on energy density, very
by acdha 5y ago
They have been experimented with for decades (I remember reading about 1970s prototypes as a kid in the 80s) but I believe it's stalled on energy density, very similar to batteries. In aircraft, the big factor is storage: if you had a robust storage system you could get more power from burning the hydrogen in a turbine but hydrogen is hard to store safely without very heavy containers.
- torginus 5y agoI remember the Soviets converted a plane for hydrogen combustion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-155 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-155 But I feel that's a bit of a distraction - turbines must use thermodynamic cycles to convert fuel into thrust - something whose maximum efficiency is less than the real world efficiency of a hydrogen fuel cell. I feel like hydrogen turbofans are not practical for small craft for a number of reasons - cost, maintenance, noise, limited start/stop cycles etc., while electrics have the ability to scale to every aircraft category.
- baybal2 5y agoThe maximum efficiency hydrogen to electricity conversion is around on around 50% for real world fuel cells. This is around efficiency of GE90. Your idea will not work. Hydrogen storage, cells, and motors will weights many times the jet engine, or a plane itself
- ncmncm 5y agoAn LH2 tank hardly weighs anything. They even put them in rockets. But they take up more room than would fit in the wings. They probably would need to be in nacelles slung under the wings like the engines.
- acdha 5y agoI'm aware that rockets have them but we have much stronger safety standards for passenger airplanes than we do for rockets. What I've heard is that it's very hard to build a hydrogen tank which is both lightweight and safe enough in the event of a crash or other incident to meet general civilian aviation standards. I'd love to be wrong on that but given the obvious appeal there must be some thorny engineering challenges for an idea which has been batted around since the 1950s.
- ncmncm 5y agoYou are hearing confused echoes. The high-pressure hydrogen tanks needed for H2-fueled cars and trucks are difficult, in a place where using LH2 instead would be wholly impractical. LH2 tanks of a size appropriate for transport aircraft are trivial: thin-walled aluminum shrouded in insulation. LH2 for transport aircraft suffers none what would make it impractical for cars: it is always used immediately, and would be synthesized on demand right at the airport. Risk of exploding leaks is easily eliminated by positive ventilation; if it can't build up, it can't ignite; if it doesn't ignite, it can't explode. In nacelles attached to the wing, alongside the engines, any extra safety concerns would be moot. Kerosene fuel is carried in wing tanks so that the wings shear off in a very bad landing and take the fuel away with them. A whole separate tank shears off much more easily than a wing.