7 ms·
Rack 2 (Virtual Eurorack)
- fartcannon 5y agoAll I can say is wow. Looks great.
- capableweb 5y agoWould have been better to submit https://vcvrack.com/news/2021-11-30-Rack-2-released https://vcvrack.com/news/2021-11-30-Rack-2-released since it goes through the new features. Also, not sure why the full name is not in the submission title? (VCV Rack)
- oarsinsync 5y agoHaving multiple links would be helpful here, so I've upvoted yours in the hopes it stays near or at the top. In a place like this, I'd rather see the source code as the headline link, rather than a press release, but the press release is still valuable.
- SweetLullaby 5y agoagree!
- borepop 5y agoOr just https://vcvrack.com/ https://vcvrack.com/ ? I don't understand the impulse on HN to make everything as technical as possible.
- capableweb 5y agoVCV Rack has been featured a lot of times on HN (https://hn.algolia.com/?q=vcv+rack https://hn.algolia.com/?q=vcv+rack), and judging by the "2" in the submission title, I think OP wanted to highlight the new version that was just released, hence appropriate to link to the release logs instead. > I don't understand the impulse on HN to make everything as technical as possible. Well, it is called "Hacker News" and hackers tend to be technical, kind of makes sense.
- klinskyc 5y agoSaw this, thought it was a new version of the Ruby server, and got excited. Synths are cool too though!
- fredoliveira 5y agoVCV Rack is such a wonderful piece of software. And I'm glad that eurorack manufacturers are using it as a bit of a testing ground too. Lots of people are priced out of hardware modular synthesis, so getting Rack is a solid way to dip ones toes into that world. I'm unaffiliated, but highly recommend Rack if you're curious about modular.
- abletonlive 5y agoI used to have >$3000 worth of modular and think VCV rack is great. It gets you completely into the modular world. Dipping toes is like saying pigments or vital is dipping your toes into synthesis. It's just jumping right into the ocean honestly. Hardware generally slows down my workflow to a crawl. There's no beating the convenience of bouncing digital instruments. Especially for sound design. If you want a new sound with modular hardware and want to reuse your modules, you're getting rid of your existing patch. There's nothing more limiting than feeling like you can't use your gear because the patch it's currently configured for is too good to change. That works for some people but not for me.
- papandada 5y agoSo am I correct in concluding that you sold a bunch of your modular hardware and continue to use mainly software now? If so what software do you use besides VCV rack and what if any other (non-modular) hardware do you use
- fredoliveira 5y agoBased on their username, I suspect Ableton Live is one such piece of software (it's the main DAW I personally use, and absolutely love it).
- abletonlive 5y agoMy setup slowly changes as the years progress but things are generally pretty simple. Right now the only hardware I have is a RME Babyface Pro FS, an arturia polybrute, an ableton push2, and Neumann KH310 monitors and the KH750 DSP subwoofer. In the past I've owned the Moog SUB37 CV and an endless list of eurorack hardware. Software most frequently used: All the stuff that comes bundled in with Ableton Live Suite (their plugins are amazing, don't sleep on it - just because it comes w/ your DAW doesn't mean it sucks), Arturia pigments, Vital (also free, better than serum in my opinion), u-he Diva. For compressors I'm really using Ableton's stock compressor and glue compressor mostly but reach for DMG TrackComp a lot. Fabfilter Saturn2 for saturation.
- 999900000999 5y ago100$ isn't a ton of money, but I'd love to test the VST without buying it. I'll try to checkout the standalone later .
- _fzslm 5y agocardinal [0] may be of interest to you [0] https://github.com/DISTRHO/Cardinal https://github.com/DISTRHO/Cardinal
- bambax 5y agoCardinal is absolutely fantastic. It's advertised as a "work in progress" but already works really great. You can download frequent builds in Github actions / artifacts; they are available for almost all platforms. The limitation is it comes with its own modules (most open source modules available for VCV) and you can't load external modules. But it's already super powerful. Highly recommended.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoIt is important to understand the reason for the limitation(s). Cardinal is intended to be usable just like a conventional plugin, which includes having presets that can be exchanged between computers (or even between users). If Cardinal allowed arbitrary modules to be loaded, there's no guarantee that when the preset was used on a different computer or by a different user it would work, because modules could be missing. One idea for Cardinal is to be able to build "synths" with it, and then represent the result as a preset that could be used anywhere. The regular Rack plugin version doesn't have this as an explicit goal, and therefore it can allow arbitrary modules to be loaded. You can certainly have presets, but there's no way to ensure that any context in which you use the presets have all the required modules.
- bambax 5y agoThe reasons given on the readme seem to be more technical than functional/practical: > A proper audio plugin should be self-contained as much as possible, as to not interfere with the DAW/Host. (...) A self-contained plugin can't be overstated, as DLL/shared-object symbol conflicts can trigger hard-to-debug crashes. I'm fine with the limitations, and like the idea of a self-contained plugin that does not phone home. And in my experience, Cardinal is already very solid and feature-complete, even in its beta form. But one could absolutely imagine a system where you can share setups that use modules that may or may not be available. For instance, you can build, save and share combinators in Reason that use non-standard REs.
- Cyclical 5y agoWonderful to see this finally get released. A lot of people (myself included) have been awaiting with bated breath for 2 full years for VCV Rack 2. It impresses me to this day that Andrew Belt is the sole developer on the project. He's been able to do something tremendous in a relatively short amount of time for just one guy.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWhile what Andrew did in code is great, what I think has been even more impressive than that is to have created, sustained and nurtured a community, an API and an ecosystem that has in turn allowed hundreds of other people to construct the modules that actually make Rack what it is. I'm not too jealous of the code accomplishments, but the ecosystem is a really strong envy point for me.
- spankalee 5y agoWhy don't they take contributions? They couldn't do a CLA?
- myself248 5y agoThe audio world yearns for a VCV competitor with a genuine community rather than a serfdom.
- dmicah 5y agoThere should just be a standard for a software module, like VST for plug-in instruments. Then they could re-used across platforms, and a DAW like Ableton could theoretically host them directly without needing an intermediary VST host app like Rack.
- squeaky-clean 5y agoI believe the new CLAP plugin format U-He and Bitwig have recently released is an attempt at this and a few other benefits plugins have been lacking for a while.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoCLAP (like every other audio/MIDI plugin API) does not cover single-sample processing, which one of the core design ideas in Rack's module API. And as an aside, CLAP has almost nothing in it that LV2 didn't already offer, and nothing that could not have been added to LV2 using the extension mechanism, but a rather severe case of NIH pushed things in the direction that they eventually went. It's quite unfortunate.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThis is a misunderstanding of the difference between a DAW and a host like Rack. Rack performs single-sample processing. DAWs (all of them) use block-structured processing. For a DAW to host modules that are designed for single-sample processing would always require an intermediary. It might as well be Rack.
- icambron 5y agoQuestion for music folks (I've played with modular synths but only in a superficial, toying-around way): is this skeuomorphic paradigm really the best way to do this? With a physical system, running wires everywhere might be the only way to do it, but it seems like in software you have more options on how you manage to connect all your components together, and how those components are laid out on the screen. But since this tangle-of-wires design is popular, perhaps it really is the way to go?
- dmicah 5y agoNo, but there were already other software synthesis options available for people who don't want a skeuomorphic interface, as various levels of complexity - Max/MSP, PureData, Reaktor, CSound, SuperCollider, Audulus, KarmaFX, etc.
- Applejinx 5y agoI don't think so. The project that got my love was Bespoke, which is node-based but not skeuomorphic :) Right now I'm polishing a hybrid system, with hardware Eurorack coming into Bespoke through multichannel audio.
- papandada 5y agoOnly a partial answer because I never get around to digging into it myself, but there is at least one other paradigm out there, "live coding", such as supercollider, csound, uh, more I'm sure.
- martyvis 5y agoSonic Pi and Chuck are two others
- tomcam 5y agoAbsolutely not, in my opinion. And I was using those rack systems 50 years ago when it was all they had. For a good UI try Korg Gadget 2 on iOS.
- 5y ago
- aspenmayer 5y agoSome context from a third party VCV Rack plugin developer: > The last straw concerned the policy about taking over inactive modules. About making it possible by default for someone to take over my very name, Aria Salvatrice, and releasing their own fork of my software under my name. > That’s right: if I’m inactive for just one short little month, someone else can just go ahead and release software under my name, my name as a person, with no process in place for me to reclaim it later, even if their releases have low quality standards, even if they add ill-conceived features that work against my long-term plans. > It would be easier to continue my work if there existed a healthier fork to migrate to, but VCV has been trying to prevent forks both through legal and social means, so there’s no viable fork yet. > There’s MiRack[0][1], a fork of VCV for Mac OS and iPhone. Any mention of it within the VCV community is immediately deleted, and its author is banned, so it exists completely disconnected from the VCV community, despite offering a smaller selection of the same modules with mobile support, which is something the community really wanted badly. Being only for Apple devices makes it impractical for me to use, so moving my development to it isn’t an option, unfortunately, if it were on PC I might have done that. https://aria.dog/barks/why-i-will-never-create-modules-for-vcv-rack-anymore/ https://aria.dog/barks/why-i-will-never-create-modules-for-v... Discussed on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27032669 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27032669 [0] https://mirack.app/ https://mirack.app/ [1] https://github.com/miRackModular https://github.com/miRackModular
- StyloBill 5y agoWow. Thank you for bringing perspective, I wasn't aware of Aria's work (which is absolutely incredible) and of what's happening behind the scenes of VCV. It's very disappointing as the product is amazing and lowers the barrier to entry to the eurorack ecosystem.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI cam across Aria's complaints about their experience as a developer within the Rack ecosystem, and I was very disappointed to read it. It made me reevaluate what I thought about Rack and Andrew's handling of the project. However, somebody then gave me a link to what is apparently one of the main threads [0] in which they and Andrew Belt's main developer "got into it", and after reading that I was much less certain about who was behaving badly here (if anyone). [0] https://community.vcvrack.com/t/do-open-source-plugins-need-to-be-submitted-to-the-vcv-library-by-its-original-developers/11357 https://community.vcvrack.com/t/do-open-source-plugins-need-... Regarding the MiRack fork ... I am not certain, but I suspect that this author acted in specific ways that upset Andrew. I talk regularly to the developer of Cardinal (mentioned below), which is another fork of Rack, and thus far, things between them and Andrew have remained reasonably cordial. Certainly as the developer of another open source audio project, if someone behaved the way the MiRack developer seems to have done [1], I would likely seek to exclude them from our community too. [1] I stress the seems because it really is not entirely clear what took place.
- indigochill 5y agoI'm curious about the pros/cons of Rack vs Reaktor. A Reddit comparison says VCV is better for modular by a mile, but not exactly why. Is it that it has a better library of modules? Or is more focused on emulating hardware modules than Reaktor is?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoA much bigger library of modules with a lot more funky ideas about module function and operation.
- strenholme 5y agoSince some people don’t like the cathedral development style VCV rack uses, I point people to a fork of an older version of VCV rack with two features VCV rack 2 doesn’t have: * It can run as a VST plugin, so one can use it with their favorite digital audio workstation (DAW) * The code is BSD licensed Here is that VST plugin fork: https://github.com/bsp2/VeeSeeVSTRack#downloads https://github.com/bsp2/VeeSeeVSTRack#downloads
- jerrysievert 5y agosome context from a third party vcv rack developer, who has not yet left the scene. while I agree with Aria's assessments[0], and respect Aria; their unhappiness is only focused on the founder (Andrew). I respect what Andrew has built, but unfortunately, the environment that he fostered has sprung up others that are 100x more toxic than Andrew himself on his worst days. Unfortunately, there are others that actively attack every other developer and module in the ecosystem, constantly claiming that theirs are the only "good" modules (while claiming they've left behind rack completely). it makes for an extremely toxic environment that has driven many more away. I think that until there are enforced community standards, it will just get worse, and drive more talented developers away. I know that I don't bother participating in the Facebook groups, reddit, discord, or the "official" rack forum because of these people. so, for those who have emailed and asked why my modules aren't yet ported: they have been lower priority compared to other things, given the extremely toxic people in the community who make it really frustrating to build anything, since there will be immediate attacks for anything new by extremely toxic individuals. [0] https://aria.dog/barks/why-i-will-never-create-modules-for-vcv-rack-anymore/ https://aria.dog/barks/why-i-will-never-create-modules-for-v...