5 ms·
Arthur Clarke apparently had some beef with Christianity all his writing life, but sometimes he went as bitter as this.
by nine_k 5y ago
Arthur Clarke apparently had some beef with Christianity all his writing life, but sometimes he went as bitter as this.
- dotancohen 5y agoInterestingly, his equally-aethiest contemporary Asimov accepted the role of religion in people's lives. I forget which book, but Asimov mentions friendly teasing between himself and a religious friend in one of the prefaces. Something about moving the Bible back out of the Fiction section of his personal library.
- southpawflo 5y agoI vaguely remember something along those lines as well, perhaps about C. S. Lewis and the Narnia series? It's been a while though.
- ud_0 5y agoCould you elaborate a bit on what you mean by "as bitter as this"? Reading the story with no context, it seems almost reverential to Christianity: We're in the far future and space-faring humans still worship the old religion(s). A supernova that occurred roughly during the time of a key event in the religion's history turned out to have killed off another distant civilization. There is an observation that bad things can happen to good civilizations and how that doesn't square with a benevolent creator deity. Do you perceive one of these as harsh criticism or was there some other issue in the text that I missed?
- nine_k 5y agoHere he basically accuses God of destroying a beautiful and desperate world to produce the light show at the Christ's birth time on Earth. I don't see much reverence in this, just a recognition of power, like that a powerful villain might have.
- pantalaimon 5y agoHow can he accuse one who does not exist? The story merely describes a cosmic catastrophe, that some people in a primitive tribe that had not discovered science yet would interpret as a sign of god, much like lightning. And the irony that this event that became so central to this religion was in fact a stellar cataclysm that had nothing to do with earth.
- knolan 5y agoHe’s not accusing god of anything, he’s pointing out that what one primitive civilisation saw as a sign from some supernatural being was a cosmic event with local consequences for another civilisation. He also shows how those beliefs, which in part survive from that early civilisation, are dissonant with our understanding of the universe. It’s like a child’s belief that heaven sits on the clouds flying in a aeroplane for the first time.
- boxed 5y agoHave you read the Bible? It's full of stuff like this. The story of the children who teased a priest so God sent a bear to kill them is a good example.
- arunix 5y agoI had to look that one up. To be fair, the text says that the two bears attacked 42 boys after Elisha cursed the boys, and doesn't mention if the attack was fatal. https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/k/kjv/kjv-idx?type=DIV1&byte=1531400 https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/k/kjv/kjv-idx?type=DIV1&byte=... (2 Kings 2, 24)
- deknos 5y agowell, as i understand it, it is the star of betlehem which showed humanity that its saviour is born, the saviour which saves mankind and with that god destroyed another sentient species which is very similar to us. how would you feel about that, if your believesystem said a genocide of another race of sentient, potentially benevolent people by god had to happen, so that you get the message your saviour came around?
- boxed 5y agoThe same god who also required a human sacrifice (which was also sort of himself) to back away from his own cruelty? Seems totally congruent.
- Sharlin 5y agoThis is something I've never understood.Are there any reasonable theological arguments for why he had to resort to what amounts to an elaborate ploy, in order to work around his own arbitrary rules of who gets saved?
- jbeninger 5y agoA character asks that question in Hyperion, by another sci-fi author (Dan Simmons). The answer he arrived at was that God was not testing Abraham. He was allowing Abraham to test God. When God stayed his hand at the last moment, he knew that he'd met a god worth following. (I'm not religious myself, but I did find this to be an interesting-enough interpretation to parrot it back to you on a web forum)
- Sharlin 5y agoNo, I was talking about Jesus (I believe the GP was as well). The Jesus situation is an interesting inversion of the Abraham dilemma though. This time God is prepared to sacrifice his own son – but we sort of failed the test by design, executing the sacrifice as planned even though we could have just let Jesus live. Not sure what it says about us or God.
- viktorcode 5y agoI don't think it is bitterness. What really interesting is the idea he put forth: maybe you could find Bethlehem star out there, in space. I think that's brilliant.
- mikehotel 5y ago“God has no need to justify His actions to man. He who built the Universe can destroy it when He chooses. It is arrogance—it is perilously near blasphemy—for us to say what He may or may not do.” Possibly taken out of context from the linked document.
- hungryforcodes 5y ago"Some beef". A lot of science types dislike religion in general -- or is this a surprise to you.